1. Project 14361: Engineering Applications Lab

2. Introductions TEAM MEMBERS Jennifer LeoneProject Leader Larry HoffmanElectrical Engineer Angel HerreraElectrical Engineer Thomas GomesElectrical Engineer Henry AlmironMechanical Engineer Saleh ZeidanMechanical Engineer Dirk ThurMechanical Engineer

3. Agenda Background Open Items from Last Review Problem Statement Customer Requirements Engineering Requirements Systems Design Concept Development Engineering Analysis Risk Assessment

4. Open Items From Last Review Refine Risk Assessment Develop modules on experimental and analytical levels

5. Problem Statement & Deliverables Current State Students in the Mechanical Engineering department currently take a sequence of experimental courses, one of which is MECE – 301 Engineering Applications Lab. Desired State Three to four modules used to provide a set of advanced investigative scenarios that will be simulated by theoretical and/or computational methods. Project Goals Create modules to instruct engineering students Expose students to unfamiliar engineering ideas Constraints Stay within budget

6. Customers & Stakeholders Professor John Wellin Contact: jdweme@rit.edu Professor Ed Hanzlik Contact: echeee@rit.edu Engineering Professors and Faculty Engineering Students MSD Team

7. Customer Requirements Requests 3 modules at minimum; 4 or 5 are preferred Modules may be of different technical challenge and complexity All modules must emphasize practical engineering experiences Each module should be interesting to the students Modules should bridge applications areas, such as electromechanical or electrochemical All modules should use commercially-off-the-shelf equipment to enable maintenance and sustainability of module use over many semesters of student enjoyment All module should have analysis challenges that are at or beyond student learning from core coursework

8. Customer Requirements Continued All modules should be able to: Fully configured, utilized, and returned by student engineers Stand alone; contain everything they need without borrowing from other sources Have a high level of flexibility and expansion allowing for many engineering opportunities Be robust and safe

9. Engineering Requirements NEED # AFFINITY GROUP NAME IMPORTANCE CUSTOMER OBJECIVE DESCRIPTIONMEASURE OF AFFECTIVENESS CN1 Key Engineering Principals 9 Modules may be of different technical challenges Bloom's Taxonomy of Learning CN2 9 All modules must emphasize practical engineering experiences. Survey Professors regarding modules to ensure they have a practical application to students future careers CN3 3 All modules should bridge application areas, such as electromechanical If modules branch into multiple disciplines CN4 9 All modules should have analysis challenges that are at or beyond student learning from core course work. Form a test group to determine the complexity of the modules CN6 Implementation of Labs 9 Customer request 3 modules at a minimum; 4 or 5 are preferred. n/a CN7 1 All modules should be interesting to the students. MSD team interest CN8 3 Can be run by 1 student but can be up to 3- 4 students -Determine number of tasks and complexity required for each module -Personal experience from MSDI Team will be considered CN9 1 Modules can use commercially-off-the-shelf equipment to enable maintenance and sustainability of module use over many semesters of student enjoyment. Research and define what can be built by the MSDI Team verses what can be bought out of the total number of parts required for the module CN10 3 All modules should be stand alone; they should contain everything they need without borrowing from other sources. Test modules in lab setting CN11 3 All modules must be robust and safe.Conduct testing on equipment and modules CN12 3 All modules should able to be fully configured, utilized, and returned by student engineers. Conduct testing on equipment and modules CN13 3 Design and build an experimental apparatus equipped with appropriate measurement tools Define measurement tools required for each module- (1) hardware (ie- controller boards, motors...) (2) Software (labview, matlab, transducer specific programs)

10. Functional Decomposition 2/12/14

11. Criteria For Modules CriteriaMeasureMeasurableGradeNotes Complexity Include extension of core courses with some knowledge from unavailable classes Include non-required Course Information along with core course information 1- Core course 2- Core Course Plus 3- Elective 4- Beyond Capability, outside learning Level 4 More than acceptable, information can added Lab Skills Students must be able to set-up an experiment and measuring instruments 1- Results Dependent on Skill (Time consuming for inexperience) 2- Skill has an noticeable affect on outcome of results 3- No skill is needed to get results (set ups are preset) 4- Skills have minimum affects on outcome of results (Time for set up is minimal) Offer multiple configurations of module Variables 1- One Variable 2- 2-3 variables 3- 4-5 variable 4- combinational variables Moved to complexity Depth of Analysis required for module Depth of analysis required duration Safety Complies with safety regulations Complies with safety regulation Reduce Risk of InjurySeverity 1- Requires Supervision 2- needs special knowledge of operation 3- needs notification 4- simple working since needed

12. Criteria For Modules CriteriaMeasureMeasurableGradeNotes Interest A variety of topics are incorporated within the module Use Google entry counts, video views, search amount Look at past application labs to see trends 1- 1,000 views not as interesting 2- 50,000 views interesting 3- 1 million views very interesting Module interesting to MSD Teamranked by relativity 1-Experience every day 2-Experience is known but not common 3- Related to regular day with minimal knowledge 4- Related and captivating to student subject is relevant Exposure to an unfamiliar idea or topic not completely covered in core ME classes Budget Cost to make module must be reasonable/ Within Budget Constraints Contains Reusable PartsOf the shelf Parts 1-Needs all custom parts with a heavy price tag 2- Need minimal custom parts 3- Most parts are off the shelf, some custom parts 4- All parts are off the shelf, affordable/reasonable custom partsIn house Manufactured Time Module can be completed with 3-5 weeks Time needs to be split into two, analytical and experimental. Experimental can't be ran for 4-5 hours.

