1. Carmel River Lagoon Update A presentation to the Carmel Point and Lagoon Preservation Association Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Status of the Study Plan for Long Term Adaptive Management of the Carmel River State Beach and Lagoon Lagoon closing in spring 2009 Lagoon closing in spring 2009 Thursday, July 23, 2009 by Larry Hampson, Water Resources Engineer

2. Study Plan for Long Term Adaptive Management of the Carmel River State Beach and Lagoon The next few slides identify: The planning areaThe planning area Why a comprehensive plan is neededWhy a comprehensive plan is needed The stakeholders involvedThe stakeholders involved Goals of the planGoals of the plan Alternatives to be consideredAlternatives to be considered Progress to dateProgress to date

3. Immediate Planning Area

4. Why a comprehensive plan is needed Issues to address include: Storms remove sand from along Scenic Road and from the south end of the beach Storms remove sand from along Scenic Road and from the south end of the beach Homes and infrastructure on the north side of the lagoon are subject to flooding from the river and the ocean Homes and infrastructure on the north side of the lagoon are subject to flooding from the river and the ocean Beach manipulation, Carmel River diversions, and land use within the Carmel River watershed impact the beach and habitat at the lagoon for steelhead and California red-legged frogs Beach manipulation, Carmel River diversions, and land use within the Carmel River watershed impact the beach and habitat at the lagoon for steelhead and California red-legged frogs

5. Spring storms remove sand from Stewarts Cove and from the slope below Scenic Road Scenic Road Stewarts Cove March 1993

6. Winter storms remove sand from the basement layer at the southern end of the beach

7. Extreme ocean storms can fill the lagoon and flood low lying areas January 5, 2008

8. January 5, 2008 Flood

9. Sand bar management affects the beach and lagoon volume

10. An outlet to the south results in low water levels April 29, 2009

11. Carmel River diversions reduce inflow in the spring and summer

12. Lagoon water flows continuously through the beach

13. Land use in the upper watershed affects beach sand replenishment

14. Impacts to Steelhead

15. High and low water comparison 9 a.m., February 9, 2006, Elev.= 9.5 Lagoon surface area = 90 acres (estimate) 8:30 a.m., February 6, 2006, Elev.= 2.7 Lagoon surface area = 12 acres (estimate)

16. Higher water levels = higher water quality and more aquatic habitat

17. Lower water levels expose fish to predators, warm water, higher salinity levels, and lower dissolved oxygen levels

18. Stakeholders Big Sur Land Trust Big Sur Land Trust California American Water California American Water California State University Monterey Bay California State University Monterey Bay Carmel Development Company Carmel Development Company Carmel River Lagoon Coalition Carmel River Lagoon Coalition Carmel River Steelhead Association Carmel River Steelhead Association Carmel River Watershed Conservancy Carmel River Watershed Conservancy Monterey County Service Area 50 Monterey County Service Area 50 Pebble Beach Company Pebble Beach Company

19. Technical Advisory Committee California Coastal Commission California Coastal Commission California Department of Fish and Game California Department of Fish and Game California State Parks California State Parks Carmel Area Wastewater District Carmel Area Wastewater District Monterey County Public Works Department Monterey County Public Works Department Monterey County Water Resources Agency Monterey County Water Resources Agency Monterey Peninsula Water Management District Monterey Peninsula Water Management District NOAA Fisheries NOAA Fisheries Regional Water Quality Control Board Regional Water Quality Control Board U.S. Army Corps of Engineers U.S. Army Corps of Engineers U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

20. Planning Goal – comprehensive management Decrease potential for flood damage on the north side of the lagoon Decrease potential for flood damage on the north side of the lagoon Reduce the need to manage the beach Reduce the need to manage the beach Improve steelhead habitat in the lagoon Improve steelhead habitat in the lagoon Protect Scenic Road Protect Scenic Road Increase the sand supply to the mouth Increase the sand supply to the mouth

21. General categories of alternatives to be studied Beach sand replenishment Beach sand replenishment Structural protection along Scenic Road Structural protection along Scenic Road Flood proofing of structures Flood proofing of structures Mechanical control of lagoon elevation (e.g., pump to reduce high levels, install grade control at outlet to raise lowest level) Mechanical control of lagoon elevation (e.g., pump to reduce high levels, install grade control at outlet to raise lowest level) Create managed outlet channel Create managed outlet channel Increase dry season flows Increase dry season flows

22. Alternatives Analysis Several scientific studies are needed in order to evaluate alternatives Several scientific studies are needed in order to evaluate alternatives These studies will provide the information necessary to complete environmental documents (i.e., EIR and EIS) and preliminary plans for alternatives These studies will provide the information necessary to complete environmental documents (i.e., EIR and EIS) and preliminary plans for alternatives

23. Progress to Date Outline of studies was completed in April 2007 Outline of studies was completed in April 2007 Proposed scope of work was provided to State and Federal elected officials in 2007 and 2008 with a request for funds Proposed scope of work was provided to State and Federal elected officials in 2007 and 2008 with a request for funds Project work is part of the highest-ranked project in the Monterey Peninsula planning region Project work is part of the highest-ranked project in the Monterey Peninsula planning region Funding for certain components of the plan has been requested by CRWC Funding for certain components of the plan has been requested by CRWC MPWMD and MCWRA continue to search for grant funds to complete studies and begin work on environmental analysis MPWMD and MCWRA continue to search for grant funds to complete studies and begin work on environmental analysis

24. How far have we really come? You can always count on Americans to do the right thingafter theyve tried everything else. You can always count on Americans to do the right thingafter theyve tried everything else. - Winston Churchill

25. Lagoon closing in spring 2009 Closing the lagoon before the dry season is timed to fill the lagoon to as high an elevation as feasible before river inflows stopClosing the lagoon before the dry season is timed to fill the lagoon to as high an elevation as feasible before river inflows stop Closing is the responsibility of the California State Parks DepartmentClosing is the responsibility of the California State Parks Department State Parks consults with the Lagoon TAC concerning the timing and location of the closureState Parks consults with the Lagoon TAC concerning the timing and location of the closure MPWMD provides data on river inflow, tides, swell height and direction, condition of the beach, and status of steelhead migrationMPWMD provides data on river inflow, tides, swell height and direction, condition of the beach, and status of steelhead migration

26. What happens when the lagoon is mechanically closed off before the dry season? The volume of water and habitat in the lagoon after closure is greater than after a natural closure The volume of water and habitat in the lagoon after closure is greater than after a natural closure Water quality remains high for a longer period during the dry season Water quality remains high for a longer period during the dry season Bird predation is decreased Bird predation is decreased Food and habitat for steelhead rearing is increased Food and habitat for steelhead rearing is increased

27. Carmel River Lagoon Cycles Above – just prior to a breach Below – during a breach that empties the lagoon

28. Carmel River State Beach – spring 2009 May 8, 2009

29. Beach Condition Prior to Closure

30. Using equipment to block the mouth and raise the beach Left - June 11, 2009

31. Emergency outlet through the south end of the beach May 26, 2009

32. Main stem Above – 5/18/2009 Right – 6/11/2009

33. South arm Above – 5/18/2009 Right – 6/11/2009