1. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary1 DataGrid Security Workshop 29/30 March 2001 SUMMARY David Kelsey CLRC/RAL, UK d.p.kelsey@rl.ac.uk

2. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary2 Agenda – Day 1 Middleware Requirements –WP1M RudaCESnet –WP2B SegalCERN –WP3S FisherRAL –WP4L ConsCERN –WP5J GordonRAL Discussion and conclusions on middleware –M9 and longer term WP6: Testbed Certificate AuthoritiesD Kelsey/RAL –including efforts to agree on CA CP/CPS –plans for Testbed0/M9

3. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary3 Agenda – Day 2 (am) Experiment/Application requirements –WP8 - LHCbEric van HerwijnenCERN –WP8 - Alice, Atlas, CMSIngo AugustinCERN –WP9 - Earth ObservationNo input –WP10 - BiologyVincent BretonIN2P3 Site/Network Requirements Denise HeagertyCERN Work of the AAAARCH research group in the IRTF and possible emerging co-operation between GGF and IETF/IRTFCees deLaatUtrecht, NL Ideas for M9 authorisation –Tools from INFNFrancesco GiacominiINFN –Ideas for map filesAndrew McNabManchester

4. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary4 Agenda – Day 2 (pm) Discussion of Authorisation possibilities –For M9 –Longer term (CAS etc) Other M9 requirements –Audit? –Incident tracking? Plans for continuation of this work Summary and conclusions

5. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary5 Summary – Day 1 (M9) Authentication - GSI seems OK Some authorisation required –GIIS – will require MDS V3 – but not critical –Grid mapfile probably OK No requirement for groups? (probably yes) Tools to maintain and manage this –Job (re) submission – renew authorisation MyProxy may be useful List of appropriate clusters for WP1 WAN access to SE only by ReplicaManager –But users need more (e.g. remote database updates) Audit and Incident management?

6. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary6 Summary – Day 1 – long term Longer term Security very important – can we trust it? –Can we afford it? Warn PMB? Retain local control Authorisation the big problem to solve –Revocation of authorisation Policies – language? Accounting Audit Firewalls (& NAT?) DOS Incident monitoring, tracking etc.

7. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary7 WP8/9/10 requirements Single sign-on Authorisation, quotas, accounting –By role, by group Policies Encryption for WP10 Light-weight access for WP10 Web servlets for LHCb Long lived credentials

8. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary8 Site security requirements Denise’s slide: How to agree a common security policy across site boundaries? –national laws may differ, e.g privacy Are firewalls feasible at high data rates? –do we need common configurations across sites? How to detect intrusions? How to respond to incidents across sites? –blocking access, tracing break-ins, a GRID-CSIRT? What issues are raised by a grid-wide SSO? How do we protect access to resources? What are the time scales and priorities? –Are there already security issues for the Testbed?

9. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary9 AAAArch See Cees de Laat slides AAA Architecture

10. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary10 Tools for Grid Mapfile INFN –Users and Groups in LDAP –Tool to aid grid mapfile maintenance Gridmapdir patch to Globus (A McNab/Manchester) –Maps to generic accounts Babar001, babar002, atlas001 etc Leased (and expired?)

11. 10-May-01D.P.Kelsey, Security Workshop Summary11 Future plans WP6 Security concerns –Responsibility of Site managers, Security mgrs –CA – next meeting CERN 5 th June –Authentication, Authorisation –User/Group registration –Many management issues New Security task force –Coordinate activities in middleware WP’s –Identify missing resources –Architectural design (with ATF) –Propose meeting at CERN on 6 th June