Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Conical intersections in quantum chemistry

Published byBeryl Garrison Modified over 8 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Conical intersections in quantum chemistry"— Presentation transcript:

1 Conical intersections in quantum chemistry
Spiridoula Matsika Temple University Department of Chemistry Philadelphia, PA

2 Conical intersections Electronic structure methods for CIs
MRCI CIS(2) Three-state CIs and their consequences QM/MM for excited states

3 Nonadiabatic events in chemistry and biology

4 Molecular Hamiltonian
e2/rij j Z e2 /ri Z e2 /rj Z Z e2 /R

5 The Born-Oppenheimer (adiabatic) approximation
Separate the problem into an electronic and a nuclear part Nuclear Electronic

6 When electronic states approach each other, more than one of them should be included in the expansion Born-Huang expansion If the expansion is not truncated the wavefunction is exact since the set Ie is complete Derivative coupling

7 Two-state conical intersections
Two adiabatic potential energy surfaces cross (E=0).The interstate coupling is large facilitating fast radiationless transitions between the surfaces

8 The Noncrossing Rule The adiabatic eigenfunctions are expanded in terms of states I which are diagonal to all other states. (the superscript e is dropped here) The electronic Hamiltonian is built and diagonalized The eigenvalues and eigenfunctions are: J. von Neumann and E. Wigner, Phys.Z 30, 467 (1929) Atchity, Xantheas and Ruedenberg, J. Chem. Phys., 95, 1862, (1991)

9 Degeneracy H11(R)=H22 (R) H12 (R) =0 Dimensionality: Nint-2, where Nint is the number of internal coordinates

10 Geometric phase effect (Berry phase)
If the angle  changes from  to  +2: The electronic wavefunction is doubled valued, so a phase has to be added so that the total wavefunction is single valued

11 Evolution of conical intersections

12 The Branching Plane The Hamiltonian matrix elements are expanded in a Taylor series expansion around the conical intersection Then the conditions for degeneracy are For displacements x,y, along the branching plane the Hamiltonian becomes (sx,sy are the projections of onto the branching plane) : Atchity, Xantheas and Ruedenberg, J. Chem. Phys., 95, 1862, (1991) D. R. Yarkony, J. Phys. Chem. A, 105, 6277, (2001)

13 The Branching Plane E h g g-h or branching plane seam
Tuning coordinate: Coupling coordinate: Seam coordinates E h g g-h or branching plane seam

14 topography asymmetry tilt
Conical intersections are described in terms of the characteristic parameters g,h,s

15 Three-state conical intersections
Based on the same non-crossing rule one can derive the dimensionality of a three-state seam. Using a simple 3x3 matrix degeneracy between three eigenvalues is obtained if 5 conditions are satisfied. So the subspace where these conditions are satisfied is Nint - 5. H11(R)=H22 (R)= H33 H12 (R) = H13 (R) = H23 (R) =0 Dimensionality: Nint-5 J. von Neumann and E. Wigner, Phys.Z 30, 467 (1929) J. Katriel and E. Davidson, Chem. Phys. Lett. 76, 259, (1980) S. Matsika and D. R.Yarkony, J.Chem. Phys., 117, 6907, (2002)

16 Requirements of electronic structure methods for conical intersections
Accurate excited states Gradients for excited states Describe coupling Correct topography of conical intersections Correct description at highly distorted geometries (needed usually for S0/S1 conical intersections in closed shell molecules but not necessary for all ci) *

17 Excited states configurations
Doubly excited conf. Ground state Singly excited conf.

18 Configurations can be expressed as Slater determinants in terms of molecular orbitals. Since in the nonrelativistic case the eigenfunctions of the Hamiltoian are simultaneous eigenfunctions of the spin operator it is useful to use configuration state functions (CSFs)- spin adapted linear combinations of Slater determinants, which are eigenfunctiosn of S2 - + Triplet CSF Singlet CSF

19 Or in a mathematical language:
Slater determinant: Configuration state function:

20 Electronic structure methods for conical intersections
Multireference methods satisfy these requirements MCSCF and MRCI

21 Locate 2-state intersections
Additional geometrical constrains, Ki, , can be imposed. These conditions can be imposed by finding an extremum of the Lagrangian L (R,  , )= Ek + 1Eij + 2Eij + 3Hij + 4Hik + 5Hkj + iKi The algorithms are implemented in the COLUMBUS suite of programs. M. R. Maana and D. R. Yarkony, J. Chem. Phys.,99,5251,(1993) S. Matsika and D. R. Yarkony, J.Chem.Phys., 117, 6907, (2002) H. Lischka et al., J. Chem. Phys.,120, 7322, (2004)

