Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 James A. D’Antonio, M.D My disclosures: Stryker -Consultant -Royalties -Research Support Ceramic on Ceramic Bearings.

Published byLee Reeves Modified over 9 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 James A. D’Antonio, M.D My disclosures: Stryker -Consultant -Royalties -Research Support Ceramic on Ceramic Bearings."— Presentation transcript:

1 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 James A. D’Antonio, M.D My disclosures: Stryker -Consultant -Royalties -Research Support Ceramic on Ceramic Bearings Total Hip Replacement

2 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 67 yr female Now 25yrs p/o

3 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Extreme hardness / Scratch resistant Extreme hardness / Scratch resistant Hydrophilic = improved lubrication Hydrophilic = improved lubrication No metal ion release No metal ion release Debri – far less volume Debri – far less volume Superior wear resistance Superior wear resistance Major Advantages

4 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 1 st US IDE Study Study period:10/96 -10/98Study period:10/96 -10/98 ProspectiveProspective ControlledControlled RandomizedRandomized Multi-center trialMulti-center trial 512 hip cases 16 centers

5 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 5 Surgeons - Benjamin Bierbaum, M.D. - William Capello, M.D. - James D’Antonio, M.D. - James Roberson, M.D. - Robert Zann, M.D. 5 Surgeons - Benjamin Bierbaum, M.D. - William Capello, M.D. - James D’Antonio, M.D. - James Roberson, M.D. - Robert Zann, M.D. # hips = 475 (380 C/C) # hips = 475 (380 C/C) US IDE Ceramic Study Design: 12 th Year CORR July, 2005 CORR December, 2005 control

6 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 1 st Stage Patients – 8-12 yrs 1 st Stage Patients – 8-12 yrs System I 99 hips System II 95 hips System III 95 hips Ti Sleeve – 7-10 yrs System III 95 hips 2 nd Stage 186 hips

7 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 DemographicsMale% Mean Age (yrs.)Diagnosis Mean Wt. (lbs.)F/U(yrs.)System I c/c 66%53OA88%1868-12 System II c/c 67%55OA82%1918-12 System III poly 60%54OA82%1888-12 2 nd Stage c/c69%51.882%1897-10 No Difference

8 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Clinical Data 7 to 12 yearsPainNone/SlLimp None/ Mild Mean HHS Harris % G/E Pt.Sat.System I c/c 96%99%96.996%99% System II c/c 95%99%97.094%99% System III poly III poly92%96%96.896%99% 2nd Stage c/c92%98%96.395%99% No Difference

9 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 All ceramic = 96.8% Poly control = 91.3%

10 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 99.5% Survivorship End Point Bearing Surface Failure  380 ceramic cases = 2 revisions = 0.5% - 1 fracture at 6yrs - 1 chip at 9yrs  No revisions for lysis or wear in the 3 Al / Al patients groups (system 1, 2, and Trident)

11 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010  All implants boney stable  Osteolysis Metal /Poly (control) = 19.4% Ceramic/Ceramic = 1.7% Radiographic (8 – 12yrs year) P <.001 12yrs4yrs

12 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 60 yr old male 6ft. 3in. 235lbs Tight end UColo Now 12 yrs p/o In gym 4-5days Asymptomatic 6 of 380 ceramic cases - evidence of lysis

13 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 AP same patient

14 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Ceramic Concerns  Fracture  Squeaking

15 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Realistic Fracture Risk 2008  If Major technical errors are avoided (head/socket mismatch, failure to seat implant, autoclaving, interposed debri etc.) - 1 in 1,500 to 1 in 5,000 head > socket 28mm > 32+mm - 1 in 1,500 to 1 in 5,000 head > socket 28mm > 32+mm

16 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Poster Presented at 2009 AAOS, Paper submitted for publication Ceramic on Ceramic hip outcome at a 5-10 year interval Arthroplasty: Ceramic on Ceramic hip outcome at a 5-10 year interval Arthroplasty: Has it lived up to its expectations? J. Wesley Mesko, MD, James A. D’Antonio MD, William N. Capello MD, Marybeth Naughton BS

17 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Patients (930 C/C hips) in IDE ABC/Trident studies plus continued access patients follow/up required by FDA follow/up required by FDA Data gathered included: DislocationsInfections Aseptic femoral loosening Aseptic acetabular loosening Noise (describe) Other (describe)

18 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 C/C Patients (930 hips)- Omnifit® HA stem and one of three acetabular components C/C Patients (930 hips)- Omnifit® HA stem and one of three acetabular components Ti Alloy CP Ti

19 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 ABC® N=325 Trident ® N=605 TotalN=930 Squeaking5(1.5%)4(0.7%)9(0.97%) Clicking2(0.6%)8(1.3%)10(1.1%) Popping02(0.3%)2(0.2%) Creaking02(1pt)(0.3%)2(0,2%) Noise

