Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Legal and Documentalistic Subelements Remarks on Biagioli`s Concept of Legal Provisions V Legislative XML Workshop Towards European standards for legislative.

Published byShanon Rogers Modified over 9 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Legal and Documentalistic Subelements Remarks on Biagioli`s Concept of Legal Provisions V Legislative XML Workshop Towards European standards for legislative."— Presentation transcript:

1 Legal and Documentalistic Subelements Remarks on Biagioli`s Concept of Legal Provisions V Legislative XML Workshop Towards European standards for legislative documents and knowledge Italy, Florence, 14 – 16 June 2006 by Harald Hoffmann - Friedrich Lachmayer METADAT A-1110 Vienna, Simmeringer Hauptstraße 24

2 Carlo Biagioli structures legal texts by creating subelements (“provisions”). This methodical approach is effective as it provides for specific results (e.g. deontic consequences). Our contribution tries to differentiate between legal and documentalistic subelements. Target is to achieve a synthesis between them, resulting in a new concept of legal acts and their subelements, a new role of legal ontologies, enabling automatic generation of consequences, and in a more comfortable user interface.

3 Legal Act Text Meaning

4 Legal Act Interpretation Text Meaning

5 Legal Act eDocument Text Meaning

6 Legal Act eDocument Text Meaning

7 Legal Act eDocument Text Meaning

8 Legal Act eDocument Text Meaning

9 Legal Act

10 Provision legal Text Meaning Legal Subelements

11 Legal Act how to create the subset? ex ante – ex post Legal Subelements Provision legal Text Meaning

12 Text Meaning Text “Article”“Legal Term”

13 eDocument Text Meaning

14 Documentalistic Subelements Provision documentalistic Text Meaning eDocument

15 Documentalistic Subelements Provision documentalistic Text Meaning eDocument how to create the subset? ex ante – ex post

16 Text Meaning Text “Article”“Legal Term” Meaning

17 Legal Act eDocument Text Meaning

18 Legal Act eDocument Provision documentalistic Text Meaning Provision legal Text Meaning

19 Legal Act eDocument Provision documentalistic Text Meaning Provision legal Text Meaning

20 Ontology of Norms Ontology of eDocuments Legal Act eDocument Provision documentalistic Text Meaning Provision legal Text Meaning

21 Ontology of Norms Ontology of eDocuments Ontology of doc. Provisions Ontology of leg. Provisions Legal Act eDocument Provision documentalistic Text Meaning Provision legal Text Meaning

22 Ontology of Norms Ontology of eDocuments Ontology of doc. Provisions Ontology of leg. Provisions Legal Act eDocument Provision documentalistic Text Meaning Provision legal Text Meaning

23 Ontology of Norms Ontology of eDocuments Ontology of doc. Provisions Ontology of leg. Provisions Metasystem Legal Act eDocument Provision documentalistic Text Meaning Provision legal Text Meaning

24 Legal Act eDocument Provision documentalistic Text Meaning Provision legal Text Meaning

25 Legal Act eDocument synth. Provision Text Meaning Proposal for Diskussion:

26 Ontology of Norms Ontology of eDocuments Ontology of synthetical Provisions Legal Act eDocument synth. Provision Text Meaning

27 Ontology of Norms Ontology of eDocuments Ontology of synthetical Provisions Metasystem Legal Act eDocument synth. Provision Text Meaning

28 Legal Act eDocument synth. Provision Text Meaning

29 Legal ActeDocument synth. Provision Text Meaning Potential Direction: Synthesis of Entities

30 Legal Act = eDocument Text Meaning Legal ActeDocument synth. Provision

31 Text Meaning Automatic Generation of Consequences Legal ActeDocument synth. Provision Proposal for Diskussion:

32 Ontologies Legal ActeDocument synth. Provision Automatic Generation of Consequences

33 Ontologies Legal ActeDocument synth. Provision Automatic Generation of Consequences

34 Ontologies Legal ActeDocument synth. Provision User Automatic Generation of Consequences

35 Ontologies Legal ActeDocument synth. Provision User Automatic Generation of Consequences

36 Comfortable User Interface New Concept of Legal Acts Legal Ontology and Provisions Automatic Generation of Consequences

37 Harald.Hoffmann @metadat.com Friedrich.Lachmayer @ metadat.com

Download ppt "Legal and Documentalistic Subelements Remarks on Biagioli`s Concept of Legal Provisions V Legislative XML Workshop Towards European standards for legislative."

Similar presentations

Units of Measure - How many standards?. 2 What is a standard? A standard is nothing more than an agreement across a particular community of interest,

Units of Measure - How many standards?. 2 What is a standard? A standard is nothing more than an agreement across a particular community of interest,
ASSESSMENT ISSUES An EU Perspective Ladislav Miko Director, Protecting the Natural Environment, DG Environment, European Commission.

ASSESSMENT ISSUES An EU Perspective Ladislav Miko Director, Protecting the Natural Environment, DG Environment, European Commission.
EIONET ANNUAL WORKSHOP Session 1 Streamlining the data – Towards a shared Water Information System for Europe Water Framework Directive Reporting Sheets.

