1. co-funded by the European Union Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 Co-authored by: Tobias Blanke, Sally Chambers, Alastair Dunning, Stefan Gradmann, Jonathan Gray, Steffen Hennicke, Gerhard Lauer, Christian Morbidoni, Alois Pichler, Jürgen Renn, Laurent Romary, Felix Sasaki, Susan Schreibman, Claire Warwick

2. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 2 Overview What is the Scholarly Domain? What is 'Modeling'? What can be Gained from Formal Modeling? Where are the Limits of Formal Modeling?

3. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 3 The Scholarly Domain

4. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 4 A normative Model

5. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 5 A Car Model

6. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 A Model Car

7. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 7 A Model Airplane (an Airplane Model?)

8. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 8 A 'Structural' Model

9. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 9 A Process Model

10. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 10 A World Model

11. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 11 Model and Representation / Picturing

12. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 12 Model and Reduction / Abstraction Viertelfahr- zeugmodell

13. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 13 Kepler: the World for Kids Pragmatic Orientation of Models (1)

14. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 14 Pragmatic Orientation of Models (2) Einstein's Field Theory: The World for Physicists

15. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 15 Pragmatic Orientation of Models (3) The World as Conceptual Graph

16. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 16 A Construction Model

17. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 17 The V-Model (1)

18. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 18 Many V-Models (2)

19. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 19 The Generic V-Model (3)

20. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 20 An Interaction Model A Circle, two Triangles

21. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 21 Model vs. Metaphor: Atoms as modeled by Bohr – and the Universe as modeled by Copernicus

22. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 22 A mythical World Model

23. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 23 Between Myth and Representation

24. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 24 From Myth to Metaphor

25. Modeling the Scholarly Research and Collaboration Domain Stefan Gradmann, London, The British Library, Conference Center. 10/06/2013 25 6 Statements on Models. 1 Question Models do not represent “reality”, but rather a perspective of 'world'. Models are instructions for creating 'reality'. Models are selective: they operate on reduction and abstraction. Reduction and abstraction always are intentionally guided. 'Powerful' models often operate with substantial metaphoric, connotative and/or symbolic 'surplus'. In this perspective, works of art are eminently powerful models! Which are our intentions when modeling the scholarly domain?