1. Computing Ontology Part II

2. So far, We have seen the history of the ACM computing classification system – What have you observed? – What topics from CS2013 have you not been able to find in the 2012 CCS?

3. Another approach The Computing Ontology project – Funded by NSF 2003 – Goal to document the entirety of the computing disciplines – Make it useful for research classification, but also for curriculum development. Website: www.distributedexpertise.org/computingontology www.distributedexpertise.org/computingontology

4. Status Work suspended during the ACM CCS update effort Recently – comparing to CCS 2012 To do – compare to CS 2013

5. Overview A different approach; a work in progress Broader categories at the top level – Look at the context for each topic – Cluster things according to their context Spreadsheet color codes – Yellow: only in our ontology – Blue: only in ACM CCS – Grey: modified ontology to match CCS – Green: in both without need to modify either

6. Ontology categories Theory Organizational context Information and recollection Software design and development Computing infrastructure Interaction Societal context

7. Theory Computability Mathematical Foundations Algorithmic Concepts (Name???)

8. Organizational Context Requirements analysis and specification Management and acquisition of organizational IT capabilities Infrastructure management Security management Software project management

9. Information and Recollection File processing Database systems Data and information modeling Managing the database environment Business intelligence (name??) Storage and retrieval, unstructured or semi- structured information Web information (mining & searching)

10. Software design and development Algorithms and Data Structures in Programming Systems Development Domain methodologies – Search and constraint satisfaction – Agents – Natural Language Processing – AI Planning systems

11. Computing Infrastructure Computer and network hardware (include robotic hardware) Computer system organization Network and distributed system architectures and organization Data coding, I/O, communication Operating systems, network protocols

12. Interaction Graphics Visualization Interfaces Systems – Multimedia – Collaboration tools – Computer vision – Interaction devices – Robotics interaction

13. Societal Context History Policies – Intellectual property, privacy, etc User characteristics Professional ethics Professional practice Crime

14. How does CS 2013 fit? Repeat the exercise of Monday, but map CS 2013 topics to this taxonomy – Taxonomy vs ontology –