Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Page 1 ACSDA Sao Paulo New Challenges for CSDs and CCPs 10 November 2006.

Published byDrusilla Alexander Modified over 9 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Page 1 ACSDA Sao Paulo New Challenges for CSDs and CCPs 10 November 2006."— Presentation transcript:

1 Page 1 ACSDA Sao Paulo New Challenges for CSDs and CCPs 10 November 2006

2 Page 2© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. Contents The old challenges – All done? The new challenges – What next?  Structural issues  Extra revenue  Reduced costs  International benchmarking

3 Page 3© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. The old challenges – All done? 1.Dematerialised 2.Demutualised 3.For profit model 4.SFI DVP 5.Stock lending & borrowing 6.Central register 7.Adequately capitalised 8.Disaster recovery in place

4 Page 4© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. The old challenges – All done? CountryDematerialised Immobilised DemutualisedFor Profit SFI DVP SLBCentral Register Adequate Capital Disaster Recovery Argentina Bolivia Brazil CETIP Canada Chile Colombia Costa Rica Dominican Republic Eastern Caribbean Ecuador El Salvador Guatemala Jamaica Mexico Nicaragua Panama Peru South Africa Trinidad & Tobago Uruguay (CBU) USA

5 Page 5© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd.  Structural issues  Extra revenue  Reduced costs  International benchmarking The new challenges – What next?

6 Page 6© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. The Standard Model Exchange CCP CSD Risk Transfer Risk Concentration Risk Minimisation The Brazilian Model BOVESPA CBLC CSD BM&F SISBEX SELIC BMA CBLC CCP CETIP Structural issues This is a risk based model It says nothing about ownership (vertical or horizontal) or governance OTC

7 Page 7© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. CountryExchangesCCPsCSDs ArgentinaBCBA, MERVALMERVALMERVAL, CVSA, CRYL BoliviaBBV-EDV BrazilBOVESPA, BM&FBMA, CBLCCBLC, CETIP, SELIC CanadaTSXCDS ChileSSE-DCV ColombiaMEC, BVC-DECEVAL, DCV Costa RicaBNV-CEVAL Dominican RepublicBVRD-CEVALDOM Eastern CaribbeanECSEECCSD EcuadorQuito, Guayaquil-DECEVALE El SalvadorBVES-CEDEVAL GuatemalaBVN- JamaicaJSE-JCSD MexicoBMVCCVINDEVAL NicaraguaBVDN-CENIVAL PanamaBVP-LatinClear PeruBVL-CAVALI South AfricaJSE, BESAJSESTRATE Trinidad & TobagoTTSE, GSS-TTCD, TTCB UruguayBVM-BVM, CBU USANYSE, NASDAQNSCC, GSCCDTC, Fed The Standard Model Structural issues

8 Page 8© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. Argentina Caja de Valores AustraliaSFE AustriaOEKB BelgiumEuroclear Belgium & Euroclear Bank Brazil CBLC Canada CDS CroatiaSDA DenmarkVP Egypt MCSD FinlandAPK FranceEuroclear France GermanyClearstream Banking GreeceCSD Hong KongHKFE HungaryKELER ItalyMonte Titoli JapanJSCC KoreaKSD LatviaLCD LebanonMidclear LuxembourgClearstream Mexico Indeval NetherlandsEuroclear Netherlands NorwayVPS PolandKDPW Russia DCC & NDC SingaporeMCD SloveniaKDD Sri LankaCDS South Africa STRATE SpainIBERCLEAR SwedenVPC SwitzerlandSIS TaiwanTDCC UAEDIFX UKCREST USA DTCC CSDs using SWIFT Structural issues

9 Page 9© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd.  Advantages  Drawbacks  Potential solutions Structural issues A Regional CCP

10 Page 10© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. Extra Revenues  Central matching  Issuer services  OTC Derivatives  Fund services CSDs should NOT compete with their participants. There should be no disintermediation CSDs are a natural monopoly and should not abuse this position. New sources of revenue

11 Page 11© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. Investors Broker/ Dealers Custodians Central Matching Utility (within CSD) Investors Broker/ Dealers Custodians Confirmation Average Price Affirmation Allocations SSI Give-ups Give-ins Allocations Without VMU With VMU Central Matching Utility Extra Revenues

12 Page 12© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. Reduced Costs  Cost reduction via consolidation or competition? Are CSDs different from CCPs?  Reduced costs for participants = revenue opportunities for CSDs  Use the utility to eliminate duplication in the market. Especially if there is no competitive advantage to be gained. Standardisation / Harmonisation is one of the main avenues to reduce costs.  Reduced costs for participants = fee reductions by CSDs  This depends on where you are on the development curve. Thus the need for proper price benchmarking exercise  Cost sharing – IT hub & spokes model  Africa, Greece/Cyprus, Middle East  Outsource to a regional CCP Cost centralisation or cost reduction?

13 Page 13© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. International benchmarks  FTSE  Morgan Stanley  CalPERS  Thomas Murray The Providers

14 Page 14© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. International benchmarks

15 Page 15© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. Morgan Stanley Emerging Markets Emerging Global Equity Markets 2006 ArgentinaIndonesiaPhilippines BrazilIsraelPoland ChileJordanRussia ChinaKorea (South)South Africa ColombiaMalaysiaSri Lanka Czech RepublicMexicoTaiwan EgyptMoroccoThailand HungaryPakistanTurkey IndiaPeruVenezuela Sri Lanka and Venezuela have since been removed from the MSCI list International benchmarks

16 Page 16© 2006 Thomas Murray Ltd. International benchmarks

Download ppt "Page 1 ACSDA Sao Paulo New Challenges for CSDs and CCPs 10 November 2006."

