1. 管理一學門 財務領域國際期刊分級排序專案計畫 ─ 保險及精算期刊 張士傑、蔡政憲 政治大學風險管理與保險學系

2. Criteria for Journal selection Literature 1.Baur, M. N., T. L. Zivney, and G. J. Wells, 1996, The Academic Community’s Revealed Preferences among Insurance Periodicals  This article tests several hypotheses regarding current insurance periodical subscriptions at university libraries throughout the United States in 1996.  Finding 69 insurance periodicals subscription at various types of universities.

3. 2. Colquitt, L. L., 1997, Relative Significance of Insurance and Actuarial Journals and Articles: A Citation Analysis  Evaluating 13 insurance and actuarial journals and 16 finance journals from 1991 through 1995.  Conclusion: –The top two insurance or actuarial journals based on the number of citations from the sample journals are the JRI and AB. –The JRI articles most frequently by the sample journals. 3. Colquitt, L. L., 2003, An Analysis of Risk, Insurance, and Actuarial Research: Citations from 1996 to 2000  Evaluating 16 risk, insurance and actuarial journals and 16 finance journals from 1996 through 2000.  Dividing 16 risk, insurance and actuarial journals into 2 groups: (1)the risk and insurance journal group, and (2) the actuarial journal group.  Conclusion: –The top two risk and insurance journals were JRI and JRU. –The top two actuarial journals were IME and AB.

4. Results 20 Scholars were selected and 10 Scholars responded 8 Risk and Insurance Journals were selected. 6 Actuarial Journals were selected Date range: 2001-2003

5. 8 Risk and Insurance Journals Journal of Risk and Insurance Journal of Risk and Uncertainty Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory Journal of Insurance Regulation Journal of Insurance Issues Risk Management and Insurance Review Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice Benefits Quarterly

6. 6 Actuarial Journals Insurance: Mathematics and Economics Astin Bulletin Scandinavian Actuarial Journal North American Actuarial Journal British Actuarial Journal Journal of Actuarial Practice

7. Ranking by Impact factor ─ Risk and Insurance Journals Risk and Insurance Journal Name Impact Factor 200120022003Average N. Score Rank Journal of Risk and Insurance0.1960.370.4490.3380.33782 Journal of Risk and Uncertainty1.4000.8460.7591.00211 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory N/A 04 Journal of Insurance RegulationN/A 04 Journal of Insurance IssuesN/A 04 Risk Management and Insurance ReviewN/A 04 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice N/A 0.120 0.11983 Benefits QuarterlyN/A 04 Singapore International Insurance & Actuarial Journal N/A 04

8. Ranking by Impact factor ─ Actuarial Journals Actuarial Journal Name Impact Factor 200120022003Average N. Score Rank Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 0.4020.6060.6140.54111 Astin BulletinN/A 02 Scandinavian Actuarial JournalN/A 02 North American Actuarial Journal N/A 02 British Actuarial JournalN/A 02 Journal of Actuarial PracticeN/A 02

9. Ranking by Literatures ─ Risk and Insurance Journals Risk and Insurance Journal Name CLL-1997CLL-2003 AverageRank N. Score Raw data Rank N. Score Raw data Rank N. Score Journal of Risk and Insurance 20.9167 110.958411 Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 60.5833 30.80.691730.7217 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 90.3333 40.70.516740.5391 Journal of Insurance Regulation 70.5 20.90.720.7304 Journal of Insurance Issues 100.25 70.40.32560.3391 Risk Management and Insurance Review N/A 100.1 80.1043 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 90.3333 60.50.416750.4348 Benefits Quarterly 120.0833 90.20.141770.1479

10. Ranking by Literatures ─ Actuarial Journals Actuarial Journal Name CLL-1997CLL-2003 AverageRank N. Score Raw data Rank N. Score Raw data Rank N. Score Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 40.25 20.83330.54173 Astin Bulletin 11 11111 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal 30.5 30.66670.58342 North American Actuarial Journal N/A 50.3333 5 British Actuarial Journal N/A 40.5 4 Journal of Actuarial Practice N/A 60.1667 6

