1. Building Operator Training Program for Energy Efficient Operations Presentation to Minnesota Chief Engineer’s Guild St Paul, MN December 3, 2013 Center for Energy and Environment

2. Page 2 Executive Order 11-13 §4.b.ii (page 4) Demonstrate Leadership in Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy. …at least 50 percent of state building operators and managers will have attended Building Operator Certification (BOC) training … or other appropriate training approved by the Real Property Executive Committee, to operate existing energy-consuming equipment in state owned buildings in the most efficient manner possible. Background

3. Page 3  Create useful training for staff at all state facilities  Customize to facility AND staff  Make the best use of staff time  Create a manual that covers all the mechanical equipment in the facility  Manual is a reference and a living document  Focus is Energy Efficient Operations  Supplemented by a series of webinars  No cost to facility (CEE is under contract with Admin through February 2014) Training has been approved: Goals

4. Page 4  Program developed for building operators to assure persistence of savings in buildings  Site specific  Half day of hands on training  Manual and Check Sheets provided  Supported by a series of monthly webinars on general energy efficient operations management topics AHU’s Economizers, Fans, Motors, VFD’s Building automation systems Heating and cooling plants Energy Efficient OperationsProgram

5. Page 5  MEEA’s Building Operator Certification (BOC) training includes nearly 60 hours of classroom and project work (6.1 CEUs) in building systems operation and maintenance. 6 full days in class; one meeting a month  AFE’s Building Operator Certification Program two levels of certification, Certified Plant Maintenance Manager (CPMM) or Certified Plant Supervisor (CPS). The focus is maintenance Training is offered out of state and is typically four days long with the examination included. Comparison to Other Programs

6. Page 6 TopicBuilding Operator Certification Energy Efficient Operations Visit EE Ops Webinar New advances in Building Operation YesNo Building walkthroughDescribed in a lecturePerformed in your building No Types of FuelsYesNoMaybe Heat pump operationsYesIf you have oneNo Air Handling UnitsYes, all kindsYes, yoursYes, many kinds EconomizersYes, all kindsYes, yoursYes, many kinds HVAC Control Sequences YesYours, if neededGeneral concepts only O & M: Green Building Design YesNo O & M: daily operations GeneralYes, yoursGeneral concepts Comparison of Programs

7. Page 7  We can create verification forms and send reminders to submit them They will be maintained in a database For as long as is needed  We are available as support Mechanical engineering expertise Controls issues General energy management Sharing of new developments and best practices Energy Efficient Operations: Additional Services

8. Page 8 Sample Check

9. Page 9 Verification Check sheet Check mark under Section 41.2 if delta T is greater than 10 degrees: No corrective action is needed.

10. Page 10  Monthly series of about ten presentations on high level topics from a general perspective  Most common systems and issues  Case studies  Presenters from CEG and CEE  Incorporates elements of AFE and BOC Training Jim Nieswaag is a Certified Plant Maintenance Manager through the Association for Facilities Engineering Building Operator Training syllabus has been used to help design this program, working with Nora Wintermute of MEEA to coordinate their participation Energy Efficient Operations: Webinars

11. Page 11  October 2013Air Handler Units  November 2013Heating Equipment  December 2013BAS Control Strategies  January 2014Lighting and Plug Loads  February 2014Fans, Pumps and Motors  March 2014Maintenance Management and PM  April 2014Predictive and Productive Maintenance  May 2014Cooling Equipment  June 2014Health, Safety and Indoor Air Quality Webinar Schedule (all sessions delivered live and recorded for later viewing)

12. Page 12 Webinars include key take-aways

13. Page 13 Quizzes are used to track attendance

14. Page 14  Thank you  Contact information: Chris Plum PBEEEP Program manager Center for Energy and Environment 612-335-5825 eeops@mncee.org cplum@mncee.org Questions?