1. IEC SMB SG1 Recommendations Energy Efficiency and Renewable Resources IEC TC 100 AGS May 20, 2009 Jean Baronas INTERNATIONAL ELECTROTECHNICAL COMMISSION TECHNICAL COMMITTEE No. 100: AUDIO, VIDEO AND MULTIMEDIA SYSTEMS AND EQUIPMENT

2. IEC SMB SG1 Recommendations 1-12 1-12 SMB/3718D/CG SMB/3718D/CG The SMB approved 1-12 in SMB/3718B/R 13-20 13-20 SMB/3970R SMB/3970R IEC TC 100 commented, as follows IEC TC 100 commented, as follows

3. #13, Smart Grid IEC TC 100 supports “IEC to organize a Workshop on the topic of ‘Advanced supply and demand side balance in electrical grids” in order to inform on the state-of-the-art in standardization and to further propose concrete new standardization activities. This encompasses a) the integration of renewable energy sources into existing grids as well as b) techniques aiming at the organization of electricity supply versus electricity demand” “IEC to organize a Workshop on the topic of ‘Advanced supply and demand side balance in electrical grids” in order to inform on the state-of-the-art in standardization and to further propose concrete new standardization activities. This encompasses a) the integration of renewable energy sources into existing grids as well as b) techniques aiming at the organization of electricity supply versus electricity demand”

4. #13, Smart Grid IEC: -TC 8 (system aspects of electrical energy supply) -TC 57 (power systems management and associated information exchange) -TC 13 (electrical energy measurement, tariff- and load control)

5. #13, Smart Grid TC 100 comments on the “use side” TC 100 comments on the “use side” Possible new Technical Area (TA) on Energy Efficiency Possible new Technical Area (TA) on Energy Efficiency IEC 62087: 2008 (Measurement Methods) IEC 62087: 2008 (Measurement Methods) IEC 62394: 2006 (Echonet) IEC 62394: 2006 (Echonet) IEC 62514, Ed.1: (100/1526/CDV, Multimedia Gateway) IEC 62514, Ed.1: (100/1526/CDV, Multimedia Gateway) Proposed: "Saving Active Power (ASP) of Home Network Appliances" Proposed: "Saving Active Power (ASP) of Home Network Appliances"

6. #14, Household Appliances IEC TC 100 supports If TC 59 supports “TC 59 and its SCs to develop / update International Standards on measurement procedures required to define energy efficiency classes of electrical household appliances. The relevant evaluation methods shall take into account a realistic simulation of the actual use of each type of appliance.” “TC 59 and its SCs to develop / update International Standards on measurement procedures required to define energy efficiency classes of electrical household appliances. The relevant evaluation methods shall take into account a realistic simulation of the actual use of each type of appliance.”

7. #14, Household Appliances TC 100 asked for coordination with our contributions to the IEC TC 111 Project Team 62542 TC 100 asked for coordination with our contributions to the IEC TC 111 Project Team 62542

8. #15,Household Appliances IEC TC 100 supports If TC 59 supports “TC 59 and its SCs to develop a harmonized international system of energy consumption classes including a labeling scheme to determine the energy consumption/energy efficiency of household appliances, taking into account the existing regional and national standards in this field.” “TC 59 and its SCs to develop a harmonized international system of energy consumption classes including a labeling scheme to determine the energy consumption/energy efficiency of household appliances, taking into account the existing regional and national standards in this field.”

9. #15,Household Appliances TC 100 comment: Please note that an energy consumption (use) classification scheme, including labeling, is out of the scope of the IEC TC100. TC 100 comment: Please note that an energy consumption (use) classification scheme, including labeling, is out of the scope of the IEC TC100.

10. #16, Household Appliances IEC TC 100 supports If TC 59 supports “TC 59 to account for standby losses and off-mode losses in their product standards.” “TC 59 to account for standby losses and off-mode losses in their product standards.” IEC TC 100 comment: Please coordinate this work with our contributions to the IEC TC111 Project Team (PT) 62542 IEC TC 100 comment: Please coordinate this work with our contributions to the IEC TC111 Project Team (PT) 62542

11. #17, Household Appliances, Consumer Products, and IT Products The IEC TC 100 supports If TC 96 supports TC 96 “Small power transformers, reactors, power supply units and similar products” to take into account standby operation and energy efficiency of power supplies in their standardization activities. (Transformers, reactors, power supply units and similar for low voltage up to 1100 V) TC 96 “Small power transformers, reactors, power supply units and similar products” to take into account standby operation and energy efficiency of power supplies in their standardization activities. (Transformers, reactors, power supply units and similar for low voltage up to 1100 V)

12. #17, Household Appliances, Consumer Products, and IT Products IEC TC 100 comment: Please coordinate with our contributions to the IEC TC111 Project Team 62542 (defining the operating modes). The modes should eventually be harmonized. IEC TC 100 comment: Please coordinate with our contributions to the IEC TC111 Project Team 62542 (defining the operating modes). The modes should eventually be harmonized.