20 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Capello Squeaking Scale 1- Occurs rarely, not reproducible 8 hips, 7 patients 2- Occasionally, reproducible 0 hips 3- Frequently, reproducible 1 hip (0.1%) (0.1%) 4- Occurs with every step/position change 0 hips JOA 23 #7 Suppl-1 2008

21 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010  At 12+ yrs experience with ceramic bearings mated with a TAlV alloy and a variety of cup designs squeaking has not been a problem

22 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Now 10 yrs p/o Cycles 3000mi/yr Snow skier Hockey player Asymptomatic no lysis 38 yr old male

23 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 45 yr old MD’s wife 5’ 3” 120lbs Marathon runner

24 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Ceramic / C 32mm Now 8yrs p/o 15-20miles/wk and 5-10K’s Asymptomatic no Lysis

25 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Summary – Ceramic/Ceramic  Superior Wear  Rare (minor) lysis at 12yrs  Survivorship high – younger pts.  Fx risk low with good surg. tech.  Squeaking – rare and not an issue

26 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 My indication for C/C bearings Young and active The high energy athletic patient

27 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 THANKYOU

28 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 My indication for C/C bearings Young and active – the high energy athlete Superior wear resistance

29 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Bearing Surface Related Failures  ceramic (380 hips) = 5 = 1.3% - 1 liner fx at 6 yrs - 1 anterior chip at 9yrs - 3 recurrent dislo.  poly control (95hips) = 5 = 5.3% - 2 for osteolysis - 3 recurrent dislo.

30 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Bearing Surface Related Failures  ceramic (380 hips) = 5 = 1.3% - 1 liner fx at 6 yrs - 1 anterior chip at 9yrs - 3 recurrent dislo.  poly control (95hips) = 5 = 5.3% - 2 for osteolysis - 3 recurrent dislo. 0.5% 2.1%

31 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Squeaking Reports titanium-molybdenum-zirconium-iron TMZF and V- 40 taper TMZF and V- 40 taper - Restrepo (JOA 08) = 3% (had high version) - Keurentjes (CORR 08) = 20% (aimed for 0º version) - Jarrett (JBJS 09) = 10.7%

32 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Squeaking Reports titanium-aluminum-vanadium  TAlV with C-taper - Lusty (JBJS) = 0.3% - Mesko (AAOS 09) = 0.97% in 930 consecutive cases ` - D’Antonio ( # 411) = 1.2% 5 pts. admit to a rare event 5 pts. admit to a rare event none can reproduce not an issue none can reproduce not an issue

33 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Squeaking Report  Restrepo, Hozack (pending JBJS) same surgeon, same approach 152 TMZF with V40 = 18.4% (6 revised) 152 TAlV with C-taper = 2.6% 152 TAlV with C-taper = 2.6% (0 revised)

34 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Noise – Vibration from Stem?  Ceramics resonate at 20,000hz above upper limit of human hearing  In - vivo range sq. hips is 400 to 7500hz  TMZF implants - 30-40% lower MOE than TAlV TMZF = smaller AP dimension -  ’d flex V-40 taper geometry smaller than C-taper  Metallurgy and geometry play a significant part in incidence and severity of squeaking

35 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Ceramics  Wide spread industrial use  30 + yrs - THA bearing world wide

36 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 2 nd Stage US IDE Study Ti Acetabular Component Sleeve Study period:10/98 - 2000Study period:10/98 - 2000 ProspectiveProspective Control ABC lllControl ABC lll Multi-center trial 5 centersMulti-center trial 5 centers

37 James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 Time Line – In Vivo Failures  50% within 12 months  70% within 24 months  83% within 36 months  28mm >> 32mm

Download ppt "James A. D’Antonio, M.D. ICJR 1/29/2010 James A. D’Antonio, M.D My disclosures: Stryker -Consultant -Royalties -Research Support Ceramic on Ceramic Bearings."

Similar presentations

CURRENT TECHNIQUES AND TECHNOLOGIES IN HIP SURGERY George J. Haidukewych M.D. Academic Chairman Director of Orthopedic Trauma Chief, Complex Joint Replacement.

CURRENT TECHNIQUES AND TECHNOLOGIES IN HIP SURGERY George J. Haidukewych M.D. Academic Chairman Director of Orthopedic Trauma Chief, Complex Joint Replacement.
Arthroplasty.

Arthroplasty.
The Swedish Total Hip Replacement Register by Henrik Malchau, Peter Herberts, Thomas Eisler, Göran Garellick, and Peter Söderman J Bone Joint Surg Am Volume.

The Swedish Total Hip Replacement Register by Henrik Malchau, Peter Herberts, Thomas Eisler, Göran Garellick, and Peter Söderman J Bone Joint Surg Am Volume.
Constrained Liners in Neurologic and Cognitively Impaired Patients Undergoing Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty P. Hernigou, P. Filippini, A. Poignard, X.

