1. doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/0795r2 Submission July 2014 The China NB contributed a variation on the “usual comment” on IEEE 802.22 China NB comment on 802.22 In addition, China NB also has concerns that the ongoing FDIS processes are reducing the quality and reputation of ISO/IEC standards. We will bring our concerns to the attention of ISO/IEC central offices. Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 1

2. doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/0795r2 Submission July 2014 The SC agreed in May 2014 on a response to the China NB comment on IEEE 802.22 Response (part 1/3) IEEE 802 thanks the China NB for its comment during the 60 day ballot on IEEE 802.22 as part of its consideration according to the PSDO agreement In the comment, the China NB objected to IEEE 802.22 using a security mechanism based on the use of ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802-1X because the China NB believes its comments in the previous FDIS ballot on ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802-1X have not been satisfactorily resolved It is up to the China NB to determine whether their comments on previous FDIS ballots have been satisfactorily resolved or not. However, we note IEEE 802 has responded fully to every comment received from all ISO/IEC SC6 and JTC1 NBs during all 60 day and FDIS ballots undertaken as part of the PSDO defined process Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 2

3. doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/0795r2 Submission July 2014 The SC agreed in May 2014 on a response to the China NB comment on IEEE 802.22 Response (part 2/3) IEEE 802 does not know of any outstanding issues related to ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802-1X, and notes that this standard is being successfully implemented globally today in billions of devices. IEEE 802 encourages any users of the standard, including China NB security experts, to provide further details of any issues related to ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802-1X at any time This can be done by e-mail or at a face to face meeting of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group. The IEEE 802.1 Working Group meeting schedule is available from the IEEE 802.1 Working Group Chair (Glenn Parsons, glenn.parsons@ericsson.com) Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 3

4. doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/0795r2 Submission July 2014 The SC agreed in May 2014 on a response to the China NB comment on IEEE 802.22 Response (part 3/3) In the comment, the China NB also asserted that the quality and reputation of ISO/IEC standards have been diminished by the use of PSDO defined approval processes No evidence has been provided to justify this assertion, so it is difficult for IEEE 802 to respond in any meaningful way. However, IEEE 802 notes the PSDO agreement between IEEE and ISO has given ISO/IEC JTC1 NBs, as important stakeholders of the widely implemented and used ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802 series of standards, an effective mechanism for both review and approval. IEEE 802 believes the PSDO process has been very effective and encourages all NBs to make greater use of the opportunity to participate in the development and approval of the ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802 series of standards Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 4

5. doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/0795r2 Submission July 2014 IEEE 802.22 WG needs to ask SC6 to allocate revision responsibility for IEEE 802.22 IEEE 802.1/3/11 standards are being liaised to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 for ratification under the PSDO based on an agreement by SC6 that the relevant IEEE 802 WG has responsibility for the revision process The agreement by SC6 is based on the existence of an established mechanism for NBs to contribute to the revision process in the IEEE 802 WG –This process is documented in N15606 The agreement was ratified by resolutions in SC6 in relation to each of IEEE 802.1/3/11 IEEE 802.11 WG needs to ask for a similar agreement in relation to IEEE 802.22 Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 5

6. doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/0795r2 Submission July 2014 A liaison is required to ask SC6 for revision responsibility for 802.22 Proposed liaison to SC6 (part 1/2) The IEEE 802.22 Working Group is currently making use of the PSDO agreement between ISO and IEEE to enable ISO/IEC JTC1 NBs to review and ratify IEEE 802.22 standards as ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802-22 standards The IEEE 802.22 Working Group is using the same processes as those being used to enable the review and ratification the ISO/IEC/IEEE 802- 1/3/11 series of standards, including those processes specified in 6N15606 ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 has made the use of those processes the basis of resolutions within SC6 to allocate responsibility for the revision process of the ISO/IEC 8802-1/3/11 series of standards to the relevant IEEE 802 Working Group Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 6

7. doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/0795r2 Submission July 2014 A liaison is required to ask SC6 for revision responsibility for 802.22 Proposed liaison to SC6 (part 1/2) The IEEE 802.22 Working Group requests that SC6 adopts the following similar resolution with respect to the ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802-22 series of standards –As empowered by clause A1.2.1 of the PSDO agreement between ISO and IEEE, SC 6 decides to allocate responsibility for the revision process of the ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802-22 series of standards to the IEEE 802.22 Working Group while the IEEE 802.22 Working Group has an ongoing revision process for the IEEE 802.22 standard. A condition of this resolution is that SC 6 and its NBs have access to an established mechanism to contribute to the revision process in the IEEE 802.22 Working Group. Note that this proposed resolution is in the same form as Resolutions 6.1.9/10/11 that were approved in September 2012 at the ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 6 plenary meeting in Gratkorn/Graz, Austria Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 7

8. doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/0795r2 Submission July 2014 The SC will consider a recommendation to the IEEE 802.22 WG and IEEE 802 EC for a SC6 liaison Motion The IEEE 802 JTC1 SC recommends to the IEEE 802.22 WG and the IEEE 802 EC that a liaison, based on slides 44-45, be sent to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 asking that they allocate responsibility for the revision process of the ISO/IEC/IEEE 8802-22 series of standards to the IEEE 802.22 WG Moved Seconded Result Andrew Myles, CiscoSlide 8