Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byGarry Adams Modified over 9 years ago
1
Introduction Results and Conclusions Analyses of demographic and social variables revealed that women were more likely to have children, be living in a group or institutional setting, and had higher levels of legal involvement. By contrast, men were older and had higher homelessness rates. In the areas of substance use and psychosocial problems, men were more likely to use alcohol as a primary substance, had more years of primary substance use, and reported more problem days related to substance use relative to women. Women more often used powder cocaine, crack, and opiates as primary substances and reported more problem days related to medical, employment, family, social, and psychological issues at admission to treatment. Although women had been using their primary substances for a shorter period of time than men, they displayed evidence of greater substance use severity; higher proportions of women reported engaging in polysubstance use and daily use of primary substances over the past six months. Further, there were no differences between men and women in age of first substance use or substance abuse treatment history, suggesting that women entered treatment more quickly than men after initiating substance use. Comparisons among diagnostic categories revealed that women had higher rates of posttraumatic stress disorder but no gender differences were found in the rates of other non- substance use disorders. On psychiatric measures, men displayed greater levels of psychiatric severity on standardized self-report and clinician ratings in the areas of phobic anxiety, paranoia, and psychoticism. At discharge, analyses of ancillary service use indicated that men received more types of services and were more likely to receive housing, food assistance, transportation, and peer mentoring, whereas women more frequently obtained medical care and prescription services. No gender differences were found in length of stay, treatment completion, or abstinence rates at termination of treatment. Consistent with previous findings in the SMI population, the current analyses revealed that women were more likely to have children, had higher rates of posttraumatic stress disorder, displayed higher medical problems, and reported more psychosocial problem compared to men. Contrary to past results, however, women were more likely to be legally involved relative to men and reported comparable rates of alcohol and other substance related arrests during the past year. Further, the results of this study did not support trends noted in other studies in which men tended to display greater severity in substance use and women in psychiatric symptoms. In this sample, men displayed greater severity on psychiatric measures and received a wider array of ancillary services, yet reported less social and psychological problem days at admission to treatment compared to women. Conversely, females presented relatively greater substance use severity but reported higher levels of psychosocial distress and less problems related to substance use. These findings suggest that a differential pattern of awareness may exist regarding the effects of psychiatric and substance use severity on life functioning, with males more readily admitting to problems related to substance use and females more open to acknowledging the effects of social and psychiatric problems. The possible presence of differential gender effects on client reporting has significant clinical implications for the assessment process and highlights the importance of using a variety of measures and informant sources to corroborate the client’s problem presentation. In addition, gender differences in problem awareness may also indicate the need for treatment programming and interventions tailored toward increasing recognition of the broader and interactive effects of substance use and psychiatric problems on social functioning. Acknowledgements Presented at the Research Society on Alcoholism Conference, Baltimore, Maryland, June 26, 2006 Demographic and Social Characteristics Problem Days Past Month at Admission Ancillary Services Received Treatment History and Substance Use The co-occurrence of psychiatric and substance use disorders (COPSD) and the effects of comorbidity on the clinical presentation and outcomes of substance abuse treatment are growing areas of study. Early studies in this area focused on severely mentally ill (SMI) populations and led to the development of specialized integrated treatment programs for these clients. As research progresses, studies are focusing on identifying client characteristics that may be associated with clinical features and outcomes. In this line of research, gender has been explored as a potential factor affecting symptom presentation and treatment response in COSPD clients with SMI. Studies to date suggest that women are more likely to have children, a greater history of victimization and associated traumatic stress, more medical problems, and may be more willing or able to identify relationship and psychiatric problems, whereas men tend to have higher levels of legal involvement. Findings in the area of substance use and psychiatric severity are inconsistent but trends suggest that men may present more severe substance use symptoms and women greater psychiatric distress. These extant studies, however, are limited to COPSD clients with SMI and may not generalize to individuals with non-severe co-occurring psychiatric disorders. The current study examines gender differences in a sample of COPSD clients entering substance abuse treatment that includes both severe and non-severe mental illnesses. The purpose of the study is to determine if gender characteristics in this sample, containing a wider array of psychiatric disorders, are similar to those found in previous studies of SMI populations. The authors acknowledge the Texas Department of State Health Services (TDSHS), Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services Division for their assistance in providing data for this study. We also acknowledge the treatment providers participating in the COSIG project for contributing client data and recognize their continuing efforts to enhance services for clients with co-occurring disorders. The findings and conclusions of this in this presentation are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official position of TDSHS. Sample and Method The sample consisted of 213 clients entering substance abuse treatment who subsequently qualified for the Texas Co-Occurring State Incentive Grant (COSIG) based on the presence of a comorbid non-substance use disorder determined though the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI). The sample was recruited between March 2005 and January 2006 from six state-funded substance abuse treatment programs participating in the COSIG project. The total sample was 60% male, 53% Hispanic, 41% White, and 7% Black. Men and women were compared on demographic variables, MINI psychiatric diagnoses, substance use characteristics, psychiatric severity, ancillary services, and treatment characteristics. Psychiatric severity measures included the Brief Symptom Inventory (client report) and the Brief Derogatis Psychiatric Rating Scale (clinician rating). Demographic, substance use, and treatment characteristics data were obtained from the Behavioral Health Integrated Provider System (BHIPS), which is the mandatory data collection and outcomes monitoring system for state-funded substance abuse treatment providers in the state of Texas. One component of the COSIG project consists of a voucher program designed to provide ancillary services to COPSD clients to support the treatment and recovery process. Data regarding COSIG voucher services received were also available from BHIPS. Continuous variables were analyzed using between groups t-tests and categorical variables were assessed using X 2 analyses. Diagnostic Characteristics COPSD Client Characteristics Psychiatric Severity Gender Differences in Alcohol and Drug Use Severity and Psychopathology in Clients with Co-Occurring Disorders Laurel Mangrum, Richard Spence & Michelle Steinley-Bumgarner University of Texas at Austin, Addiction Research Institute
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.