1. Compatibility Review System 3.0 Robert Freimuth October 28, 2008 Overview

2. CRS Project Teams Developer Rakesh Nagarajan Washington University St. Louis, MO Persistent Systems Pune, India Preeti Lodha Yogesh Shetty Poornima Govindrao … and many others Co-Developer Robert Freimuth Mike Schauer Mayo Clinic Rochester, MN

3. Compatibility Review System Introduction to the CRS Review of Supported Workflows Overview of New Functionality Future Enhancements Use Cases for Semantic Infrastructure

4. Compatibility Review Process Scope of the CRS

5. Overview of the CRS Web-based system Goals of the CRS Centralize information for the review Submission package Data from the caDSR (CDEs) and UML model Increase the efficiency of Compatibility Reviews Gathering documentation Streamlining communication Reduce administrative overhead Managing the review Gathering and integrating comments Formatting and color-coding the reports Workflows UML loading VCDE review Architecture review

6. Main Features of CRS 1.0 Features in CRS 1.0/1.1 Administration User and account management Workspace management Checklist management Submission package management Workflows Requesting a review (submission package creation) Review project creation and assignment VCDE review Reports Overview report Detail report

7. Main Features of CRS 2.0 Features added in CRS 2.0/2.1 Checklists Checklist grouping Granularity associated with every checklist item Workflows Architecture review workflow UML Loading workflow (pre-review) Review Page Checklist items are displayed based on their granularity Streamlined UI File Handling and Reports Upload/Download files Download of submission package as zip Report generation at any point during the review Bug fixes for CRS 1.1

8. Main Features of CRS 3.0 Enhanced UI Menu layout More information "at your fingertips" during a review Support for wide or multiple monitors Redesign of the submission package module UML loading Review Post-review UML loading workflow Reports Detail (includes more information) Individual reviewer CDE reuse (independent of review) XMI comparison Support for additional browsers caCORE 4.0 API (CRS 3.1 patch)

9. Compatibility Review System Introduction to the CRS Review of Supported Workflows Overview of New Functionality Future Enhancements Use Cases for Semantic Infrastructure

10. UML Loading Workflow Fill Out Loading Form Submit Form and XMI Load Model Create Round-Trip XMI Make Changes to Model Submit Revised XMI Load Model Create Round-Trip XMI Compatibility Review Changes Require Reloading ? No Yes Curate on caDSR See Review Workflow Developer caDSR Team CRS Administrator Workspace Lead Review Project Lead VCDE Lead Reviewer VCDE Reviewer Arch Lead Reviewer Arch Reviewer CRS Roles

11. Review Workflow Submission Package Submissi on Package OK? Request More Information Review Submission Package No Yes Choose Checklist, Global Checkoff, Review Schedule Assign Tasks Submissi on Package OK? Request More Information Review Submission Package No Yes Choose Checklist, Global Checkoff, Review Schedule Assign Tasks Perform Review All Review s Comple te? Generate Draft Reports Create Final Reports Upload Final Reports Perform Review No Yes Developer caDSR Team CRS Administrator Workspace Lead Review Project Lead VCDE Lead Reviewer VCDE Reviewer Arch Lead Reviewer Arch Reviewer CRS Roles

12. Compatibility Review System Introduction to the CRS Review of Supported Workflows Overview of New Functionality Future Enhancements Use Cases for Semantic Infrastructure

13. Home Page New UI and Browser Support

14. Dashboard

15. Review Page Element Tree Content Tabs (not split screen)

16. Review Page Assigned/Unassigned Elements

17. Review Page Element Detail

18. Review Page Java Docs

19. Review Page Checklist Items

20. Review Page Submission Package

21. Review Page CDE Reuse

22. CDE Reuse Search Results Page

23. Review Page Element Detail

24. Review Page New Windows for Data

25. Review Page Checklist Completion

26. Review Page Adding Comments

27. Individual Reviewer Report

28. XMI Comparison Report

29. Class Attributes Associations

30. XMI Comparison Report Change in Model Difference in Role Name

31. XMI Comparison Report Addition/Deletion

32. Compatibility Review System Introduction to the CRS Review of Supported Workflows Overview of New Functionality Future Enhancements Use Cases for Semantic Infrastructure

33. Future Development Administrative Status reports Reminders Searchable review archive Team assignment pre-submission More robust loading process Review Search function and index for review elements View/comment on unassigned elements Improved visualization of model during review SIW errors displayed during review Automated Correspondence Checks UML model = XMI = caDSR = API = API docs = XML schema

34. Future Development Workflows Mentoring Gold level reviews Vocabulary reviews Report generation UML-CDE combined report VD report (including enumerated values) PV reuse report (exact/super/sub set of another VD?) PV source and code validity report IM reuse report Scalability Increased demand for compatibility reviews non-caBIG projects (e.g., CTSA)?

35. Compatibility Review System Introduction to the CRS Review of Supported Workflows Overview of New Functionality Future Enhancements Use Cases for Semantic Infrastructure

36. Infrastructure Needs Everything that has been mentioned to support compatibility reviews See previous presentations, especially Gold Compatibility and GridPIR Interface to the SIW error checking routines Export as XML Ability to annotate and register methods/interfaces Ability to link (web) to search results and individual records in the caDSR and EVS

37. Infrastructure Needs Need for more powerful ways to query metadata Identify similar or related CDEs Same set of concepts, different order Related concepts, explicit relationships Related concepts, implicit relationships Applications Silver level reviews Gold level reviews Model development and harmonization CDE harmonization others… SemDEQ

38. Shameless Plugs Vocabulary Knowledge Center 9:00 am – 10:30 am tomorrow Northwestern Room 202

39. Shameless Plugs Vocabulary Knowledge Center 9:00 am – 10:30 am tomorrow Northwestern Room 202 CRS Breakout Session 11:00 am – 12:30 pm tomorrow Northwestern Room 202

40. Shameless Plugs Vocabulary Knowledge Center 9:00 am – 10:30 am tomorrow Northwestern Room 202 CRS Breakout Session 11:00 am – 12:30 pm tomorrow Northwestern Room 202 AMIA 2008 Annual Symposium caBIG Compatibility Review System: Software to Support the Evaluation of Applications Using Defined Interoperability Criteria November 10, 2008 Washington, D.C.