22 Derivative coupling Similar to energy gradient

23 Geometric phase effect (Berry phase)
An adiabatic eigenfunction changes sign after traversing a closed loop around a conical intersection The geometric phase can be used for identification of conical intersections. If the integral below is  the loop encloses a conical intersection

24 Radiationless decay in DNA bases
Implications in photoinduced damage in DNA Absorption of UV radiation can lead to photocarcinogenesis DNA and RNA bases absorb UV light Bases have low fluorescence quantum yields and ultra-short excited state lifetimes Fast radiationless decay can prevent further photodamage Daniels and Hauswirth, Science, 171, 675 (1971) Kohler et al, Chem. Rev., 104, 1977 (2004)

25 Exploring the PES of excited states using electronic structure methods
State-averaged multiconfigurational self-consistent field (SA-MCSCF) Multireference configuration-interaction (MRCI) MRCI1: Single excitations from the CAS (~1 million CSFs) MRCI: Single excitations from CAS +  orbitals (~10-50 million CSFs) MRCI: Single and double excitations from CAS + single exc. from  orbitals ( million CSFs) Locate minima, transition states, and conical intersections Determine pathways that provide accessibility to conical intersections

26 Conical intersections in nucleic acid bases
Uracil Cytosine S. Matsika, J. Phys. Chem. A, 108, 7584, (2004) K. A. Kistler and S. Matsika, J. Phys. Chem. A, 111, 2650, (2007) K. A. Kistler and S. Matsika, Photochem. Photobiol.,83, 611, (2007)

27 Three-state intersections in DNA/RNA bases
In pyrimidines: In purines: They connect different two-state conical intersections

28 Three-state conical intersections in nucleobases
Three state ci Three state ci

29 Three-state conical intersections in cytosine
Multiple seams of three-state conical intersections were located for cytosine and 5M2P, an analog with the same pyrimidinone ring. S3 S2 S1 S0 ππ*/nNπ*/nOπ* GS gs/ππ*/nNπ* gs/ππ*/nOπ*

30 energy difference gradient vectors
coupling vectors The branching space for the S1-S2-S3 (*,n*,n*)(ci123) conical intersection. coupling vectors energy difference gradient vectors The branching space for the S1-S2-S3 (*,*,n*)(ci123’) conical intersection energy difference gradient vectors

31 The three-state ci012 are connected to two state seam paths and finally the Franck Condon region.
K. A. Kistler and S. Matsika, J. Chem. Phys. 128, , (2008)

32 Phase effects and 3-state Conical Intersections
Different pairs of 2-state CIs exist around a 3-state CI. Around a S0/S1/S2 CI there can be S0/S1 and S1/S2 CIs Loop f01 f12 f02 No CI + One (or odd #) S0/S1 + One (or odd #) S1/S2 - Keat and Meating, J. Chem. Phys., 82, 5102, (1985) Manolopoulos and Child, PRL, 82, 2223, (1999) Han and Yarkony, J. Chem. Phys., 119, 11561, (2003) Schuurman and Yarkony J. Chem. Phys., 124, , (2006)

33 We will now explore the phases on loops around the conical intersections that may or may not enclose a second ci K. A. Kistler and S. Matsika, J. Chem. Phys. 128, , (2008)

34 Derivative coupling:  constant

35 Plots of the derivative coupling along , f, the magnitude of f, and the energy of states S0, S1, and S2 for a loop around a regular two-state ci away from a three-state ci. |f20|

36 Energies along four branching plane loops around point D.

37 f01 f12 f02 No CI + One (or odd #) S0/S1 + One (or odd #) S1/S2 - 0.07

38 The magnitude of the derivative coupling is shown for four branching plane loops around point D. f10, f20, f21, with respect to  are plotted. Detail of c) above.

