Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published bySusanna Chandler Modified over 9 years ago
1
Use of Toxicological Pathways for Hazard Assessment in OECD (Q)SAR Toolbox: McKim Conference September 2008, Duluth, USA LMC, Bourgas University, Bulgaria Chemical Management Center, NITE, Japan Fraunhofer Institute for Toxicology and Experimental Medicine, Germany OECD, Environment Directorate, Paris International QSAR Foundation, USA
2
Outline Conceptual framework of QSAR Categorization and QSAR Predicting human health endpoints in Toolbox Molecular initiating events and toxicological pathways Case study with 28d RDT Mechanism database in Toolbox
3
Outline Conceptual framework of QSAR Categorization and QSAR Predicting human health endpoints in Toolbox Molecular initiating events and toxicological pathways Case study with 28d RDT Mechanism database in Toolbox
4
Molecular Initiating Events Chemical Speciation and Metabolism Measurable System Effects Adverse Outcomes Parent Chemical Conceptual Framework of SAR/QSAR Rather than developing statistical models of complex endpoints, key molecular initiating events become the “well-defined” endpoints for QSAR. Gil Veith; International QSAR Foundation
5
Adverse Outcomes Parent Chemical IQF Framework for QSAR Black Box Models Rapid but not mechanistically transparent
6
Molecular Initiating Events Speciation and Metabolism Measurable System Effects Adverse Outcomes Parent Chemical IQF Framework for QSAR 1. Identify Plausible Molecular Initiating Events 2. Design Database for Abiotic Binding Affinity/Rates 3. Explore Linkages in Pathways to Downstream Effects 4. Develop QSARs to Predict Initiating Event from Structure QSAR SystemsBiology Chemistry/Biochemistry QSAR
7
Outline Conceptual framework of QSAR Categorization and QSAR Predicting human health endpoints in Toolbox Molecular initiating events and toxicological pathways Case study with 28d RDT Mechanism database in Toolbox
8
Categorization and QSAR The categories concept is part of the historical description of QSARs QSARs are quantitative models of key mechanistic processes which result in the measured activity
9
Each QSAR estimate is a result of two predictions: Qualitative prediction of predominant interaction mechanisms and hazard identification (defined by category) Quantitative prediction of the intensity (potency) of the specific mechanisms of interaction (predicted by QSAR) Wrong definition for the mechanism of underlying reaction could result in using of a wrong QSAR for the potency estimate Categorization and QSAR
10
Example Phenols are polar narcotics, uncouplers or electrophilic chemicals. QSAR models for predicting acute effects for each mechanism have comparable uncertainty The potency of the electrophilic mechanism can be orders of magnitude greater than polar narcotics Wrong categorization of chemicals could cause significant errors in defining the potency
11
The logic for selecting a specific model (category) for a specific chemical is the cornerstone of regulatory acceptance Categorization and QSAR Basic Assumption for Regulatory Acceptance OECD QSAR AD-Hoc group meeting, Madrid, April 2007
12
Outline Conceptual framework of QSAR Categorization and QSAR Predicting human health endpoints in Toolbox Molecular initiating events and toxicological pathways Case study with 28d RDT Mechanism database in Toolbox
13
Modelled human health endpoints in Toolbox Sensitization Lung Skin Genotoxicity AMES bacterial mutagenicity Chromosomal aberration Irritation/corrosion Eye Skin
14
Commonality between the modelled endpoints The effects could be characterized by: Single toxicological pathway Strong dependency on initiating molecular events (e.g. on molecular structure) Small impact of subsequent biological processes (“short” toxicological pathways)
15
Molecular Initiating Events Speciation and Metabolism Measurable System Effects Adverse Outcomes Parent Chemical QSAR Framework for modeled endpoint QSAR Biological processes Initiating chemical/Biochemical Interactions QSAR
16
Molecular Initiating Events Speciation and Metabolism Adverse Outcomes Parent Chemical QSAR QSAR QSAR Framework for modeled endpoint Initiating chemical/Biochemical Interactions
17
Epidermis Dermis Hypodermis Vein Protein conjugates Penetration Protein conjugates Metabolism Lymph Mechanism of skin sensitization Subject of modeling Assumptions in the model: 1.Chemicals always penetrate stratum corneum 2.Formation of protein conjugates is a premise for ultimate effect 3.Metabolism may play significant role in skin sensitization
18
Model Simulator of skin metabolism ∩ QSAR models Parent Metabolism Phase II Reactive species Reactive species Reactive species S-Pr W sensitization S-Pr W sensitization S-Pr S sensitization S-Pr S sensitization No sensitization QSAR
19
Conclusion: The categorization of substances according to chemical mechanisms governing the initiating reaction with protein or DNA is good enough for predicting human health effects resulting from single and “short” toxicological pathways
20
Outline Conceptual framework of QSAR Categorization and QSAR Predicting human health endpoints in Toolbox Molecular initiating events and toxicological pathways Case study with 28d RDT Mechanism database in Toolbox
21
General characterization by the following grouping schemes: Substance information Predefined Mechanistic: Acute Toxicity MOA (OASIS) Protein binding (OASIS) DNA binding (OASIS) Electron reach fragments (Superfragments) BioBite Cramer Classification Tree (ToxTree) Veerhar/Hermens reactivity rules (ToxTree) Lipinski rules (MultiCase) Chemical input ProfilingCategory Definition Filling data gap ReportEndpoints Toolbox logical sequence of components usage
29
Molecular Initiating Events and Toxicological Pathways General Consideration
30
Molecular Level Mechanism of chemical interactions
31
Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Molecular Level
32
