1. Optical Control Plane Standardization - OIF / IETF / ITU Lyndon Ong, Director, Network Control Architecture Ciena Corporation Lyong@ciena.com

2. Agenda  What is the OIF NNI?  Where does it fit within GMPLS, ASON, etc.?  What do we learn from the NNI Demo?  Where does it go from here?

3. NNI Goals  Assumptions Carriers’ networks have multiple domains Multi-vendor or multi-technology networks Administrative/management controls Different choices for intra-domain protocol An Inter-Domain interface is needed – the NNI  Goals of the NNI Demo Demonstrate NNI Concepts Domain Interoperability Domain abstraction/isolation Hierarchy Implement pre-standard NNI protocols

4. NNI Demo Network Routing Controller NNIUNI Abstracted Topology Actual Topology

5. Relationship with GMPLS  GMPLS – Generalized MultiProtocol Label Switching A set of IETF standards for Sub-IP Control Plane Signaling: RSVP-TE and CR-LDP Routing: OSPF-TE and ISIS Link Management  Current limitations Restricted to single routing area – limited scope Limited support of hierarchy or abstraction  Future Multi-area extensions

6. Relationship with ASON  ASON – Automatic Switched Optical Networks A set of ITU-T standards for Optical control plane G.8080 ASON architecture G.7712, 7713, 7714, 7715 ASON requirements G.7713.1/2/3 and G.7714.1 protocol specs  Top-down design Carrier-based requirements Multi-domain model  Alignment with NNI Signaling aligned Routing tbd

7. What we can learn  What can be done practically now? RSVP-based NNI signaling OSPF-TE (or ISIS)-based NNI routing  What needs to be done? Multi-level hierarchy Domain support (redundancy, abstraction) Call identifier/end-to-end capabilities  Where are there potential interoperability issues? Provisioning of control plane addresses/identifiers Interpretation of end-to-end objects (e.g., ERO) Etc.

8. Where do we go from here?  The NNI Demo provides a proof-of-concept Protocol extensions to meet carrier needs Implementation of GMPLS/ASON across domains Software that can evolve to NNI standards “Running code”  Target outputs “Observations from the Demo” documentation Feedback into IETF and ITU-T standards work  Standards-based OIF NNI Interoperability Agreement(s)