Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL PANEL RULES Stephen M. Kennedy Clyde & Co US LLP The Chrysler Building, 16 th Floor 405 Lexington Avenue New York, NY 10174 (212) 710-3935.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL PANEL RULES Stephen M. Kennedy Clyde & Co US LLP The Chrysler Building, 16 th Floor 405 Lexington Avenue New York, NY 10174 (212) 710-3935."— Presentation transcript:

1 ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL PANEL RULES Stephen M. Kennedy Clyde & Co US LLP The Chrysler Building, 16 th Floor 405 Lexington Avenue New York, NY 10174 (212) 710-3935 Stephen.Kennedy@clydeco.us

2 1 SECTIONS OF ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL RULES  INSTRUCTIONS FOR ADOPTION AND APPLICATION 1. INTRODUCTION 2. DEFINITIONS 3. NOTICE AND TIME PERIODS 4. COMMENCEMENT OF ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS 5. RESPONSE BY RESPONDENT 6. APPOINTMENT AND COMPOSITION OF PANEL 7. CONFIDENTIALITY 8. INTERIM DECISIONS 9. LOCATION OF PROCEEDINGS 10. PRE-HEARING PROCEDURE 11. DISCOVERY 12. SUMMARY DISPOSITION AND EX PARTE HEARING 13. ARBITRATION HEARING 14. FINAL AWARD

3 2 ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL RULES I.BASED ON STANDARD RULES (ARIAS U.S. RULES FOR RESOLUTION OF INSURANCE AND REINSURANCE DISPUTES) SIMILAR PROVISIONS IN BOTH SET OF RULES: RULES DO NOT SUPERSEDE ANY PROCEDURES AGREED UPON BY PARTIES THAT MAY ALTER OR BE DIFFERENT FROM THE RULES PRE-HEARING PROCEDURES RELATING TO THE ORGANIZATIONAL MEETING ─ POSITION STATEMENTS ─ HOLD HARMLESS ─ SETTING ARBITRATION SCHEDULE DISCOVERY RELATED PROCEDURES ─ EXCHANGE OF DOCUMENTS ─ DEPOSITIONS ─ PANEL DISCRETION TO LIMIT DISCOVERY

4 3 ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL RULES ARBITRATION HEARING ─ PANEL NOT OBLIGATED TO FOLLOW STRICT RULES OF LAW OR EVIDENCE ─ PANEL GENERALLY HAS DISCRETION TO DECIDE THE TYPE AND AMOUNT OF EVIDENCE ADMITTED INTO RECORD

5 II.WAYS IN WHICH NEUTRAL RULES ARE DIFFERENT 1. COMPOSITION OF PANEL i. NO PARTY ARBITRATORS ii. PANEL MEMBERS MUST BE “NEUTRAL” AS DEFINED BY RULES: a. DISINTERESTED, UNBIASED, AND IMPARTIAL; b. DOES NOT ADVOCATE FOR EITHER PARTY; AND c. ARIAS U.S. CERTIFIED NEUTRAL ARBITRATOR LIST (SECTION 2.2) – INDIVIDUALS WHO PLEDGE IN WRITING TO SERVE ONLY AS NEUTRAL ARBITRATORS AND WHO MEET ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL PANEL CRITERIA SET FORTH IN SECTION 6.3 AT TIME OF PLEDGE; OR 4 ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL RULES

6 5 d. MEET THE NEUTRAL CRITERIA IN SECTION 6.3 SECTION 6. 3: CANDIDATE CANNOT SERVE IF DURING PAST FIVE YEARS PREVIOUSLY SERVED  AS PARTY ARBITRATOR IN MATTERS FOR ONE OF THE PARTIES OR PARTIES’ LAW FIRMS AMOUNTING TO MORE THAN 10% OF TOTAL NUMBER OF PARTY ARBITRATOR APPOINTMENTS  AS UMPIRE IN MATTERS INVOLVING ONE OF THE PARTIES OR PARTIES’ LAW FIRMS AMOUNTING TO MORE THAN 20% OF TOTAL NUMBER OF UMPIRE APPOINTMENTS  AS EXPERT OR CONSULTANT IN MATTERS FOR ONE OF THE PARTIES OR PARTIES’ LAW FIRMS AMOUNTING TO MORE THAN 50% OF EMPLOYMENT AS AN EXPERT/CONSULTANT  AS COUNSEL OR FOR ONE OF THE PARTIES IN MATTERS AMOUNTING TO MORE THAN 10% OF EMPLOYMENT AS COUNSEL  AS EMPLOYEE BY ONE OF THE PARTIES

7 6 ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL RULES B.“PARTY” MEANS: (1) PARENTS, SUBSIDIARIES AND AFFILIATES WHOSE INSURANCE AND REINSURANCE DISPUTES ARE MANAGED BY SAME GROUP OF INDIVIDUALS THAT MANAGE THE NAMED PARTY’S INSURANCE OR REINSURANCE DISPUTES OR (2) A NON-AFFILIATED CLAIMS MANAGERS OR TPA 2.APPOINTMENT PROCESS A.EACH PARTY NOMINATES SIX CANDIDATES FROM ARIAS U.S. ARBITRATOR LIST OR CERTIFIED NEUTRAL ARBITRATOR LIST B.SEND NOMINEES TO ARIAS U.S. AND OTHER PARTY C.ARIAS U.S. SENDS NEUTRAL ARBITRATOR QUESTIONNAIRE TO CANDIDATES ON ARIAS U.S. ARBITRATOR LIST WHICH INCLUDES DISCLOSURES RELATING TO SECTION 6.3 D.CANDIDATES WHO ARE ON CERTIFIED NEUTRAL LIST SENT ARIAS U.S. UMPIRE QUESTIONNAIRE

8 7 ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL RULES E.ONCE THERE ARE 12 CANDIDATES WHO MEET NEUTRAL CRITERIA, EACH PARTY RANKS CANDIDATES 1-12 AND NOTIFIES ARIAS U.S. OF RANKINGS F.ARIAS U.S. WILL ADD TOGETHER THE PARTIES’ RANKINGS FOR EACH CANDIDATE G.THREE CANDIDATES WITH LOWEST SCORES WILL SERVE; THERE ARE CERTAIN TIE-BREAKING PROVISIONS H.THREE ARBITRATORS WILL SELECT THE CHAIR OF PANEL

9 8 ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL RULES 3. OTHER PROVISIONS A.IF SELECTED, ARBITRATORS CANNOT ACCEPT APPOINTMENT AS EXPERT/CONSULTANT, COUNSEL OR NON-NEUTRAL ARBITRATOR FOR EITHER PARTY B.NO EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS WITH ANY ARBITRATOR CANDIDATE BEFORE OR AFTER APPOINTMENT C.PARTIES SHARE EQUALLY IN COST OF THREE ARBITRATORS D.PANEL MUST ISSUE A REASONED DECISION E.PARTIES HAVE OPTIONS SET FORTH IN INSTRUCTIONS FOR ADOPTION AND APPLICATION 1)Adjust Neutral Criteria 2)Eliminate Requirement of Reasoned Decision


Download ppt "ARIAS U.S. NEUTRAL PANEL RULES Stephen M. Kennedy Clyde & Co US LLP The Chrysler Building, 16 th Floor 405 Lexington Avenue New York, NY 10174 (212) 710-3935."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google