EIONET ANNUAL WORKSHOP Session 1 Streamlining the data – Towards a shared Water Information System for Europe Water Framework Directive Reporting Sheets.
1 European Union Regional Policy – Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion Draft guidance on monitoring and evaluation 2014-2020: Concepts and recommendations.

1 European Union Regional Policy – Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion Draft guidance on monitoring and evaluation : Concepts and recommendations.
4. Workshop on Legislative XML Bericht von Harald Hoffmann & Friedrich Lachmayer 18. 11. 2005 4. Workshop on Legislative XML Bericht von Harald Hoffmann.

4. Workshop on "Legislative XML Bericht von Harald Hoffmann & Friedrich Lachmayer Workshop on "Legislative XML Bericht von Harald Hoffmann.
Legislative Business Processes Klagenfurt Legislative Informatics Harald Hoffmann - Friedrich Lachmayer 2005-11-18.

Legislative Business Processes Klagenfurt Legislative Informatics Harald Hoffmann - Friedrich Lachmayer
CHARMCATS: Harmonisation demands for source metadata and output management CESSDA Expert Seminar: Towards the CESSDA- ERIC common Metadata Model and DDI3.

CHARMCATS: Harmonisation demands for source metadata and output management CESSDA Expert Seminar: Towards the CESSDA- ERIC common Metadata Model and DDI3.
Semiautomatic Generation of Data-Extraction Ontologies Master’s Thesis Proposal Yihong Ding.

Semiautomatic Generation of Data-Extraction Ontologies Master’s Thesis Proposal Yihong Ding.
IVITA Workshop Summary Session 1: interactive text analytics (Session chair: Professor Huamin Qu) a) HARVEST: An Intelligent Visual Analytic Tool for the.

IVITA Workshop Summary Session 1: interactive text analytics (Session chair: Professor Huamin Qu) a) HARVEST: An Intelligent Visual Analytic Tool for the.
Automatic Evaluation of Migration Quality in Distributed Networks of Converters Miguel Ferreira Supervisors Ana Alice Baptista.

Automatic Evaluation of Migration Quality in Distributed Networks of Converters Miguel Ferreira Supervisors Ana Alice Baptista.
A Flexible Workbench for Document Analysis and Text Mining NLDB’2004, Salford, June 23-25 2004 1 Gulla, Brasethvik and Kaada A Flexible Workbench for Document.

A Flexible Workbench for Document Analysis and Text Mining NLDB’2004, Salford, June Gulla, Brasethvik and Kaada A Flexible Workbench for Document.
ICT TOOLS AND SOCIETY INVOLVEMENT AMONG THE EUPAN NETWORK HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE SURVEY RESULTS TANYA CHETCUTI EUROPEAN COMMISSION.

ICT TOOLS AND SOCIETY INVOLVEMENT AMONG THE EUPAN NETWORK HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE SURVEY RESULTS TANYA CHETCUTI EUROPEAN COMMISSION.
OntoWeb SIG 2: Ontology Language Standards Heiner Stuckenschmidt Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam With contributions from: Ian Horrocks and Frank van Harmelen.

OntoWeb SIG 2: Ontology Language Standards Heiner Stuckenschmidt Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam With contributions from: Ian Horrocks and Frank van Harmelen.
EMayor Confidential ProprietaryIST Priority - No 507217 Venue:Bolzano Author(s): Nineta Polemi ( ) Organisations: University of Pireus.

EMayor Confidential ProprietaryIST Priority - No Venue:Bolzano Author(s): Nineta Polemi ( ) Organisations: University of Pireus.
Semantic Mediation & OWS 8 Glenn Guempel 703-648-4541.

Semantic Mediation & OWS 8 Glenn Guempel
University of Ljubljana 13 th November 2014 Outlines of Legal Informatics From Legal Text towards the Legal Document Friedrich LACHMAYER University of.

University of Ljubljana 13 th November 2014 Outlines of Legal Informatics From Legal Text towards the Legal Document Friedrich LACHMAYER University of.
Ministry of Transport, Information Technology and Communications Technological base: Interoperability Tsvetanka Kirilova Ministry of TITC Bulgaria.

Ministry of Transport, Information Technology and Communications Technological base: Interoperability Tsvetanka Kirilova Ministry of TITC Bulgaria.
Feed the Future Innovation Lab for Small-Scale Irrigation Alan Duncan Ethiopia Partner meeting, Mar 27 2015 From Plan to Action Field Studies and Ex Ante.

Feed the Future Innovation Lab for Small-Scale Irrigation Alan Duncan Ethiopia Partner meeting, Mar From Plan to Action Field Studies and Ex Ante.
Action planning work Wednesday Building upon plans (and gaps) from day 1 – What change (result)? – What activities (how) / sequencing are we proposing?

Action planning work Wednesday Building upon plans (and gaps) from day 1 – What change (result)? – What activities (how) / sequencing are we proposing?
Beyond Legal XML Günther Schefbeck 4th Workshop „Legislative XML“ Klagenfurt, 18 November 2005.

Beyond Legal XML Günther Schefbeck 4th Workshop „Legislative XML“ Klagenfurt, 18 November 2005.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google