1. Public Sector Compensation Scheme 2013 Public Sector Pensions Authority Consultation

2. Compensation Scheme - Introduction Aims and Objectives of this Presentation  Joint presentation Employers/Unions  To outline the proposed new Public Sector Compensation Scheme  Give you the opportunity to ask questions and to provide clarification  Provide details of how to participate in the consultation

3. Compensation Scheme  What is the Public Sector Compensation Scheme for?  The Compensation Scheme provides benefits for loss of office Voluntary Redundancy Compulsory Redundancy  Not a Mutually Agreed Resignation Scheme (MARS) or a Voluntary Resignation Scheme (VRS)

4. Compensation Scheme  How have we got here?  Interim arrangements are in place for between 1 - 3 years from implementation of Unified Pension Scheme (now in year 2)  Council of Ministers determined a review should be carried out  Public Sector Pensions Authority Working Group, Chaired by the Vice Chair of the PSPA

5. Compensation Scheme - Introduction  Why is Scheme being revised? Current arrangements are complex, costly in terms of pension enhancements, varied and require modernising Simplify and harmonise compensation benefits across the public service Other considerations: - Existing employees - Labour Market - New Joiners - Private Sector - Taxpayer Supporting continuing economic success - Keeping people in employment Available to all including those not in the Unified Pension Scheme

6. Compensation Scheme  Who is covered by the proposed Scheme?  Majority of Public Sector Workers  Full details are in Schedule 1 of the Scheme

7. Compensation Scheme  Who is not covered by the proposed Scheme?  Teachers/Lecturers  Fire Fighters  Constabulary  Manx Radio staff  GP/Dental Practice staff  Medical/Dental Practitioners (under a contract for services)  Hospice staff  Local Government staff  Judiciary  Attorney General  Medical Officer or Chaplin (prison) Full details are in Schedule II of the Scheme

8. Current Position – IoM Public Service Current Position – Isle of Man Public Service:  Civil Servants/Manual Workers etc -Compulsory/Flexible Early Retirement (Over 50 years) -Approved Early Retirement (Over 50 years) -Compulsory/Flexible Early Severance (Under 50 years)  NHS –Up to 24 months’ pay for compulsory redundancy –Up to 24 months’ pay for voluntary redundancy –No additional pension enhancement

9. Current Position - Benchmarks Current position – Benchmarks:  United Kingdom Civil Service –Up to 12 months’ pay for compulsory redundancy –Up to 21 months’ pay for voluntary redundancy –No additional pension enhancement  Private Sector –Statutory Minimum – 1 weeks’ pay per year of service (capped at £480 per week) –Large Businesses – many capped at 12 months’ pay

10. Provisions of the Proposed Scheme  Main features:  Provision of a compensation lump sum for new and existing public servants  No automatic right to an enhanced pension - Pension and this scheme are separate

11. Provisions of the Proposed Scheme  Main Features:  New starters: Up to 12 months’ pay for compulsory redundancy Up to 18 months’ pay for voluntary redundancy  Applicants declined voluntary redundancy who are made compulsorily redundant will be entitled to voluntary terms  Compensation will be paid on the basis of a deemed salary of no less than £25,000 per annum

12. Transitional Arrangements Based on implementation date of the Scheme:  All staff up to age 45 years: maximum compensation lump sum of 18 months pay for compulsory redundancy and 24 months for voluntary redundancy (based on 1 month’s pay for each year of continuous service)

13. Transitional Arrangements Based on implementation date of the Scheme:  Staff aged 45 years and over: maximum compensation lump sum of 24 months pay for voluntary and compulsory redundancy (based on 1 month’s pay for each year of continuous service)

14. Age Profile of Workforce (excluding Police/Fire/Teachers/Lecturers)

15. Length of Service - % of Workforce (excluding Police/Fire/Teachers/Lecturers)

16. Conclusions  More than 60% of the workforce are aged 45 years and over  Very few staff under 45 years of age will have achieved more than 18 years service  Many staff over 60 years will receive improved benefits

17. Provisions of the Proposed Scheme  Pension Enhancement Options:  Staff made redundant aged 50 or over will have the option to use some or all of their compensation payment to purchase added service  Staff made redundant aged between 50 and 55 will be able to buy additional service but pension will not be paid before the age of 55  Staff will be able to buy as much or as little additional service as they wish up to the maximum available through the use of the compensation lump sum

18. Transitional Arrangements Based on implementation date of the Scheme:  All staff aged over 50 years: will have the option to use some or all of their compensation payment to purchase enhanced added service to increase their pension. Three year transitional arrangement.

19. Union View  UK Scheme Changes 2010 (Civil Service only) - means detrimental change was inevitable  GUS negotiations - Unions negotiated a period of up to 3 years no change  Aim – improved benefits compared to the UK Civil Service  Aim – ensure pension could be enhanced for those nearing pension age via improved lump sum provision  Aim – transition arrangements for existing members, those nearing retirement, and low paid amongst others

20. Union View  Current proposals – we would like to see them improved. Examples include:  Key change – existing members should be subject to the same provisions for the life of their employment  Key change - Standard minimum 3 month redeployment and 3 month notice periods across the public sector in cases of compulsory redundancy  Key change – 12 months compulsory and 21 months voluntary for new starters

21. Union View  Each union will submit a response to the consultation in respect of our members views  We need EVERY union member to input to the consultation individually and we will issue guidance on how you might do that  After the consultation, the scheme will be negotiated through individual forums/members will be balloted  COMIN has agreed that moving these provisions into collective bargaining should be further explored

22. Next Steps  Public Consultation/Joint Briefings  Finalisation of the Scheme by PSPA  Trade Union ballots  PSPA Approval  New scheme implemented  Tynwald Approval

23. Compensation Scheme – Information  More information on the consultation can be found on the Public Sector Pensions Authority website: www.pspa.im

24. Any Questions?