Constrained Liners in Neurologic and Cognitively Impaired Patients Undergoing Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty P. Hernigou, P. Filippini, A. Poignard, X.
Hip Arthroplasty Chris Oser. Presentation Why hip replacement? How? –Surgery! Different materials Pros and Cons Resurfacing Patient post-op.

Hip Arthroplasty Chris Oser. Presentation Why hip replacement? How? –Surgery! Different materials Pros and Cons Resurfacing Patient post-op.
Fracture of a BIOLOX Delta Ceramic Femoral Head Articulating Against a Polyethylene Liner by Anneliese D. Heiner, and Craig R. Mahoney JBJS Case Connect.

Fracture of a BIOLOX Delta Ceramic Femoral Head Articulating Against a Polyethylene Liner by Anneliese D. Heiner, and Craig R. Mahoney JBJS Case Connect.
WHAT MUST BE A WELL-CEMENTED PROSTHESIS?

WHAT MUST BE A WELL-CEMENTED PROSTHESIS?
THA TO SALVAGE FAILED ACETABULAR FRACTURES

THA TO SALVAGE FAILED ACETABULAR FRACTURES
Ten year comparison of Oxidized Zirconium & Cobalt Chrome Femoral Components in Total Knee Arthroplasty- a randomised controlled trial Justin Roe, Justin.

Ten year comparison of Oxidized Zirconium & Cobalt Chrome Femoral Components in Total Knee Arthroplasty- a randomised controlled trial Justin Roe, Justin.
History of THA Luke Gauthier January 6, 2011.

History of THA Luke Gauthier January 6, 2011.
Charnley-Kerboull THA for AVN: A minimal 10-year follow-up study C. Nich, J.P. Courpied, M. Kerboull M. Postel, M. Hamadouche Service A de Chirurgie Orthopédique.

Charnley-Kerboull THA for AVN: A minimal 10-year follow-up study C. Nich, J.P. Courpied, M. Kerboull M. Postel, M. Hamadouche Service A de Chirurgie Orthopédique.
THA after Chiari osteotomy: Intraoperative complications and behaviour of cup fixation in 24 cases Migaud H., Beniluz J., Gougeon F., Pinoit Y., Besson.

THA after Chiari osteotomy: Intraoperative complications and behaviour of cup fixation in 24 cases Migaud H., Beniluz J., Gougeon F., Pinoit Y., Besson.
The Kinetic Relationship between Sitting & Standing Posture & Pelvic Inclination. A. Stephens, S. Munir, S. Shah, W.L Walter The Specialist Orthopaedic.

The Kinetic Relationship between Sitting & Standing Posture & Pelvic Inclination. A. Stephens, S. Munir, S. Shah, W.L Walter The Specialist Orthopaedic.
Congenital Hip Dislocation.

Congenital Hip Dislocation.
OSTEONECROSIS OF THE FEMORAL HEAD: Modern Results of Total Hip Arthroplasty Daniel J. Berry, MD Prof and Chairman Mayo Clinic Rochester, MN.

OSTEONECROSIS OF THE FEMORAL HEAD: Modern Results of Total Hip Arthroplasty Daniel J. Berry, MD Prof and Chairman Mayo Clinic Rochester, MN.
Newcastle University CREST Extending prosthesis longevity through tribological understanding James Lord & Dr Tom Joyce.

Newcastle University CREST Extending prosthesis longevity through tribological understanding James Lord & Dr Tom Joyce.
Aseptic loosening of Hip Prostheses

Aseptic loosening of Hip Prostheses
بنام خداوند جان وخرد. Reasons for Hip Replacement Osteoarthritis (OA) Trauma and post-traumatic arthritis Congenital deformities Bone tumors Avascular.

بنام خداوند جان وخرد. Reasons for Hip Replacement Osteoarthritis (OA) Trauma and post-traumatic arthritis Congenital deformities Bone tumors Avascular.
Paris 2003 Wear of UHMWPE cup and component loosening in total hip arthroplasty Professor B.M. Wroblewski P.D. Siney P.A. Fleming The John Charnley Research.

Paris 2003 Wear of UHMWPE cup and component loosening in total hip arthroplasty Professor B.M. Wroblewski P.D. Siney P.A. Fleming The John Charnley Research.
HEMIRESURFACING M. E. Cabanela, M.D. Professor of Orthopedic Surgery Mayo Clinic College of Medicine Rochester, Minn. M. E. Cabanela, M.D. Professor of.

HEMIRESURFACING M. E. Cabanela, M.D. Professor of Orthopedic Surgery Mayo Clinic College of Medicine Rochester, Minn. M. E. Cabanela, M.D. Professor of.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google