1. 1 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES 1 SLC and the Sawtooth (from grad student’s perspective) Boris Podobedov NSLS Robert H.Siemann Symposium July 7, 2009

2. 22 Background I graduated from Moscow Inst. of Physics & Technology, MS in Physics, summer of 1993 I enrolled in Stanford Ph.D. program in Appl. Phys., fall 1993 I knew nothing about accelerators or acc. physics In October 1993 I met Bob Siemann … I became the first grad student of Bob at Stanford/SLAC I spent 6 years working on my PhD under Bob’s guidance These were truly exciting times to be here SLC operations and the mystery of the saw-tooth instability ARDB formation, rapid growth, expansion into new research areas Great people and creative and stimulating environment

3. 33 Professor AP 324: Introduction to Accelerator Physics

4. 44 First Paper Together

5. 55 Saw-tooth Instability History

6. 66 Instability after Vacuum Chamber Replacement At Bob’s suggestion this became a topic of my PhD Mysteries remained: Effect on the beam Effect on SLC, if any Instability mechanism and cause

7. 77 Detecting Instability Signals Clearly a better diagnostics was needed

8. 88 Accelerator Physics Through Building Your Own Diagnostics

9. 99 New Diagnostics Works Out We finally got the t-domain instability signal. We could now combine it with the streak camera

10. 10 Saw-Tooth Instability: Main Results Recover complete phase- space picture Unstable mode contains ~3% of the beam Detector signals correlated with SLC beam downstream

11. 11 PhD Thesis Writing Bob strongly believed that thesis writing is essential part of graduate education Writing required many iterations Huge effort from Bob

12. 12 What Those Theses Meant for Bob

13. 13 Graduation and Beyond I moved to BNL in Sept 1999 We kept in touch discussing topics ranging from PRST-AB to his grad. students, and of course, Science My last meeting with Bob was on my SLAC visit in Feb 2007 … Graduation ceremony, July 1999