11. Ranking by Scholars ─ Risk and Insurance Journals Risk and Insurance Journal Name 學者評分結果分數換算 AverageRank N. Score 12345678910 Journal of Risk and Insurance10 8 9.8011 Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 1048 86 8.6020.8776 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 1048848 8.2030.8367 Journal of Insurance Regulation 82482488886.0050.6122 Journal of Insurance Issues82482584885.7060.5816 Risk Management and Insurance Review 84284688886.4040.6531 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 42442444844.0070.4082 Benefits Quarterly42242444423.2080.3265

12. Ranking by Scholars ─ Actuarial Journals Actuarial Journal Name 學者評分結果分數換算 Average Rank N. Score 12345678910 Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 10 8 8 9.6011 Astin Bulletin108 8 9.6011 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal 848841088 87.6040.7917 North American Actuarial Journal 8104 888 88.4030.875 British Actuarial Journal444444451044.7050.4896 Journal of Actuarial Practice 25244444443.7060.3854

13. Journal Rating Result ─ Risk and Insurance Journals Risk and Insurance Journal Name 文獻排名結果學者評論 Impact Factor (01-03) 加權平均 Rank N. Score Rank N. Score Rank N. Score RankAverage Journal of Risk and Insurance111120.337810.8676 Journal of Risk and Uncertainty30.721720.87761120.8397 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 40.539130.83674030.5503 Journal of Insurance Regulation20.730450.61224040.537 Journal of Insurance Issues60.339160.58164050.3683 Risk Management and Insurance Review 80.104340.65314070.303 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 50.434870.408230.119860.3612 Benefits Quarterly70.147980.32654080.1898

14. Journal Rating Result ─ Actuarial Journals Actuarial Journal Name 文獻排名結果學者評論 Impact Factor (01-03) 加權平均 Rank N. Score Rank N. Score Rank N. Score RankAverage Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 30.5417111110.8167 Astin Bulletin11112020.8 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal 20.583440.79172030.55 North American Actuarial Journal 50.333330.8752040.4833 British Actuarial Journal40.550.48962050.3958 Journal of Actuarial Practice60.166760.38542060.2208

15. Journal Rating Result ─ Risk and Insurance and Actuarial Journals Risk and Insurance and Actuarial Journal Name RankAverage Risk and Insurance and Actuarial Journal Name RankAverage Journal of Risk and Insurance 1 (A) 0.8676 North American Actuarial Journal 8 (B+) 0.483 Journal of Risk and Uncertainty20.8397British Actuarial Journal 9 (B) 0.396 Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 3 (A-) 0.8167Journal of Insurance Issues 10 (B) 0.368 Astin Bulletin40.8 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 11 (B) 0.361 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 5 (A-) 0.5503 Risk Management and Insurance Review 12 (B) 0.303 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal 6 (B+) 0.55Journal of Actuarial Practice 13 (B) 0.221 Journal of Insurance Regulation 7 (B+) 0.537Benefits Quarterly 14 (B) 0.19

16. 7 Risk and Insurance Journals (2000-2004) Journal of Risk and Insurance Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory Journal of Insurance Regulation Journal of Insurance Issues Risk Management and Insurance Review Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice Benefits Quarterly

17. 5 Actuarial Journals (2000-2004) Insurance: Mathematics and Economics Scandinavian Actuarial Journal North American Actuarial Journal British Actuarial Journal Journal of Actuarial Practice

18. Ranking by Impact factor ─ Risk and Insurance Journals Risk and Insurance Journal Name Impact Factor 20002001200220032004Average N. Score Rank Journal of Risk and Insurance0.5540.1960.3700.4490.4410.40211 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 0.7620.000 0.1520.37912 Journal of Insurance RegulationN/A 04 Journal of Insurance IssuesN/A 04 Risk Management and Insurance Review N/A 04 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 0.000 0.1200.0000.0240.05973 Benefits QuarterlyN/A 04

