1. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

2. + CD Capability Framework = ???
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

3. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed are those of the presenter and should not be considered as official policy of the CCD COE or NATO
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

4. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
Agenda
Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence
CD Capability Framework
CCD COE + CD CF = ???
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

5. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
CCD COE + CD CF = ???
CCD COE =
= Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

6. The Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence Is
A multinationally manned and sponsored entity currently comprised of 8 Sponsoring Nations
Germany, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovak Republic, Spain and Estonia
joining process with: Turkey, USA
Accredited as the NATO COE (Oct 28th 2008)
Directed and tasked by a Multinational Steering Committee of those 8 Sponsoring Nations + Turkey + NATO ACT
Actively receives additional NATO requests via Supreme Allied Command of Transformation
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

7. Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence is Not
Part of NATO Command or Force Structure
Funded from NATO Common budget
24/7 NATO Operational Incident Handling Center nor Multinational Computer Emergency Response Team working on behalf of Sponsoring Nations
Group of hackers or “Cyber Warriors”
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

8. Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence – CCD COE
Mission and Vision
Mission: to enhance the cooperative cyber defence
capability of NATO.
Vision: to become a primary source of expertise for NATO
in cooperative cyber defence-related matters.
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

9. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
Main Functions
Input to doctrine and concepts in the field of cyber defence
Cyber defence related analysis, education, awareness and training
Research and development projects in the field of cyber defence
Cyber defence related analysis and lessons learned
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

10. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
Organization
Director
Chief of Staff
Administration
Training
and
Doctrine
Research
Development
(VNC)
Legal
Policy
MIL
Any
Admin
TUR
Sec
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

11. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
Relationships
Steering
Committee
NATO entities
HQ SACT
NATO CDMA
- NCIRC
- NC3A
NATO COE-s
COE-DAT
C2 COE
Nations
NATO
Non-NATO
Other entities
Universities
Private sector
Customers
NATO
Sponsoring Nations
Contributing Participants
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

12. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
CCD COE + CD CF = ???
CD CF =
= CD Capability Framework
NATO RTO IST 096 (J. Sidoran)
NC3A
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

13. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
"Cyber Defence Capability Breakdown" - borrowed from the original NC3A's document
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

14. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
Topics for which CCDCOE has developed (mainly within its research and development activities) a good knowledge or is going to develop (immediate future) (by LtCol M de Falco)
NC3A's CD Capability Framework breakdown reference CCDCOE POW reference
Project(s) SME/engaged
1 Sensor data collection CD Monitoring Solutions Risto Vaarandi
2 Sensor data normalization CD Monitoring Solutions Risto Vaarandi
3 Sensor data collection CD Monitoring Solutions Risto Vaarandi
4 Interpret. context Intelligent Cyber Defence Methods Peeter Lorents
Dynamic risk assessment Security Methodologies Jüri Kivimaa
6 Visualization for situational awareness NoE - CD-SAFE (Cyber Defense For Europe)
(FP7-funded project) Marco De Falco (et al., .B.D.)
Timely decision making Intelligent Cyber Defence Methods (Decision Support systems)
Peeter Lorents,
Enn Tõugu, Pavel Grigorenko
8 Situation assessment Intelligent Cyber Defence Methods
9 Collection *…+ of historical data CD Monitoring Solutions Risto Vaarandi
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

15. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
CCD COE + CD CF = ???
??? = !!!
! = Collaboration
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch

16. Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch
One thing more:
ICCC 2011
International Conference on Cyber Conflicts June 8 – 10, 2011, Tallinn, Estonia
Professor Peeter Lorents, CCD COE Chief of the R&D Branch