Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byPiers Hancock Modified over 9 years ago
2
1.) Three-tiered state court system: trial, appellate, supreme (differences between trial courts and appellate courts) 2.) Three-tiered federal court system a.) approx. 100 Federal district courts b.) 13 Federal Circuit Courts of Appeal c.) US Supreme Court: exerts complete (& strict) control over its own docket ----writ of certiorari --in forma pauperis Brief digression: civil v. criminal cases
3
1.) The District Courts: tradition of “senatorial courtesy” 2.) Increasing politicization of judicial confirmations: committee delay and grilling, holds & filibusters 3.) Failed Supreme Court nominations ---Fortas, Carswell, Haynesworth rejected for corruption/competence reasons ---Robert Bork (Reagan appointee) the first to be rejected for explicitly ideological reasons (1987) ---Post-Bork nominations: Clarence Thomas (1991), Sonia Sotomayor (2009), Roberts & Alito What factors make for a controversial nominee? Increased coaching and evasion of tough questions
4
1.) Act as referee between state and Federal governments (remember Federalism cases) 2.) Act as referee between Federal executive and legislative branches ---US v. Nixon (1974); Truman & the steel mills; line-item veto case 3.) Act as referee between Federal and state govts. and individual citizens (remember all those civil lib. Cases!)
5
Power to strike down state laws: implied in supremacy clause Power to strike down federal laws: where does it come from? The strange case of Marbury v. Madison (1803) Trends in overturning Federal laws judicial activism v. judicial restraint
6
1.) The “Discuss List” and the Rule of Four ---when to grant cert? exceptions: “defensive denials” and “aggressive affirmations” 2.) Oral argument 3.) The vote ---What influences SC justices’ votes? a.) precedent? (stare decisis) b.) ideology (the attitudinal model)? c.) the Solicitor General? d.) amicus curiae briefs?
7
Assigning the writing of the opinion Dissenting opinions Concurring opinions Explaining the decline in consensual norms
Similar presentations
© 2025 SlidePlayer.com. Inc.
All rights reserved.