19. Ranking by Impact factor ─ Actuarial Journals Actuarial Journal Name Impact Factor 20002001200220032004Average N. Score Rank Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 0.6070.4020.6060.6140.6020.56611 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal N/A 02 North American Actuarial Journal N/A 02 British Actuarial JournalN/A 02 Journal of Actuarial Practice N/A 02

20. Ranking by Literatures ─ Risk and Insurance Journals Risk and Insurance Journal Name CLL-1997CLL-2003 AverageRank N. Score Raw data Rank N. Score Raw data Rank N. Score Journal of Risk and Insurance 20.9167 110.958411 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 90.3333 40.70.516730.5391 Journal of Insurance Regulation 70.5 20.90.720.7304 Journal of Insurance Issues 100.25 70.40.32550.3391 Risk Management and Insurance Review N/A 100.1 70.1043 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 90.3333 60.50.416740.4348 Benefits Quarterly 120.0833 90.20.141760.1479

21. Ranking by Literatures ─ Actuarial Journals Actuarial Journal Name CLL-1997CLL-2003 AverageRank N. Score Raw data Rank N. Score Raw data Rank N. Score Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 40.25 20.83330.541720.9285 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal 30.5 30.66670.583411 North American Actuarial Journal N/A 50.3333 40.5713 British Actuarial Journal N/A 40.5 30.857 Journal of Actuarial Practice N/A 60.1667 50.2857

22. Ranking by Scholars ─ Risk and Insurance Journals Risk and Insurance Journal Name 學者評分結果分數換算 Average Ran k N. Score 12345678910 Journal of Risk and Insurance10 8 9.8011 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 1048848 8.2020.8367 Journal of Insurance Regulation 82482488886.0040.6122 Journal of Insurance Issues82482584885.7050.5816 Risk Management and Insurance Review 84284688886.4030.6531 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 42442444844.0060.4082 Benefits Quarterly42242444423.2070.3265

23. Ranking by Scholars ─ Actuarial Journals Actuarial Journal Name 學者評分結果分數換算 Average Rank N. Score 12345678910 Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 10 8 8 9.60 1 1 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal 848841088 87.60 3 0.7917 North American Actuarial Journal 8104 888 88.40 2 0.875 British Actuarial Journal444444451044.70 4 0.4896 Journal of Actuarial Practice 25244444443.70 5 0.3854

24. Journal Rating Result ─ Risk and Insurance Journals Risk and Insurance Journal Name 文獻排名結果學者評論 Impact Factor (00-04) 加權平均 Rank N. Score Rank N. Score Rank N. Score RankAverage Journal of Risk and Insurance11111111 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 30.539120.836720.379120.6261 Journal of Insurance Regulation20.730440.61224030.537 Journal of Insurance Issues50.339150.58164040.3683 Risk Management and Insurance Review 70.104330.65314060.303 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 40.434860.408230.059750.3491 Benefits Quarterly60.147970.32654070.1898

25. Journal Rating Result ─ Actuarial Journals Actuarial Journal Name 文獻排名結果學者評論 Impact Factor (00-04) 加權平均 Rank N. Score Rank N. Score Rank N. Score RankAverage Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 20.9285111110.9714 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal1130.79172020.7167 North American Actuarial Journal 40.571320.8752030.5785 British Actuarial Journal30.85740.48962040.5386 Journal of Actuarial Practice50.285750.38542050.2684

26. Journal Rating Result ─ Risk and Insurance and Actuarial Journals Risk, Insurance, and Actuarial Journal Name RankAverage Risk, Insurance, and Actuarial Journal Name RankAverage Journal of Risk and Insurance 1 (A) 1 Journal of Insurance Regulation 7 (B+) 0.537 Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 2 (A-) 0.8167Journal of Insurance Issues 8 (B) 0.3683 Scandinavian Actuarial Journal 3 (B+) 0.7167 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Issues and Practice 9 (B) 0.3491 Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance Theory 4 (A-) 0.6261 Risk Management and Insurance Review 10 (B) 0.303 North American Actuarial Journal 5 (B+) 0.5785Journal of Actuarial Practice 11 (B) 0.2684 British Actuarial Journal 6 (B) 0.5386Benefits Quarterly 12 (B) 0.1898