13. #18, Consumer Products and IT Products The IEC TC 100 cannot support “TC 100 and TC 108 should take into account both standby losses and off-mode losses in their standards. This implies external power supplies (AC / DC converters) to be considered as integral parts of the pertinent equipment (i.e. same treatment as for internal power supplies). For true zero standby and off-mode losses, the power supply shall be completely disconnected from the mains power by appropriate means.” “TC 100 and TC 108 should take into account both standby losses and off-mode losses in their standards. This implies external power supplies (AC / DC converters) to be considered as integral parts of the pertinent equipment (i.e. same treatment as for internal power supplies). For true zero standby and off-mode losses, the power supply shall be completely disconnected from the mains power by appropriate means.”

14. #18, Consumer Products and IT Products TC 100 comments: TC 100 comments: Continue with energy efficiency measurement standards Continue with energy efficiency measurement standards “Zero standby and off mode losses" remains the mission of governmental agencies that consider the social and economic impacts “Zero standby and off mode losses" remains the mission of governmental agencies that consider the social and economic impacts Continue working in close collaboration with the IEC TC108 Continue working in close collaboration with the IEC TC108

15. NOTE NOTE: SG1 met in Paris, 3/09 NOTE: SG1 met in Paris, 3/09 Minutes: SMB-SG 1/0065/RM Minutes: SMB-SG 1/0065/RM Concluded that the IEC TCs define the metrics and methods of testing (for energy efficiency) and the regulators “fix the limits." Concluded that the IEC TCs define the metrics and methods of testing (for energy efficiency) and the regulators “fix the limits."

16. #19, IT Equipment and Consumer Products The IEC TC 100 supports part of #19 “TC 100 and TC 108 to develop / update International Standards on measurement procedures for IT equipment and consumer electronics, which are the basis for establishing energy consumption / energy efficiency classes or other performance indicators.” “TC 100 and TC 108 to develop / update International Standards on measurement procedures for IT equipment and consumer electronics, which are the basis for establishing energy consumption / energy efficiency classes or other performance indicators.”

17. #19, IT Equipment and Consumer Products Comments from IEC TC 100: Comments from IEC TC 100: Continue developing measurement procedures: IEC 62087 Continue developing measurement procedures: IEC 62087 Technology-independent, for comparison Technology-independent, for comparison Considered in regulation Considered in regulation Performance indicators are unlikely candidates for standards Performance indicators are unlikely candidates for standards Labeling is out of scope Labeling is out of scope Plan to continue collaborating with the IEC TC108 Plan to continue collaborating with the IEC TC108 Cannot support energy efficiency classes, performance indicators (second part of Recommendation 19 ) Cannot support energy efficiency classes, performance indicators (second part of Recommendation 19 )

18. #20 IT Equipment and Consumer Products The IEC TC 100 cannot support “TC 100 and TC 108 to develop a harmonized international system of energy consumption classes or other performance indicators including e.g. a labeling scheme to determine the energy consumption / energy efficiency of consumer electronic products, such as TV sets, set-top boxes, cable modems, DSL routers etc.” “TC 100 and TC 108 to develop a harmonized international system of energy consumption classes or other performance indicators including e.g. a labeling scheme to determine the energy consumption / energy efficiency of consumer electronic products, such as TV sets, set-top boxes, cable modems, DSL routers etc.”

19. #20 IT Equipment and Consumer Products Comments from the IEC TC 100: Comments from the IEC TC 100: Collaborating with the IEC TC108 Collaborating with the IEC TC108 Classifications, performance indicators, e.g., a labeling scheme are out of the scope of the IEC TC100 Classifications, performance indicators, e.g., a labeling scheme are out of the scope of the IEC TC100

20. Summary 13-Workshop 14-Classification of Household Appliances* (definitions) (if TC 59 supports) 15-Consumption and Labels - Appliances (if TC 59 supports) 16-Standby losses – Appliances* (definitions) (if TC 59 supports) 17-Standby and energy efficiency of small transformers* (definitions) (if TC96 supports

21. Summary 18-Measurement Procedures for External power supplies: zero standby and off-mode losses 19-Measurement Procedures as a Basis for Consumption Classes 20-Harmonized Consumption Classification System, Performance Indicators, Labels

22. Summary IEC TC 100 supported most recommendations IEC TC 100 supported most recommendations Not supported are out of scope Not supported are out of scope Not supported if unlikely candidates for standards Not supported if unlikely candidates for standards Close collaboration with other TCs remains essential Close collaboration with other TCs remains essential Harmonized definitions Harmonized definitions IEC TC 100 plans to remain active in responding to the work efforts of the IEC SMB SG1 IEC TC 100 plans to remain active in responding to the work efforts of the IEC SMB SG1