1. Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Teunis Jansen Danish Institute for Fisheries Research 2006-WS on FishFrame Acoustics Extraction of methodology descriptions

2. Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Regions and combination of trawls Nederland: –“We make a graph with the cumulative distributions of all hauls and group them by eyeball on the basis of their geographical closeness and similarity in the cumulative LF distribution. Hauls with less than 20 herrings (or sprat) and specimens of less than 6 cm are disregarded”. Germany: –Region = rectangle –“the number of all herring in all 60min-standardised hauls of the rectangle are added and the same is done for sprat.” –Remember the length distribution when calculating the mean weight at age “The total numbers per length&age&maturity- class per rectangle (from 3.6) are now summed up over the rectangles of the whole area of investigation and these sums are then multiplied with the appropriate mean weight for each length&age&maturity-class. The resulting total weights per length&age&maturity-class are the summed up for each age&maturity-class and divided by the total number of herrings in this age&maturity-class. The result is the mean weight of a single herring in each age&maturity-class that takes account of the (often skewed) length distribution of this class.” Norway: “The “regions” used are ICES sq.” Denmark: –Regions: Based on an extensive study in the early 80ies. –“Mean haul per stratum calculated as a weighted mean after all hauls has been normalised to 60 min hauls” BIAS: –“Trawl catches within each ICES rectangle are combined to give an average species composition of the catch.” And “…each trawl catch is given equal weight. ” –Region = Rectangle for Length distrib. –Region = “Rectangle” for Age and mean weigth (max effort) –Region = “Sub-Division” for Age and mean weigth (min effort)

3. Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Abundance Nederland: –on raising densities to abundance in total area: “for rectangles with land, we apply a coastal factor based on “experience””. Germany: –“ = const. * ” (same as when b = 20 which it is so far for all relevant species). Denmark: –“By use of mean TS per stratum are number of ”mean” fish calculated by stratum”. Is “mean TS” really meaning “mean cross section  ”. How is it calculated? BIAS: –Check 5.9 “This total abundance is split into species classes Ni by Ni = N * fi (5.9.2)

4. Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute for Fisheries Research Unsampled strata Germany: –Rectangles for which sufficient echo-acoustic information exists but that have not been sampled with the net are interpolated using the biological data from the neighbouring rectangles. –Detailed description in chapter 4. Denmark: –No holes. Only 6 regions. BIAS: –“…mean of all available neighboring rectangles “