Distribution in lipid phase Protein binding Arylcarboxylate aminolysis Michael-type addition Schiff base formation … DNA binding Quinones Hydrazines … Mechanism of chemical interactions Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Molecular Level
33
Distribution in lipid phase Protein binding Arylcarboxylate aminolysis Michael-type addition Schiff base formation … DNA binding Quinones Hydrazines … Mechanism of chemical interactions Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … Molecular Level
34
Mechanism of chemical interactions Initiating event/Receptor Activation of AP-1 、 NF-kB 、 EpRE in hepatocyte →Activation of JNK/AP-1 pathway Activation of estrogen Signals → Proliferation of bile duct cell and hepatocyte injury Activation of MAPK Signals - Apoptosis … Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … Molecular Level
35
Mechanism of chemical interactions Initiating event/Receptor Activation of AP-1 、 NF-kB 、 EpRE in hepatocyte →Activation of JNK/AP-1 pathway Activation of estrogen Signals → Proliferation of bile duct cell and hepatocyte injury Activation of MAPK Signals - Apoptosis … Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
36
Mechanism of chemical interactions Cell Level System biology/Effect Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
37
Mechanism of chemical interactions Cell Level System biology/Effect Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
38
Mechanism of chemical interactions Cell Level System biology/Effect System biology Hepatotoxicity mechanism: Oxidant stress Mitochondrial damage Apoptosis Degradation of membrane phospholipid Aberration of ion channel Increase of enzyme activition of drug metabolism Inflammatory responses … Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Molecular Level
39
Mechanism of chemical interactions Cell Level System biology/Effect Cell Effects Hepatocyte Changes in the tubular epithelium … Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
40
Mechanism of chemical interactions Cell Level System biology/Effect System biology Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
41
Mechanism of chemical interactions Cell Level System biology/Effect System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Observed Effects Symptomology Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
42
Mechanism of chemical interactions Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … Cell Level System biology/Effect System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Observed Effects Symptomology Tissue Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Organ Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Body Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
43
Mechanism of chemical interactions Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … Cell Level System biology/Effect System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Observed Effects Symptomology Tissue Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Organ Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Body Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Molecular initiating event(s) and subsequent downstream effects Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
44
Mechanism of chemical interactions Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … Cell Level System biology/Effect System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Observed Effects Symptomology Tissue Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Organ Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Body Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Molecular initiating event(s) and subsequent downstream effects Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
45
Mechanism of chemical interactions Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 Mechanism 3 … Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – … Cell Level System biology/Effect System 1 – System 2 – System 3 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Observed Effects Symptomology Tissue Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Organ Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Body Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3... Molecular initiating event(s) and subsequent downstream effects Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
46
1.One complex endpoint (e.g., 28days RDT) could be conditioned by more than one toxicological pathway (blood toxicity, liver damage, kidney damage) Conclusion: 2.(Q)SAR models should be associated with a single toxicological pathway 3.Chemicals which interact by different toxicological pathways should be out of the model mechanistic domain
47
Conclusion: 4.The categorization of substances according to chemical mechanisms governing the initiating reactions with protein or DNA is not enough for predicting human health effects resulting from multiple and complex toxicological pathways 5.The link between chemical and toxicological mechanisms and respective categorization schemes needs to be identified
48
Outline Conceptual framework of QSAR Categorization and QSAR Predicting human health endpoints in Toolbox Molecular initiating events and toxicological pathways Case study with 28d RDT Mechanism database in Toolbox
49
Case study: Twenty-eight day repeat dose oral toxicity test of chemicals (28d RDT) 1.Data produced by: Safety examination of existing chemicals in NITE- Japan; under Japanese Chemical Substances Control Law; Fraunhofer Institute for Toxicology and Experimental Medicine, Hanover, Germany 2. Categorization of chemicals for predicting 28d RDT is based on analysis of data by NITE and LMC
50
28-day RDT tests conducted on male rats that tested 14 aromatic amines
51
Categorization of Anilines 1.Based on their effects on two organs: Blood Kidney
52
Categorization of Anilines 1.Based on their effects on two organs: Blood Kidney
53
Blood Toxicity: Blood toxicity effects: decrease in erythrocyte count (RBC) hemoglobin level (Hb) Hematocrit (HTC) glutamic-pyruvic transaminase (GPT) increase in the number of reticulocytes hemosiderin pigmentation in the spleen increase in hematopoiesis etc.