39 QM/MM for solvent effects

40 Including the solvent effects
Basics of QM/MM M: solvent charges i: electrons : nuclei

41 A Hybrid QM/MM approach using ab initio MRCI wavefunctions
Quantum Mechanics: MCSCF/ MRCISD using COLUMBUS Molecular Mechanics/Dynamics TINKER or MOLDY Coupling between QM-MM regions Averaged solvent electrostatic potential following the Martin et al. scheme Martin et al. J. Chem. Phys. 116, (2002), 1613

42 General scheme Solve Schrodinger Eq. HQM=E -> q0
Molecular dynamics -> average potential (HQM+HQM/MM)=E Compute energy and solute properties ( excitation energies)

43 Polarization Uncoupled method Polarization of solute:
Do not change the partial charges of the solute during the MD simulation Polarization of solute: Partial charges (Mulliken): MRCI initial: C , O , H final: , , MCSCF initial: , , final: , , Polarization of the solvent:

44 General scheme Solve Schrodinger Eq. HQM=E -> q0
Molecular dynamics -> average potential Until convergence (HQM+HQM/MM)=E -> q Compute energy and solute properties ( excitation energies)

45 Average electrostatic potential on a grid
f* Rvdw f=0.8 S0=1.2 Å S1=1.15 Å 4 shells 624 points S0 S1

46 qi Vj Grid A: inside the surface to calculate the solvent induced electrostatic potential Grid B: outside to obtain q Least squares fitting for q Error in fitting: 150 cm-1

47 Blueshift (cm-1) in formaldehyde
Exp: ~1700 cm-1 1A2 Exp.: eV MCSCF: eV MRCI: eV MCSCF/PCM 595 CASSCF/ASEP 1470 MRCISD/COSMO 1532 CCSD/MM(TIP3P) 2139 CCSD/MM(SPCpol) 2803 MRSDCI 1500 MCSCF 1580 MRSDCI(no solute pol) 970 CASSCF/MC CASSCF/MC (pol) 1A1 CAS+MRCI(4,3) /aug-cc-pvtz Z. Xu and S. Matsika, J. Phys. Chem. A,110, 12035, (2006)

48 Dipole moment shifts Gas phase Solution phase MCSCF MRCI exp
Method 1.66 0.38 MRCISD/COSMO 1.74 0.52 CASSCF/ASEP 2.270 1.305 CC2/MM(TIP3P) 2.306 0.982 CASSCF/MC 2.455 1.490 CC2/MM(SPCpol) 1.95 1.237 CCSD/MM(TIP3P) 2.683 1.420 CCSD/MM(SPCpol) 1.78 0.59 MCSCF/MM 2.597 0.67 MRCISD/MM /D /D Method 2.98 0.54 MRCISD/COSMO 3.00 0.65 CASSCF/ASEP 3.377 1.269 CASSCF/MC 3.442 1.206 CC2/MM(TIP3P) 3.597 1.187 CCSD/MM(TIP3P) 3.662 1.426 CC2/MM(SPCpol) 3.816 1.406 CCSD/MM(SPCpol) 2.91 0.64 MCSCF/MM 3.09 0.68 MRCISD/MM

49 Solvatochromic Shifts in Uracil
6.57 S3(nO’π*) 6.31 5.79 S2(ππ*) (=6.47 D) +0.41 (=2.67 D) Energy (eV) 4.80 S1 (nOπ*) S0 (=4.30 D) EOM-CCSD/MM: S1: eV, S2: eV (Epifanovsky et al., JPC A, (2008)

50 Solvatochromic shifts in Cytosine
+0.83 (=2.86 D) 5.93 nOp* (=2.93 D) 5.29 nNp* pp* +0.25 (=5.29 D) Energy/ eV (=6.14 D) EOM-CCSD/MM: S1: +0.25eV, S2: +0.57eV (Vallet and Kowalski, JCP,125, )

51 Conclusions Two- and Three-state conical intersections are ubiquitous in polyatomic molecules. Multireference configuration interaction electronic structure theory methods can be used to describe these features. Single reference methods are more challenging and varios problems need to be overcome Three-state conical intersections connect two-state seams Three-state conical intersections can affect couplings and possibly the dynamics. Phase changes can be used as signature for the presence of these conical intersections. A QM/MM method using MRCI wavefunctions can describe solvation effects on excited states

52 Acknowledgments Dr. ZongRong Xu Dr. Dimitri Laikov Kurt Kistler
Kandis Gilliard Madiyha Muhammad Benjamin Mejia Elizabeth Mburu Chris Kozak Financial support by: NSF CAREER Award DOE Temple University

Download ppt "Conical intersections in quantum chemistry"

Similar presentations

Introduction to Computational Chemistry NSF Computational Nanotechnology and Molecular Engineering Pan-American Advanced Studies Institutes (PASI) Workshop.

Introduction to Computational Chemistry NSF Computational Nanotechnology and Molecular Engineering Pan-American Advanced Studies Institutes (PASI) Workshop.
Wave function approaches to non-adiabatic systems

Wave function approaches to non-adiabatic systems
Understanding Complex Spectral Signatures of Embedded Excess Protons in Molecular Scaffolds Andrew F. DeBlase Advisor: Mark A. Johnson 68 th Internatinal.

