1. Copernicus Gesellschaft © Copernicus Gesellschaft The Two-Stage Publication Process for Journals published by Copernicus Gesellschaft Foster scientific discussion, Enhance effectiveness & transparency of scientific quality control July 2005

2. Copernicus Gesellschaft © Copernicus Gesellschaft First publication as open access discussion paper Open accessible comments of referees, authors & the scientific community Second publication as peer-reviewed final revised paper The innovative Two-Stage Publication Process

3. Copernicus Gesellschaft © Copernicus Gesellschaft Author 1 1. Submission Editor Referees 2 2. Access Review 3 3. Technical Corrections Discussion Paper 4 4. Publication as Discussion Paper 5 5. Comments Referee Comments Scientific Community Short Comments 5 5. Comments Author Author Comments 1 st Stage (Discussion Forum) 5 5. Comments 6 6. Revision 7 7. Submission as Revised Paper Editor 8 8. Peer-Review 9 9. Final Publication Final Revised Paper 2 nd Stage (Journal)

4. Copernicus Gesellschaft © Copernicus Gesellschaft Foster scientific discussions Enhance effectiveness & transparency of scientific quality control Enable rapid publication Advantages of the Two-Stage Publication Process