54
Toxicity scale of Intensity Intensity scale: basis of the number of effects indicative of toxicity strong medium weak non
55
Toxicity scale of Intensity Example: determining LOEL of N-ethylaniline: Test doses - 0, 5, 25, 125 mg/kg/day Decrease in RBC only has been observed at 5 mg/kg Decrease in RBC, Hb and HTC–at 25 and 125 mg/kg Hence, LOEL for hemolysis is 5mg/kg/day
56
★★ ★★ ★★ ★ ★ ★★ ★ ★★★ ★ ▲ ▲ ▲▲ ▲ ▲ ■ 02004006008001000 Dose (mg/kg/day) Anemia findings ○: 0, ▲: 1, ■: 2, ★ : >3 RBC↓, Hb↓, HTC↓, GPT ↑ Reticulocytes↑ hemosiderin pigmentation in the spleen hematopoiesis↑ etc. Comparison of the intensities of anemia for 14 aromatic amines
57
NOELs for anemia RBC↓, Hb↓, HTC↓ Reticulocytes↑ hemosiderin pigmentation in the spleen hematopoiesis↑ etc. Water soluble anilines (logKow<0 ) have NO EFFECT Relationships between NOEL for anemia and logKow for 14 aromatic amines
58
LOELs for anemia RBC↓, Hb↓, HTC↓ Reticulocytes↑ hemosiderin pigmentation in the spleen hematopoiesis↑ etc. Relationships between LOEL for anemia and logKow for 14 aromatic amines Water soluble anilines (logKow<0 ) have NO EFFECT
59
CYP450 in the Liver Glucuronide and sulfate conjugation Urine Adducts with DNA, Blood proteins: Hb, Alb Hb Met Hb Mechanism 1 Mechanism 2 These mechanisms of initiating reactions will be used to develop toxicological mechanism based categories Mechanism underlying the toxic effects exerted by anilines
60
LOELs for anemia RBC↓, Hb↓, HTC↓ Reticulocytes↑ hemosiderin pigmentation in the spleen hematopoiesis↑ etc. Mechanism 2 Mechanism 1 Relationships between LOEL for anemia and logKow for 14 aromatic amines
61
Hemoglobin binding index (HBI) HBI = (mmole compound/mole Hb)/(mmole compound/kg body weight) Sabbioni, Environ. Health Perspect. 102 (1994) 61-67. HBI = f (ΔE # ) ΔE # Nitrenium ion E Reaction pathway Validation of Mechanism #1
62
Calculated HBI ( E # [eV]) vs. change in RBC in RDT test Validation of Mechanism #1
63
in vitro, female rat liver R. Kato et al., Jpn. J. Pharmacol., 19 (1969) 53 – 62 + Rats 28 days >5 mg/kg/day Hemolysis (Japanese CSCL) Rats 28 days >6 mg/kg/day Hemolysis (EU Risk Assessment Report) Rats 90 days <150 mg/kg/day No Hemolysis Findings [Johnnsen et al., Toxicol. Lett., 30 (1986) 1-6.] Repeated Dose Toxicity Test Metabolite of N-methylanilines Validation of Mechanism #1
64
Using HBI of the metabolite(Aniline) Validation of Mechanism #1
65
Categorization of Anilines 1.Based on their effects on two organs: Blood Kidney
66
Effect on the kidney ○ : Nothing ▲ : Weak (Kidney wt↑) ■ : Medium (Other) ★: Strong (Necrosis) ★ ★ ▲ ■ 02004006008001000 Dose (mg/kg/day) ■ ▲ ▲ ★ Comparison of the effect on the kidney for 14 aromatic amines
67
LOELs for the kidney Different effect of the chemical as compared with the anemia. This will be related with interaction mechanism Relationships between LOEL for the kidney and logKow for 14 aromatic amines
68
CYP450 in the Liver Glucuronide and sulfate conjugation Urine Adducts with DNA, Blood proteins: Hb, Alb Hb Met Hb Mechanism underlying the toxic effects exerted by anilines on kidney Mechanism 2 Mechanism underlying the toxic effects exerted by anilines
69
× > binding with the SH proteins RDT Effect on the kidney Effect initiating mechanism Basophilic tubule, proximal (100, 500) Necrosis, Tubular epithelium, proximal (500) Kidney, wt ↑ (720)
70
Category building based on the link between chemical and toxicological mechanisms
71
Category Building Category #1. Water soluble aromatic amines – logKow ≤ 0 – no effect Based on the link between chemical and toxicological mechanisms Category #2. If 0<logKow ≤ 1; it is eliminated by mechanism #2 and as parent or metabolite has alerting groups interacting with: Proteins (such as quinone imines; Mechanisms #2) – strong kidney toxicity and weak blood toxicity (Category #2a) DNA or blood proteins (Mechanisms #1) – week blood toxicity (Category #2b)
72
Category Building Based on the link between chemical and toxicological mechanisms Category #3. If logKow > 1 and as parent or metabolite has alerting groups interacting with: Proteins (Mechanisms #2) – week kidney toxicity (Category #3a) DNA (Mechanisms #1) – strong blood toxicity (Category #3b)
73
LogKow<0 Chemical
74
Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical
75
