Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published bySheryl Curtis Modified over 9 years ago
2
The Future The Future Evaluate Skill NOT Style Performance Measurement Performance Measurement And Attribution
3
Luck?? Skill?? Back to Basics
4
Luck?? If you don’t know the problem, you can’t fix it. Old Approaches Don’t Work Old Approaches Don’t Work Skill?? = Style??
5
Off-the-shelf Benchmark Portfolio Results Performance Analysis 1980’s Slicer & Dicer Sector Size Yield P/E
6
Luck Skill Bridge the Gap Is Your Manager Lucky or Skillful? Is Your Manager Lucky or Skillful?
7
Style Matters
8
IS Past IS Prologue: Information Ratios and Sortino Omegas PERSIST * * Gruber(96), Stewart(98), Rudd & Kahn(99,00,01), Ibbotson(01) Getting WHY’s MPT, PMPT, APT, RBSA… Market and Style effects dominate Style-&-market-adjusted success/failure persists Signal / Noise
9
The difference between Style and Skill Styles go in & out of favor Skill persists
10
TheCostOfConfusion
11
Attribution Attribution Against Custom Style Blend Sources of Return Returns or Holdings StyleAnalysis Value Core Growth
12
Evolution of Attribution Evolution of Attribution
13
Value Growth Core Portfolio Custom Benchmark Skill Style Today’s Craft Today’s Craft
14
Sample Analysis of Skill & Style Sample Analysis of Skill & Style
15
A Close Look at Style Effects
16
A Closer Look at Style Effects
17
Details Sector Allocation & Stock Selection Attribution
18
Sector Allocation Custom Style Benchmark Fund Allocation
19
Sector Allocation & Stock Selection Fund Returns Style Opportunities Custom Style Benchmark
20
Attribution
22
Style Matters
23
Style Allocation & Performance
24
Trends Style Allocation Sector Allocation Cumulative Performance Cum Sources of Value Added – Persistence Relative Performance
25
Style Allocation History $
26
Mid Growth Mid Core Mid Value Large Growth Large Core Large Value $
27
Sector Allocation Technology Finance Non-Durables Health $
28
Cumulative Growth Fund Market Style Ranks
29
Consistent Sources of Value Added The Best Picture
30
Sources of Value Added -- Persistence Stock Selection Sector Allocation Activity
31
Sources of Value Added -- Persistence Stock Selection Sector Allocation Activity
32
Benefits Identify Skillful Investment Managers Risk Control (MDAs) Global Hedge Funds
33
Talent Contest Made Easy Talent Contest Made Easy Style-adjusted Winners of the Style-adjusted Performance Race Reasons for Win Confirm People, Process, Philosophy
34
Equity Diversification Equity Diversification Sector : Technology, Consumer, Health Care Characteristics: Capitalization, P/E, yield, R-squared
35
Equity Diversification Equity Diversification Sector : Technology, Consumer, Health Care Characteristics: Capitalization, P/E, yieldStyle
36
Extensions Global Hedge Funds
37
Hedge Funds Leverage Direction Amount long & amount shortStyle
38
Off-the-shelf Benchmark Portfolio Results The Past
39
Value Growth Core Portfolio Custom Benchmark Skill Style The Future The Future
40
No standardization in sight, but… Style Indexes
41
Style Effects (Holdings or Returns-Based) Style Effects (Holdings or Returns-Based) Growth Core Value
42
Some Suggested Criteria Mutually Exclusive : Multicollinearity/ Holdings Reports Exhaustive (Includes everything): Fit/ Holdings Reports Regular Rebalancing : Adjust to Change Core : Value-Growth Compromise
43
Surz Style Definitions Capitalization Large : Top 65% of $s Mid : Next 30% Small : Bottom 5% E/P + y + B/P Value : Top 40% Core : Middle 20% Growth : Bottom 40% Rebalanced Quarterly
44
Research Caution Popularity Popularity is not is notNecessarily Synonymous with Quality Quality
45
Mobius Research Candidates : Russell, Surz, Pru, Wilshire, Vestek Fundamental : All win except Wilshire Tracking error : Surz & Russell Multicollinearity : Surz Coverage : Surz & Russell
46
IMCA Research Candidates : Barclays, Barra, Dow Jones, IIA, OakBrook, Parametric, Prudential, Russell, S&P, Salomon, Surz, Wilshire Criterion : Best Average Fit ( Adjusted R 2 ) Separate Account Winners: Russell, Surz, S&P/BGI Mutual Fund Winners: Russell, Surz, Wilshire
47
FREE Surz Stuff is FREE www.PPCA-Inc.com
48
The Future Style matters Returns-based complements holdings-based Evaluate Style
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.