1. ASEE ENGINEERING DEANS INSTITUTE 1 Josh Thomases Deputy Chief Academic Officer for Instruction NYC Department of Education

2. Class of NYC Calculation MethodNY State Calculation Method Notes: NYC traditional calculation includes Local and Regents Diplomas, GEDs, Special Education diplomas, and August graduates. It does not include disabled students in self-contained classrooms or District 75 students. The NYS calculation, used since 2005, includes Local and Regents Diplomas and all disabled students. It does not include GEDs and Special Education diplomas. * Final year NYS did not include August graduates. AFTER REMAINING NEARLY FLAT FOR 10 YEARS, NYC’S GRADUATION RATE HAS INCREASED BY 41 PERCENT SINCE 2005 1992-2001: +0% (City Calculation) 2002-2011: +39% (City Calculation) 2005 to 2011: +40.9% (State Calculation) * 2

3. MORE NEW YORK CITY STUDENTS ARE COLLEGE- READY THAN A DECADE AGO College Readiness % of Students in Cohort Graduating College- Ready** AP Performance # of Students Passing at least 1 Exam*** CUNY Enrollment # of DOE Graduates**** Enrolling at CUNY as First-time Freshmen Increase 2005–12: +10 pts.Increase 2002–12: +87%Increase 2002–11: +62% *August graduate data is only available for the classes of 2008–11. **According to the Progress Report College Readiness Index, which is defined as the percentage of students who met the 2012 CUNY standards for passing out of remedial coursework. According to the Progress Reports’ 2012 definition, 29% of students are College Ready when you include results on the ACT and the CAT. ***2002 data are from the College Board’s 2004 College Bound Seniors Report. College Board updates its historic data annually to adjust for revised data on students. Data reported are the most recent comprehensive information available to the NYCDOE; 2012 data are from the College Board's 2012 College Bound Seniors Report. ****Includes all students who, when they enroll in the fall, report to CUNY that they have graduated from a NYC high school at any point in time. Source: CUNY Office of Institutional Research and Assessment. Graduation Rates % of Cohort Graduating in 4 years* Increase 2005–11: +19 pts. 3

4. White Students Asian Students Hispanic Students Black Students FOUR-YEAR GRADUATION RATES INCREASED FROM 2005-2011 ACROSS ETHNICITY GROUPS 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 Note: Totals reflect data available at the time of reporting provided by NYS; August graduate data is only available for years 2008-2011 The overall rate may not equal the sum of each diploma type due to rounding. Regents and Advanced Regents Local Diploma 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 +25.0% +57.8% +50.6% +23.3% 20052011 7,7507,818 20052011 10,47715,896 20052011 9,68218,192 20052011 6,5019,925 40.1 42.9 47.8 55.9 60.6 57.8 60.4 37.4 40.1 43.5 53.3 55.9 58.2 59.0 66.3 67.1 71.8 77.6 80.1 82.4 82.9 64.0 66.8 69.0 74.8 76.5 78.2 78.9 4

5. A college and career ready racial gap for males exists at all 8 th grade ELA proficiency levels Grade 8 ELA Proficiency Level (2006) *College Readiness as defined by APM “English/Math APM” (Aspirational Performance Measures) which includes students who scored 80 or higher on a Regents examination in mathematics and 75 or higher on the English Regents examination. Totals reflect data available at the time of reporting provided by NYSED; August graduate data available for 2010. **Students with no score are those who were not enrolled in the DOE in 8th grade. Percent of Males achieving College Readiness in 2010 after 4 Years of High School* RACE IS A PREDICTOR OF COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS 5

6. Percent of Males achieving College Readiness in 2010 after 4 Years of High School* Grade 8 Math Proficiency Level (2006) *College Readiness as defined by APM “English/Math APM” (Aspirational Performance Measures) which includes students who scored 80 or higher on a Regents examination in mathematics and 75 or higher on the English Regents examination. Totals reflect data available at the time of reporting provided by NYSED; August graduate data available for 2010. **Students with no score are those who were not enrolled in the DOE in 8th grade. A college and career ready racial gap for males exists at all 8 th grade Math proficiency levels RACE IS A PREDICTOR OF COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS 6

