1. Using Formal Deliverable Certification to Support Line of Sight Southeast Alaska Network May 4, 2015

2. Line of Sight

3. Failed technology circa 1995

4. Failed technology circa 2005

5. The great hope in 2015

6. SEAN’s Information Model

7. All information products must be identified and defined in the protocol

8. Formal certification criteria are established

9. Criteria are established for all deliverables – not only tabular data

10. Validation apps report on compliance to criteria  KM_D Validation Findings for Submission 439 Begun Wednesday, December 05, 2012 6:28 PM Checking \\inpglbafs03\data\SEAN_Data\staging\KM\KM_D\439\$temp\KM_D_2012.csv Optional: at line 4922: ANGLE (60) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 6524: ANGLE (60) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 9904: ANGLE (325) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 13510: GROUP_SIZE (38) is usually between 1 and 24. Optional: at line 15789: ANGLE (300) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 22016: DISTANCE (1) is usually between 10 and 300. Optional: at line 22840: ANGLE (65) is usually between 70 and 290. ** MANDATORY at line 24081: SPECIES (P) must be K, M, or U. Optional: at line 38099: ANGLE (60) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 39680: ANGLE (300) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 40023: ANGLE (60) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 40557: ANGLE (60) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 41056: ANGLE (20) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 45889: ANGLE (65) is usually between 70 and 290. Optional: at line 46217: GROUP_SIZE (29) is usually between 1 and 24....Total lines: 49,541 of which 49,540 are data, 1 are column headings, and 0 are blank. Files having mandatory errors: 1 Files having optional errors: 14 Total CSV files that were checked:1 The submission status has been updated to "F" - Failed. ----- Validation attempt ended at Wednesday, December 05, 2012 6:28 PM -----

11. Mandatory criteria are enforced by the back end  ALTER TABLE km.tbl_km_observation  ADD CONSTRAINT ck_km_observation_angle  CHECK ( [angle] IS NULL  OR ( [angle] >= 0 AND [angle]<=359 ) )  GO

12. Program leaders and data managers are restricted to specific domains

13. The certification dance

14. Each dance is documented in writing

15. And our monitoring products achieve immortality Well, at least they’ll be available for longer than your expert monitoring program staff.