1. GENESIS OF I/UCRC EVALUATORS Process began at the NSF with Alex Schwarzkopf in the early 1980’s Process began at the NSF with Alex Schwarzkopf in the early 1980’s Alex wanted a measurement of the performance of I/UCRC centers Alex wanted a measurement of the performance of I/UCRC centers Denis Gray was recommended to Alex by an NSF manager who directed a program to study innovation Denis Gray was recommended to Alex by an NSF manager who directed a program to study innovation Thus began a long relationship with N.C. State University and Dr. Denis Gray Thus began a long relationship with N.C. State University and Dr. Denis Gray The I/UCRC Program has as its primary mission to build research partnerships between Universities and Industry. Evaluators collect data to measure this success The I/UCRC Program has as its primary mission to build research partnerships between Universities and Industry. Evaluators collect data to measure this success

2. NSF PERSPECTIVE Why Evaluators?? To answer questions of program accountability To answer questions of program accountability Build data base of accomplishments and to provide historical perspective Build data base of accomplishments and to provide historical perspective To give important feedback to NSF Program Directors To give important feedback to NSF Program Directors Provide data to assist in NSF budget requests from Congress Provide data to assist in NSF budget requests from Congress To develop a background of data to assist in the justification for the I/UCRC Program To develop a background of data to assist in the justification for the I/UCRC Program

3. NSF PERSPECTIVE Expectations of Evaluators To arrange for all necessary data collection required by the NSF or requested by the N.C. State group To arrange for all necessary data collection required by the NSF or requested by the N.C. State group Attend IAB meetings and manage the collection of feedback by use of LIFE forms Attend IAB meetings and manage the collection of feedback by use of LIFE forms Provide a summary of information collected from the LIFE forms to the IAB for review at the meeting Provide a summary of information collected from the LIFE forms to the IAB for review at the meeting Collect any additional data as requested by Center Director or N.C. State group Collect any additional data as requested by Center Director or N.C. State group Send out and collect all survey information requested Send out and collect all survey information requested

4. NSF PERSPECTIVE What is not Expected To be technically competent to assess research quality or performance within the center To be technically competent to assess research quality or performance within the center To take a managerial role in the center To take a managerial role in the center To be responsible for recruitment of center industry members To be responsible for recruitment of center industry members To develop policy or operational procedures for the center To develop policy or operational procedures for the center To make IAB meeting arrangements and develop the agenda To make IAB meeting arrangements and develop the agenda

5. NSF PERSPECTIVE The Value of Evaluators The information collected and made available in summary form is extremely valuable to the NSF The information collected and made available in summary form is extremely valuable to the NSF The annual reports are used frequently and extensively by Program Directors and Division Management at the NSF The annual reports are used frequently and extensively by Program Directors and Division Management at the NSF Provides an amazing historical data base that gives a long term projection of trends Provides an amazing historical data base that gives a long term projection of trends The I/UCRC Evaluators Program has built a high level of confidence in the evaluators at the NSF The I/UCRC Evaluators Program has built a high level of confidence in the evaluators at the NSF