7. 7 White Male Students 05 06 07 08 09 10 Asian Male Students Hispanic Male Students Black Male Students The number of male students achieving the English/Math Regents-based Aspirational Performance Measure 05 06 07 08 09 10 NYS Percent of 4-Year Cohort achieving English/Math APM (Note: 2009 & 2010 includes August grads) 44.8 10.3 8.7 35.4 Note: Totals reflect data available at the time of reporting provided by NYS; August graduate data is only available for years 2009-2010. NO MATTER THE INDICATOR, BLACK AND LATINO YOUNG MEN ARE NOT READY FOR COLLEGE

8. NEW YORK CITY IS FOCUSED ON STRENGTHENING STUDENT WORK AND TEACHER PRACTICE 88 * New York is part of a consortium of states, the Partnership for the Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC), working together to develop new state assessments.  New York State adopts Common Core standards  New York State passes Education Law 3012-c 2009-10  New York State assesses Common Core in grades 3-8  DOE recommends Common Core-aligned curriculum materials  All schools implement citywide instructional expectations 2012-13 2014-15  New York City students take State PARCC* assessments 2010-11  New York City launches Common Core pilots in 100 schools  Teacher Effectiveness Pilot begins with 20 schools and over 700 teachers 2011-12  All schools implement citywide instructional expectations 2013-14  New York State assesses Common Core in Algebra I, Geometry, ELA Regents  All schools implement citywide instructional expectations  Implementation of Education Law 3012-c citywide, pending agreement

9. CTE IS A KEY LEVER FOR COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS IN NEW YORK CITY CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT – for discussion only 9 1905-1960: 18 CTE high schools opened Large schools with multiple career tracks National standouts and industry pipelines: Aviation, Fashion Industries 1960-2003: no new CTE high schools opened Rise of “college for all” approach to education served to stigmatize “voc ed” as dumping ground for less able students 2004-today: 28 new CTE schools have opened Smaller and more focused; easier to align with industry Return to notion of high school as career exploration opportunity; aligned to workplace competencies that employers value Key input to industry pipelines and local economic development Focus on college and career There are 38 designated Career and Technical Education high schools in New York City, serving approximately 26,000 students annually.

10. CTE POSITIONS STUDENTS FOR POSTSECONDARY SUCCESS Three components of CTE practice in NYC align to federal and local policy guidance, as articulated in the USDOE April 2012 CTE Blueprint for Reauthorization of the Carl D. Perkins Act (VTEA) and 2008 NYC Mayoral Task Force on CTE Innovation Report CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT – for discussion only 10 Skill Foundation Students work towards a CTE-endorsed Regents Diploma including industry recognized certification Work Experience Student understands industry, including relationship of education to advancement, and a meaningful experience within the workplace in which s/he demonstrates specific abilities and general workplace competencies (“soft skills”) External Validation Building upon his/her accomplishments and experiences, the student/jobseeker can leverage personal and institutional endorsements from individuals or organizations that can vouch for the value this individual adds to the workplace

11. NEW YORK CITY HAS OPENED 11 ENGINEERING- FOCUSED CTE PROGRAMS CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT – for discussion only 11 The 11 programs listed represent State approved or under review for approval engineering programs. Computer Integrated Manufacturing Brooklyn Technical HS Civil Engineering, Architecture, and General Technology Brooklyn Technical HS Civil Engineering City Polytechnic HS Academy of Engineering HS for Construction Trades, Engineering & Architecture Technology Education-Pre- Engineering Midwood HS Engineering Pathways in Technology Early College HS (P-Tech) Pre-Engineering Electronic Technology Queens Vocational &Technical HS Engineering Staten Island Technical HS Technical Electronics Engineering Robotics Thomas A. Edison Career & Technical Education HS Drafting/Design Engineering Technologies/Technicians Thomas A. Edison Career & Technical Education HS Electronics Pre- engineering Transit Tech Career & Technical Education HS

12. QUESTIONS 12