1. (Mr.) Bean Sprout By Premus

2. Big beans didn't grow Sprouts of the smallest beans grew the tallest Equal amount of water Equal amount of space Equal number of beans Same temperature Same humidity Same time frame Data

3. The big beans would have grown if they had been soaked in water The bigger the bean the longer the soaking Soaking increases the water content in the beans and brings them out of quiescence (sleep) Claim, warrant and backing

4. Most people soak bigger beans before germination (sprouting) The beans might have been too old to germinate Qualifier and rebuttal