1. Workshop Positions Data Collection /Assessment Thursday, June 2 nd How Can We Make “International Strategy for Cyberspace” Acceptable?

2. Disclaimer All content selections and comments are those of the presenter, and do not necessarily represent the views of his employer or the Government, except when explicitly stated.

3. International Strategy for Cyberspace Overview of US Proposed Strategy (Homework to read this on www.whitehouse.gov) – Global Perspectives Comments from Others Others? – Group Discussion of the Issues Reactions and Opinions Debate (Friendly Intellectual Argument)? – The Rationale for Cyber Attack Deterrence Role of Cyber C5ISR (Traditional C5ISR is Military Use of Command, Control, Communications, Computers, Combat Systems, Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance) Today: Workshop Data Collection/Assessment (If Something of Value Results, Report our Ideas on “Potential Improvement” in an Open Letter, Etc.)

4. Unofficial Chinese Feedback The strategy is really about military capabilities and deterrence Despite the calls for cooperation, the U.S. is trying to maintain its technological lead The push for Internet freedom will lead to more conflict

5. International Debate Obvious Problems Intellectual Property Loss National Security Threats Not Everyone Shares “Our Vision of the Future”, e.g. – Some Are Against Global Economy For All People – Against Internet Freedom for All People in General – Against Rule of International Law; “Norms” of Behavior – Quote: “Will Lead to Conflict” From Global Freedom of Internet Speech and Activism? For Oppressive Governments? How Can We Improve Upon the Improve Upon the “International Strategy for Cyberspace”? “Free World” Wants Global Internet Freedom; International Laws & Enforcement Cooperation Improved Global Economy Ability to Defend/Deter

6. This Proposed 1 st Panel How Can We Improve Upon this “International Strategy for Cyberspace”? This Panel Would Be a First Start – Would Need to be Polished Up in Following Weeks – If Something of Value Results, Report our Ideas on “Potential Improvement” in a Letter to the US State Department

7. Primary References “International Strategy for Cyberspace,” signed by President Barack Obama and published May 1, 2011 by U.S. Government http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/rs s_viewer/international_strategy_for_cyberspace. pdf http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/rs s_viewer/international_strategy_for_cyberspace. pdf Unofficial Chinese Feedback http://blogs.cfr.org/asia/2011/05/23/chinese- responses-to-the-international-strategy-for- cyberspace/ http://blogs.cfr.org/asia/2011/05/23/chinese- responses-to-the-international-strategy-for- cyberspace/

8. Budapest Convention on Cyber-Crime Albania Denmark Latvia Portugal Turkey Argentina Andorra Estonia Liechtenstein Romania Ukraine Australia Armenia Finland Lithuania Russia UK Canada Austria France Luxembourg San Marino Chile Azerbaijan Georgia Malta Serbia Costa Rica Belgium Germany Moldova Slovakia Dom. Rep. Bosnia and Herzegovina Greece Monaco Slovenia Japan Bulgaria Hungary Montenegro Spain Mexico Croatia Iceland Netherlands Sweden Philippines Cyprus Ireland Norway Switzerland S. Africa Czech Rep Italy Poland [Macedonia]USA  Council Of Europe Members Non- Members 