1. 2010 ASCCC Curriculum Institute Santa Clara Marriott July 8-10, 2010 Cul de Sac? PROGRAM REDUCTION AND DISCONTINUANCE Julie Bruno, Sierra College Sidney Burks, Chaffey College Lesley Kawaguchi, Santa Monica College

2. Participant Learning Outcomes After attending this session, participants should be able to: – Distinguish between Program Review and Program Discontinance – Explain the principles and key components of a Program Discontinance Policy – Develop a principled Program Discontinance Policy

3. A PRINCIPLED VIEW AND THE ROLE OF THE CURRICULUM COMMITTEE

4. DEFINING PROGRAMS Title 5 §55000(g): An educational program is “an organized sequence of courses leading to a defined objective, a degree, a certificate, a diploma, a license, or transfer to another institution of higher learning.”

5. TITLE 5 §51022 Requires California community colleges to have policies for the establishment, modification, or discontinuance of courses or programs

6. TITLE 5 §78016 Requires that districts form advisory committees for vocational education [career technical education] programs.

7. Education Code Section 78016 Requires that occupational programs undergo a review every two years

8. EXAMINING PROGRAMS: PROCESSES 1. PROGRAM REVIEW: – Self Study: What the program is doing well The resources needed to improve, including the use of Student Learning Outcome assessment results to highlight needs – Opportunity to show program quality and success – Opportunity to build a plan of correction – The emphasis is on improvement

9. PROCESSES, continued 2. PROGRAM VIABILITY PROCESS: – EXAMPLE: Los Angeles Pierce College – See http://www.asccc.org/Events/Curriculum/2009/ Curric2009.htm http://www.asccc.org/Events/Curriculum/2009/ Curric2009.htm Two handouts under “Natural Lifecycle of a Program”

10. PROCESSES, continued 3. Program Vitality/Discontinuance Policy

11. PRINCIPLES TO CONSIDER ASCCC POSITION: – Discontinuance policy is “distinct” from program review – Include collective bargaining representative(s). – Focus on saving or improving a program – Local senate should take lead and process should be collegial – Curriculum should reflect the missions of the community colleges

12. GETTING A POLICY Curriculum Committee role

13. ELEMENTS TO CONSIDER

14. KEY COMPONENTS OF A PROGRAM DISCONTINUANCE POLICY WARNING: Do not write a policy during the current budget climate!

15. POLICY PURPOSE: Needs to be clearly stated

16. INDICATORS What conditions or events “trigger” a vitality or discontinuance review are identified, such as – Significant decline in enrollment – Significant facility and/or equipment issues – Availability of qualified faculty – Failure to meet state mandates or accreditation standards – Significant changes in the labor market – Program no longer supports existing fulltime faculty

17. CONSIDERATIONS Accreditation Standard II.A.6.b: – “When programs are eliminated or program requirements are significantly changed, the institution makes appropriate arrangements so that enrolled students may complete their education in a timely manner with a minimum of disruption.”

18. CONSIDERATIONS: Impact on students Impact on faculty Impact on community Impact on local/regional employers Keep in mind: Curriculum and the multiple CCC missions

19. DEFINE THE PROCESS Who initiates the process? What are the steps? Who has the input? Is there a timeline? What data do you need? How is the final decision made? How is shared governance addressed?

20. QUESTIONS?

21. Thank you! Please fill out the evaluation form!