Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Lyndsay Macrae Leanne Taylor. The ‘Big Three’ Discourses  Kailyard – sentimental and nostalgic representation of rural Scotland with no real issues or.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Lyndsay Macrae Leanne Taylor. The ‘Big Three’ Discourses  Kailyard – sentimental and nostalgic representation of rural Scotland with no real issues or."— Presentation transcript:

1 Lyndsay Macrae Leanne Taylor

2 The ‘Big Three’ Discourses  Kailyard – sentimental and nostalgic representation of rural Scotland with no real issues or problems.  Tartanry – romanticised depictions of Scotland usually featuring noble highlanders in beautiful highland landscapes.  Clydesideism – Focused on West Scotland, typically features hardworking Scottish men in urban settings.

3 “at a societal level it provides a reflection of cultural norms, social structures and ideologies. At the individual level it is an important element in shaping experiences and in moulding relationships between people and places“ Malcomson (1985)

4 "evoke images as contrary as Glasgow hard men and prim Edinburgh lawyers; Clyde shipbuilders and rural, very proper Presbyterian villagers; plucky Gaels and ruddy-cheeked, whisky-swilling Highlanders in ridiculous plaid dress….. Yet, while all of these images seem to be recognizably 'Scottish,' they do little justice to everyday Scotland, even while they retain a very real role in preserving many Scots' sense of their own national identity." Bicket (1998)

5 Discourse Problems  Iron Cage Constantly reiterated = strengthening  Reductionist; Does not reflect contemporary Scottish life. ○ Formulaic ○ Stereotypical ○ Out-of-date

6 "the role of mythology, legend and fable, the gothic, the supernatural and the unconcious within the development of the Scottish imagination is not a symptom of psychosis but a sophisticated engagement with the fantastic that other cultures might celebrate as magic realism“ Whyte (1995)

7

8 Fixing the Discourse Problem  Introducing a mixture of tradition discourses and bringing in modern, up- to-date images of Scotland.  This would allow images of Scotland to remain easy to identify but make it a more realistic representation of Scottish life.


Download ppt "Lyndsay Macrae Leanne Taylor. The ‘Big Three’ Discourses  Kailyard – sentimental and nostalgic representation of rural Scotland with no real issues or."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google