1. When do you think this photo was taken? Think about an explanation for your answer.

2. Your name is Lisa and you are fifteen. You are living in a small town in German occupied France during the Second World War. You live with your parents and two younger siblings, Thomas (9 years old) and Rebecca (11 years old). Your father is the only local doctor and people in the village depend on him. It is late November 1943 when one of your school friends knocks on your bedroom window late one evening, just as you are about to fall asleep. You know his father has links to the anti-German resistance. He tells you that he has been sent by his father who knows of a Jewish family that has managed to elude the German police authorities, but needs to find a new safe house. Your family are respected and trusted by the local community as well as the German authorities, and the Jewish family has nowhere else to go. Will you shelter them? Holocaust Dilemma

3. Questions for discussion What makes this a dilemma? What are the key issues that might influence a decision? Does this dilemma resemble something you might have encountered before? In what ways?

4. Outline of enquiry process 1.Read and discuss dilemma in class. 2.In your groups, find the wisest possible solution to the dilemma. Remember there is no one “right” answer to the dilemma and each group might come up with a different solution or might change their solution at any point. 3.In your groups, answer the questions on each web sheet. This will help structure your discussion. You will have about 10 minutes per web sheet and feed back to the class after the first one. 4.In your groups, make sure to stay on task and listen/talk to each other respectfully. 5.Feedback your group decision to the class. Talk about what you decided to do and why you made this choice. 6.Complete feedback questionnaire.