Understanding Complex Spectral Signatures of Embedded Excess Protons in Molecular Scaffolds Andrew F. DeBlase Advisor: Mark A. Johnson 68 th Internatinal.
0 Jack SimonsJack Simons, Henry Eyring Scientist and Professor Chemistry Department University of Utah Electronic Structure Theory Session 7.

0 Jack SimonsJack Simons, Henry Eyring Scientist and Professor Chemistry Department University of Utah Electronic Structure Theory Session 7.
Well Defined and Accurate Semiclassical Surface Hopping Propagators and Wave Functions Michael F. Herman Department of Chemistry Tulane University New.

Well Defined and Accurate Semiclassical Surface Hopping Propagators and Wave Functions Michael F. Herman Department of Chemistry Tulane University New.
Biexciton-Exciton Cascades in Graphene Quantum Dots CAP 2014, Sudbury Isil Ozfidan I.Ozfidan, M. Korkusinski,A.D.Guclu,J.McGuire and P.Hawrylak, PRB89,085310.

Biexciton-Exciton Cascades in Graphene Quantum Dots CAP 2014, Sudbury Isil Ozfidan I.Ozfidan, M. Korkusinski,A.D.Guclu,J.McGuire and P.Hawrylak, PRB89,
Post Hartree-Fock Methods (Lecture 2)

Post Hartree-Fock Methods (Lecture 2)
Conical Intersections between Vibrationally Adiabatic Surfaces in Methanol Mahesh B. Dawadi and David S. Perry Department of Chemistry, The University.

Conical Intersections between Vibrationally Adiabatic Surfaces in Methanol Mahesh B. Dawadi and David S. Perry Department of Chemistry, The University.
Molecular Bonding Molecular Schrödinger equation

Molecular Bonding Molecular Schrödinger equation
Marco Caricato Molecular Spectroscopy Symposium Ohio State University, Columbus, OH June 23, 2011 Gaussian, Inc. Wallingford, CT Excitation energy in solution.

Marco Caricato Molecular Spectroscopy Symposium Ohio State University, Columbus, OH June 23, 2011 Gaussian, Inc. Wallingford, CT Excitation energy in solution.
Molecular Quantum Mechanics

Molecular Quantum Mechanics
Introduction to Molecular Orbitals

Introduction to Molecular Orbitals
Quantum Mechanics and Force Fields Hartree-Fock revisited Semi-Empirical Methods Basis sets Post Hartree-Fock Methods Atomic Charges and Multipoles QM.

Quantum Mechanics and Force Fields Hartree-Fock revisited Semi-Empirical Methods Basis sets Post Hartree-Fock Methods Atomic Charges and Multipoles QM.
Computational Chemistry

Computational Chemistry
1 Cold molecules Mike Tarbutt. 2 Outline Lecture 1 – The electronic, vibrational and rotational structure of molecules. Lecture 2 – Transitions in molecules.

1 Cold molecules Mike Tarbutt. 2 Outline Lecture 1 – The electronic, vibrational and rotational structure of molecules. Lecture 2 – Transitions in molecules.
Conical Intersections Spiridoula Matsika. The study of chemical systems is based on the separation of nuclear and electronic motion The potential energy.

Conical Intersections Spiridoula Matsika. The study of chemical systems is based on the separation of nuclear and electronic motion The potential energy.
Femtochemistry: A theoretical overview Mario Barbatti IV – Non-crossing rule and conical intersections This lecture can be.

Femtochemistry: A theoretical overview Mario Barbatti IV – Non-crossing rule and conical intersections This lecture can be.
Case Studies Class 5. Computational Chemistry Structure of molecules and their reactivities Two major areas –molecular mechanics –electronic structure.

Case Studies Class 5. Computational Chemistry Structure of molecules and their reactivities Two major areas –molecular mechanics –electronic structure.
Femtochemistry: A theoretical overview Mario Barbatti II – Transient spectra and excited states This lecture can be downloaded.

Femtochemistry: A theoretical overview Mario Barbatti II – Transient spectra and excited states This lecture can be downloaded.
The spectral method: time-dependent quantum dynamics of FHF - : Potential Energy Surface, Vibrational Eigenfunctions and Infrared Spectrum. Guillermo Pérez.

The spectral method: time-dependent quantum dynamics of FHF - : Potential Energy Surface, Vibrational Eigenfunctions and Infrared Spectrum. Guillermo Pérez.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google