Similar presentations

1 Retail vs Wholesale Models 10 th November 2006 Presentation to ACSDAs Seminar in Sao Paulo - Brazil MONICA SINGER CEO STRATE Ltd.

1 Retail vs Wholesale Models 10 th November 2006 Presentation to ACSDAs Seminar in Sao Paulo - Brazil MONICA SINGER CEO STRATE Ltd.
Slide 1 Ian Bessarabia Regional Account Manager SWIFT Presentation 30 October 2007 Accra, Ghana.

Slide 1 Ian Bessarabia Regional Account Manager SWIFT Presentation 30 October 2007 Accra, Ghana.
® 2009-2010. Students 9,866,143 Students 9,866,143 Students 382,637Volunteers.

® Students 9,866,143 Students 9,866,143 Students 382,637Volunteers.
Page 1 © 2011 Thomas Murray Ltd. Shortening the Equity Settlement Cycle: Prospects, Hurdles and Goals of a Global Move to T+2 March 2011.

Page 1 © 2011 Thomas Murray Ltd. Shortening the Equity Settlement Cycle: Prospects, Hurdles and Goals of a Global Move to T+2 March 2011.
The Bretton-Woods Conference June 1944. Founders Harry Dexter White - Chief International Economist at the U.S. Treasury Harry Dexter White - Chief International.

The Bretton-Woods Conference June Founders Harry Dexter White - Chief International Economist at the U.S. Treasury Harry Dexter White - Chief International.
ACSDA Issuer Services Survey 2008. CDSs that responded the Issuer Services Questionnaire CDS - Canada DTCC – United State INDEVAL – México CBLC – Brasil.

ACSDA Issuer Services Survey CDSs that responded the Issuer Services Questionnaire CDS - Canada DTCC – United State INDEVAL – México CBLC – Brasil.
6th ACSDA International Seminar Punta del Este, Uruguay - October 27-28, 2004 CBLC Brazilian Settlement and Depository Models for International Investment.

6th ACSDA International Seminar Punta del Este, Uruguay - October 27-28, 2004 CBLC Brazilian Settlement and Depository Models for International Investment.
2  Regulated Exchange of EU.  Cyprus has joined the EU since May 2004.  Cyprus has joined the Eurozone as of January 2008.  Cyprus, as an EU Member.

2  Regulated Exchange of EU.  Cyprus has joined the EU since May  Cyprus has joined the Eurozone as of January  Cyprus, as an EU Member.
Build 2015 4/16/2017 © 2015 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. MICROSOFT MAKES NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS, IMPLIED OR STATUTORY, AS TO THE INFORMATION.

Build /16/2017 © 2015 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. MICROSOFT MAKES NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS, IMPLIED OR STATUTORY, AS TO THE INFORMATION.
KDPW Strategy 2010-2013 Dr Iwona Sroka President, KDPW Management Board Warsaw, 9 December 2009.

KDPW Strategy Dr Iwona Sroka President, KDPW Management Board Warsaw, 9 December 2009.
CDS Topic #2 - Opportunities and Innovation: Have you pursued businesses outside your traditional customer base? SEDAR - Issuer Filings SEDI – Insider.

CDS Topic #2 - Opportunities and Innovation: Have you pursued businesses outside your traditional customer base? SEDAR - Issuer Filings SEDI – Insider.
Service to a Regional Market Miami (HQ) 34 México 3 Guatemala 3 Costa Rica 2 Panamá 1 Trinidad y Tobago 1 Colombia 23 Ecuador 7 Perú 16 Brasil 9 Chile.

Service to a Regional Market Miami (HQ) 34 México 3 Guatemala 3 Costa Rica 2 Panamá 1 Trinidad y Tobago 1 Colombia 23 Ecuador 7 Perú 16 Brasil 9 Chile.
Latin American Countries Map Review. Mexico Nicaragua Panama Colombia Haiti Puerto Rico Jamaica Honduras The Bahamas Cuba United States Belize Guatemala.

Latin American Countries Map Review. Mexico Nicaragua Panama Colombia Haiti Puerto Rico Jamaica Honduras The Bahamas Cuba United States Belize Guatemala.
LATIN AMERICAN GEOGRAPHY Lesson #2. Physical Features Dense __________________ mixed with mountainous terrain and dry, arid lands Tropical Islands (Caribbean)

LATIN AMERICAN GEOGRAPHY Lesson #2. Physical Features Dense __________________ mixed with mountainous terrain and dry, arid lands Tropical Islands (Caribbean)
United States - 1887. India - 1898 Cabo Verde - 1901.

United States India Cabo Verde
AFTER 1947 ISRAELI – PALESTINE CONFLICT. Focus: Understanding the UN’s role and how the UN functions Interpreting the vote in the UN’s decision regarding.

AFTER 1947 ISRAELI – PALESTINE CONFLICT. Focus: Understanding the UN’s role and how the UN functions Interpreting the vote in the UN’s decision regarding.
The Tourism Geography of Latin America and the Caribbean.

The Tourism Geography of Latin America and the Caribbean.
Investments: Analysis and Behavior

Investments: Analysis and Behavior
El mundo español Jack Miley

El mundo español Jack Miley
Investing in the UAE CH 10. Investing in the UAE Introduction Why Investing in Global Markets? 1. Additional investment opportunities 2. Growth potential.

Investing in the UAE CH 10. Investing in the UAE Introduction Why Investing in Global Markets? 1. Additional investment opportunities 2. Growth potential.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google