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical
76
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert
77
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity
78
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity
79
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert
80
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert Yes Week blood toxicity
81
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert Yes Week blood toxicity No No blood toxicity
82
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert Yes Week blood toxicity No No blood toxicity No Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert
83
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert Yes Week blood toxicity No No blood toxicity No Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Week kidney toxicity Yes
84
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert Yes Week blood toxicity No No blood toxicity No Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Week kidney toxicity Yes No No kidney toxicity
85
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert Yes Week blood toxicity No No blood toxicity No Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Week kidney toxicity Yes No No kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form alert interacting with DNA
86
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert Yes Week blood toxicity No No blood toxicity No Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Week kidney toxicity Yes No No kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form alert interacting with DNA Yes Strong blood toxicity
87
No Yes 0<LogKow<1 Yes No toxic effect LogKow<0 Chemical Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Yes Strong kidney toxicity No No/Week kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form DNA binding alert Yes Week blood toxicity No No blood toxicity No Parent or metabolites have or form protein binding alert Week kidney toxicity Yes No No kidney toxicity Parent or metabolites have or form alert interacting with DNA Yes Strong blood toxicity No No blood toxicity
88
Demonstrated by using RDT database, Fraunhover ITEM, Hanover, Germany New Pilot Functionalities in Toolbox
89
Input chemical
90
Chemical category based on molecular initiating event
91
Measured RDT and Genotoxicity data are extracted from the OASIS genotox and RDT databases
92
OECD Toolbox Species Organ/System Effect/Tissue rat mouse immune system intestine kidney larynx liver lung lymph node mammary gland nervous system dermal drinking water feed gavage inhalation oral unspecified Route weight decreased weight increased cell proliferation changed enzyme activity degeneration inflammation metaplasia Alanine aminotransferase Alkaline phosphatase Lactate dehydrogenase Specification NOEL LOEL RDT Structure Endpoint
93
OECD Toolbox Filtering Reference Study Endpoint Route Bioassay (Species) *Gender *Exposure duration Organ/Tissue Effect Study information Supplemental Information Rat Mouse … Strain Study sex Effect sex Study duration, days Study duration, categories Post exposure Reliability Author(s) Title Source Date Dermal Drinking water Feed Gavage … Immune system Intestine Kidney … Weight decreased Weight increased Cell proliferation … New Filtering Functionality *Items not in SIDS tree
94
Target endpoint: LOEL, feed, rat Damaged organs and effects are unknown before chemical mechanism based categorization
95
Chemical grouping based on initiating molecular reaction
96
Target endpoint: LOEL, feed, rat Damaged organs and effects should be defined based on chemical mechanism based categorization
98
Subcategorization based on chemical interaction mechanisms and/or structure based similarity
101
Subcategorization based on toxicological mechanisms resulting from underlying chemical interaction mechanisms
105
Missing information on organs expected to be damaged as a result of initiating reaction
106
Missing information on effects expected on damaged organs as a result of initiating reaction
113
Assumed Toxicological Pathway Binding with DNA Tumour formation in liver Chemical MechanismsToxicological Mechanisms Aromatic Amines
114
Defining toxicological pathway and building the mechanism data base is critical for the Toolbox project Chemical MechanismsToxicological Mechanisms
