1. Use Cases / Requirements Notes from 6/12/2007 Rockville, MD meeting

2. Frank Hartel (1) User Identification –Expertise –Domain Rights Assignment –Registration –Validation Targeted locks Blocks of Concepts (Harvest blocks, no individual) –What is the criterion for creating a block? Hierarchical authority

3. Frank Hartel (2) Lead can mark concept as “Ready” Status of concept (in Progress, not started, etc) Add Concepts and tree them – Form Modify concepts and tree changes – Form Suggest New Class property, annotation, type, etc. - Form Report of History of concept – format and dialog Restore Wiki if Corrupted WYSWYG Editing/Ajax completion support Voting support – to resolve contention.

4. Frank Hartel (3) Karma, WikiPedia & good/bad behavior Voting for contributor by users and other contributors Wiki to Protégé

5. Frank Hartel (4) Wiki Is Public –Register saying who you are, how to get a hold of you, bio –Indicate which domains you want to be able to edit –NCI provides logon identity, including rights for domain Assignment – everyone starts out as contributor, one of them morphs into lead. “Lead” – can change the state of a review process to complete –Weekly – “harvest” complete records, run through export and put into Protégé as part of workflow –Concepts marked as complete are locked – no further work can occur

6. Hartel/Chute Annotations in WIKI are wholesale imported into corresponding annotation space in Protégé –Need to test whether history can live independent of the terminology (Collaborative Protégé) Annotations are assigned status within Protégé Re-import through back-end repository will carry modified annotations into wiki.

7. Chris Chute Hierarchical Authority Federated namespaces –Namespace –Wiki Some dialogs need to be off limits (e.g. dialog about competence/etc. of ) –Notion of restricted meta discussion

8. Gilberto Fragossio Change history of concept Discussion history as part of collaboration Needs to be accessible in Wiki

9. Secondary Requirements Ability to lock for off-wiki edits Ability to record version that was being seen when the editing occurred –Ability to detect/flag out of date edits –Ability to uniquely identify edits for export and import Wiki export (english + (?template? ?RDF?))

10. Secondary Figure out how Wikipedia manages authority structure Investigate talk pages Flesh out domains in NCI Thesaurus –Start w/ Kinds as first approximation –Parsia (Hendler’s group) – topological grouping (e-connections) –Appeared to be congruent w/ Kinds

11. Issues How much writing within the wiki itself?