1. Looking at Student Work Tuning Protocol Kathy Arminio Kathy Hoppe Monroe 2-Orleans BOCES

2. The Critical Friends Group! Looking at Student Work Protocol Work becomes public Formal with careful listening involved Comments are kept short Process is descriptive not for judgment or evaluation

3. The Critical Friends Group Guidelines! Looking at Student Work Protocol Be considerate and avoid:

4. One Person Volunteers to be the Facilitator One Person Volunteers to be the Presenter

5. Facilitator Looking at Student Work Protocol Sets the ground rules Helps maintain the focus and structure Listens, takes notes and participates

6. Presenter Looking at Student Work Protocol Describes the lesson very briefly Answer questions succinctly Listen intently to comments of group

7. What is the structure? Looking at Student Work Protocol Introduction and ground rules (norms) by facilitator Description of lesson by teacher presenter  Following presentation nothing is said by presenter unless questioned or reflecting Examination of student work Clarifying questions to teacher by critical friends group  Teacher presenter answers Feedback  Warm Comments  Cool Comments  Probing Questions (Teacher presenter does not answer) Reflection from teacher presenting Debrief

8. Protocol in Action Looking at Student Work Watch a segment of “Critical Issues in School Reform,” entitled: Reflecting on Teaching Practice: Student Work, Teacher Work, and Standards, Part I—Math

9. Keeping Track Keeping Track Looking at Student Work Protocol Develop your short presentation Keep a record of warm and cool comments Write a short reflection about what might be helpful in revision of your lesson

10. AGENDA  Welcome/Catch Up  Presentation on "Looking at Student Work: Tuning Protocol“  Film demonstrating Tuning Protocol  Critical Friends Group 1 & 2 (Using your student work) 11:30-12:30 Lunch  Critical Friends Group 3 & 4 (Using your student work)  Planning for next meeting