13. Rail Gun Windmill Leiden Frost Effect Mass Spring System Electrical Cooling System Analogous Behavior Speakers Solar Panels Roller Coaster Helicopter MR Fluid Bridge (Lack of complexity) Hydrogen Engine (safety reasons, complexity) Bike Pump (Lack of complexity) Submarine (Lack of complexity) Inverted Pendulum (complexity, variability) Module Concepts Considered:

14. Concepts Considered NumberIdea TitleME Theoretical conceptsAnalytical Challenges Experimental Challenges / Execution of Modules 1Mass- Spring SystemDynamics Find the frequency and amplitude of the building vibration with and without mass dampeners 2Electrical Cooling System Thermo, Electrical Control Affects on heat flux to maintain specific temperature with different air speed, fin size/shape, material Maintain chip operating temperature under heavy loads 3Inverted PendulumDynamicsProgramming I.PBuilt I.P (Lego?) 4Sterling Engine Thermo Energy Conversion Thermal analysis of engine to find work outputted/ Efficiency Analyze output work and construct a P-V diagram 5PropellerFluid DynamicsAngle of attack and Thrust Measure the thrust of the propeller 6Draw Bridge Stress and Strain Structure, Statics and Fluid Stress/Strain AnalysisMeasure strain and fatigue 7SubmarineFluid Dynamics Affects of variable, Depth depending on fluid, materials Have the sub rise and dive to various depths

15. Electrical Cooling System Problem Statement: Thermo, Electrical Control Equations: What are we going to do? Experimental Challenges: Maintain chip operating temperature under heavy loads Analytical Challenges: Affects on heat flux to maintain specific temperature with different air speed, fin size/shape, material

16. Sterling Engine Problem Statement: Thermo Energy Conservation Equations: What are we going to do? Experimental Challenges: Analytical Challenges: Thermal analysis of engine to find work output and efficiency

17. Helicopter Problem Statement: Fluid Dynamics Equations: What are we going to do? Experimental Challenges: Analytical Challenges: Angle of attack and Thrust

18. Concepts Against Criteria Project ComplexitySafetyInterestBudgetTime Include extension of core courses with some knowledge from unavailable classes Lab Skills Offer multiple configurations of module Depth of Analysis required for module Complies with safety regulation s Reduce Risk of Injury A variety of topics are incorporat ed within the module Module interesting to MSD Team Exposure to an unfamiliar idea or topic not completely covered in core ME classes Cost to make module must be reasonable/ Within Budget Constraints Contains Reusable Parts Module can be completed with 3-5 weeks Mass- Spring System xxx xx x Electrical Cooling System xxx xx x Inverted Pendulum xxx xx x Sterling Engine xxx xx x Helicopter xxx xx x Draw Bridge xxx xx x Submarine x xx xx x Windmill xxxxxx Leiden Frost Effect xxxxxx Analogous Behavior xxxxxx Speakers xxxxxx Solar Panels xxxxxx MR Fluid xxxxxx Hydrogen Engine xxxxxx Bike Pump xxxxxx

19. Risk Assessment IDRisk ItemCauseEffect Likelihood Severit y Importanc e Action of Management OwnerModule 1Complexity of Modules To hard/ to simple Students fail to learn 224 Refer to customer expertise to ensure proper complexity Team P14361 2Injury to student Human error Death, severe injury, emotional trauma or dismemberme nt 133 In-depth Risk assessment/a nalysis once modules are chosen Project leader Rail Gun Solar Panel Leiden Frost Effect 3Damage to property Misuse of modules Damage to property 122 In-depth Risk assessment/a nalysis once modules are chosen Mechanical Engineer Solar Panel HR Fluid 4Late parts Failure to check lead times Missed deadlines 224 Establish order deadline Team P14361 5Budgeting Over/Under spending Run out or lose funds 111 Budget accordingly Team P14361 6Scheduling Conflicts 7 people with different schedules Can’t get team together to work on tasks 224 Communicati on with Team members and guide Team P14361 7Module Requirement s Module too large, requires high voltage Module will not be able to be used, can not fit in lab 111 Additional locations will be looked at, best fit for module Team P14361

20. Project Plan (WK 10-12) Update all Action Items Add all documents to EDGE Arrange Meeting with Facility to review DDR Test Subsystems Continue detailed design Continual improvement of Risk Assessment Review designs with customers

21. Questions?