115
Chemical categorization Grouping by Chemical Mechanisms Toxicological categorization Grouping by Toxicological Mechanisms Predicted initiating reactions for the target chemical Predicted toxicological outcome for the target chemical
116
Outline Conceptual framework of QSAR Categorization and QSAR Predicting human health endpoints in Toolbox Molecular initiating events and toxicological pathways Case study with 28d RDT Mechanism database in Toolbox
117
The Mechanism Database in the Toolbox Project
118
System biology Symptomology Chemistry/Biochemistry
119
Molecular LevelCell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Chemistry/Biochemistry
120
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
121
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Functions Pathways Processes Molecular Level Chemistry/Biochemistry
122
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – Receptor 4 –... System 1 – System 2 – System 3 – System 4 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3 Effect 4... Molecular Level Functions Pathways Processes Chemistry/Biochemistry
123
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Initiating reaction (Q)SAR Categorization Molecular Level Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – Receptor 4 –... System 1 – System 2 – System 3 – System 4 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3 Effect 4... Functions Pathways Processes Chemistry/Biochemistry
124
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Initiating reaction (Q)SAR Categorization Molecular Level Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – Receptor 4 –... System 1 – System 2 – System 3 – System 4 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3 Effect 4... Functions Pathways Processes Chemistry/Biochemistry Chemical Mechanism Database
125
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Initiating reaction (Q)SAR Categorization Tissue Organ Body Response Molecular Level Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – Receptor 4 –... System 1 – System 2 – System 3 – System 4 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3 Effect 4... Functions Pathways Processes Chemical Mechanism Database Chemistry/Biochemistry Expert observation
126
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Initiating reaction (Q)SAR Categorization Tissue Organ Body Response Molecular Level Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – Receptor 4 –... System 1 – System 2 – System 3 – System 4 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3 Effect 4... Functions Pathways Processes Chemical Mechanism Database Chemistry/Biochemistry Expert observation Toxicological Mechanism Database
127
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Initiating reaction (Q)SAR Categorization Mechanism Knowledge Database Tissue Organ Body Response Expert observation Molecular Level Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – Receptor 4 –... System 1 – System 2 – System 3 – System 4 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3 Effect 4... Functions Pathways Processes Chemistry/Biochemistry
128
Cell Level System biology Tissue, Organ and Body Symptomology Search / Collection of in vitro Test Information Initiating reaction (Q)SAR Categorization Mechanism Knowledge Database (Toxicological pathways) Tissue Organ Body Response Molecular Level Receptor 1 – Receptor 2 – Receptor 3 – Receptor 4 –... System 1 – System 2 – System 3 – System 4 –... Effect 1 Effect 2 Effect 3 Effect 4... Functions Pathways Processes Chemistry/Biochemistry Expert observation
129
Contributors:
130
O. Mekenyan S. Dimitrov T. Pavlov G. Chankov A. Chapkanov Laboratory of mathematical Chemistry, Bourgas, Bulgaria
131
Chemical Management Center, NITE, Japan Case study on RDT of aromatic amines Chemical vs. toxicological mechanisms (Project of NEDO Japan) Jun Yamada Yuki Sakuratani
132
Fraunhofer Institute for Toxicology and Experimental Medicine, Department Chemical Risk Assessment, Hanover, Germany Data from REPDOSE Database (Project of CEFIC LRI) Inge Mangelsdorf Sylvia Escher Annette Bitsch
133
Environment Directorate, OECD, Paris Bob Diderich Terry Schultz
134
International QSAR Foundation, USA Gilman Veith
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.