1. Going Forward: Year 2 NMI and Higher Ed Middleware

2. Agenda Assessment of CAMP Assessment of processes web site, email lists, virtual briefings, meetings (session and preconference options) Going Forward NMI – Year 2 Higher Ed Middleware Take-aways

3. NMI-EDIT Participation and Resources Websites NMI: nsf-middleware.org NMI-EDIT: www.nmi-edit.org Internet2:middleware.internet2.edu EDUCAUSE: www.educause.edu Refer to the websites for more information on email lists Education and Workshops CAMPs Presentations and tutorials Working groups Renee Frost (rwfrost@internet2.edu) participation@nmi-edit.org Questions, requests, comments… Ann West (awest@educause.edu)

4. CAMP Assessment Content too lofty/pretty fine/too detailed too intense/fine/more too immediate/fine/too long range political/technical balance Format panels? Presentations? Hand waving? Others? break into workgroups? bofs? Facilities location (global, local) wireless

5. Process Assessment web site (public and private/shared) email lists virtual briefings meetings (session and preconference options) Other ideas? Volunteer mechanisms

6. Going Forward NMI Higher Ed Middleware Virtual Organizations – identifier crosswalks, etc PKI - HEBCA, CREN CA, S/MIME, SEVIS GGF – what role for the enterprise? (security, accounting) Shibboleth 1.0+ and FOO Upperware – video, DRM, common calendars Affiliated directories AuthZ Centralized Services

7. NMI – The Process Releases approximately every six months – next one (Release 2) Oct 27, 2002 Will continue to be a mix of software (programs and objectclasses), good practices and recommendations, and architectural whitepapers May be an opportunity to announce services (bridge CA’s, registries, etc.) as well GridsCenter anticipates some (relatively modest) enhancements to Globus Toolkit 2.0, no OGSA EDIT Team anticipates Shibboleth 1.0 (RM 0.5,ARPManager 0.5), eduOrg, Pubcookie 3.0, LDAP Analyzer, Architectural Papers in Video, Digital Rights Management, etc. Integration? Leveraging Campus Infrastructure in Grids?

8. Objectclasses in R2 eduPerson 1.5 final eduOrg 1.0 final, eduOrg 1.5 experimental VoDendPoint 1.0 experimental Status of docs draft – in the works, grist for the mill experimental – consensus by work group (e.g. Mace-dir) rpr – released for public review; vetted fully within I2 community final – as good as it gets (international, corporate, broader higher ed commentary)

9. Virtual Organizations Grid experiments, digital library consortiums, Internet2 VideoCommons, etc. Share real (realm-based) resources among a sparse set of (interrealm) users Requirements for authentication and authorization, resource discovery, etc need to leverage federated and hierarchical infrastructures.

10. Support services for VO’s Centralized unique vo names and associated namespaces, objectclasses required trust model items (cert profiles, roots, etc.) … At origin enterprises enterprise-wide app directories local security to vo security local directory mods At the target enterprises agency requirements

11. PKI SEVIS HEBCA next steps CREN CA next steps S/MIME Server side issues Open-Source CA’s

12. Global Grid Forum Is GGF a standards organization for us? a way to internationalize academic objclasses, PKI enablement, etc. Is GGF a standards organization against us? security? accounting? web services? Is GGF a standards organization? can it be effective? can it define appropriate scope? What will we do if a Grid lands on campus?

13. Shibboleth 1.0 and FOO Pilots start almost immediately Next three months Completion of coding, security testing, performance enhancements, monitoring tools Serious work on resource managers and attribute release managers Architecting a fuller vision of resource managers and attribute management Shib 1.0 + FOO (federating organizations organization) to discuss the hard issues of multiple federations, subclubs, implementation, etc.

14. Upperware Video slowness in H.323 land a coming to grips in SIP space open clients and proxies DRM the workshop an architectural white paper in the fall Common calendars? Portals? OKI?

15. Got AuthZ? Role-based group-implemented access controls promote the Stanford work An enhanced model of the target side PDP PEP policy languages rights languages etc

16. What Centralized Services are Needed? A Sector CA? Higher Ed Bridge CA? Cert stores? UDDI host? Name Spaces? For what names (docs, attributes, Registries for Clubs for Virtual Organizations for Objectclasses

17. Take-aways Wireless authn/z done via forcing a web browser to a DMZ net Server-side PKI to solve immediate needs and get our feet wet El Dupe not yet dead Flashing twelves can drive a training curve Shib is gaining traction in the library community State diagrams and transition rules for account management are excellent tools IPSEC and VPN’s in the wireless space End-entity PKI still not nigh Identity Management falls to those that need IT File sharing needs are still strong Pay for printing is a rat hole

18. Takeaways Librarians like us and we like them cause they understand and promote privacy sampleUperson installed in many places RBAC is viable and a win Registries and underlying databases help the management of directories The community remains interested and committed. We’re not telling the story well