1. www.see-grid-sci.eu SEE-GRID-SCI Branko Marovic University of Belgrade branko@rcub.bg.ac.rs JRA1 progress PSC05 Meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11 September 2009 The SEE-GRID-SCI initiative is co-funded by the European Commission under the FP7 Research Infrastructures contract no. 211338

2. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.092 Deliverables Three JRA1 deliverables produced  DJRA1.1 - Grid application requirements and commonalities assessment  M06, 7 PM, UoB-RCUB, Editor: B.M.  DJRA1.2 - Application-specific monitoring and control tools design  M08, 12 PM, IPP, Editor: E.A.  DJRA1.3 - Application services design report  M12, 10 PM, UoB-RCUB, Editor: B.M.  DJRA1.4 - Application services implementation and deployment report  M22, 30 PM, UoB-RCUB, Editor: B.M.  DJRA1.5 - Assessment of operational tools developed  M23, JRA1 28,5 PM, ICI, Editor: A.S.

3. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.093 Milestones MJRA1.1 - Baseline analysis of operational tools  M03, IPP: wiki, informal report MJRA1.2 - Application commonalities assessed and areas of development identified  M06, UoB-RCUB: DJRA1.1 MJRA1.3 - Operational tools implemented and running  M16, IPP: wiki, informal report  5 in production, Logwatch-G and AMS in beta MJRA1.4 - Selected application services implemented and deployed  M24, UoB: DJRA1.3, demonstration at review

4. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.094 Ongoing Developments and Metrics (Y1->PSC05) 11 AS (7 major, 3 pre-existing as prototypes, 1 small effort with some initial interest)  Described in DJRA1.1 and DJRA1.3 7 OT  Described in DJRA1.2 Black: As in DoW Green: Achieved M0M12M16M24 MTJRA1.1 AS developed 0 / 3 preexisting 2 / 4 production + 4 alpha/beta6 + 56 MTJRA1.2 OT developed 0 / 02 / 4 production + 2 alpha5 + 24

5. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.095 Application Services (Y1->PSC05) NameStatusAvailability datePartners SEE-GRID File Management Java APIProduction/liveAvailableUOB Data Management Web Portal *Meteo VO demo Production/liveAvailableUOB Event LoggerProduction/stableOctober 08UOB Work BinderProduction/liveOctober 08UOB SDS (Seismic Data Server) Applications Service *Seismo VO demo BetaJanuary 09 ULAKBI M TUBITAK User Level Monitoring ToolBeta Since beginning of 09 Production version in second half of 09 UKIM Common Workflow Repository Extension of P- GRADE Portal Beta -> Production/stable (PSC05) May 09SZTAKI Environment oriented Satellite Data Processing Platform Alpha -> Beta (PSC05) 1. October 09 (Phase 1) 30. March 10 (Final) UTCN Mathematical Expressions Web Service Development -> Production/live (PSC05) June 09ETFBG Rendering Application Service Development -> Alpha (PSC05) July 09FGA Advanced-Workflow Development Tool and Orchestration Service Development -> Alpha (PSC05) September 09UKIM

6. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.096 Operational Tools (Y1->PSC05) NameStatusAvailability datePartners JTS, Job Track Service *Enviro VO demo Production/liveFebruary 09IPP-BAS/UKIM BBmSAM ExtensionsProduction/liveMarch 09UoBL Grid Site Software Vulnerability Analyzer Production/live -> Stable (PSC05) March 09SZTAKI No Mercy Trouble Ticketing System Production/liveMay 09ICI User/application specific grid infrastructure monitoring extension Alpha -> Stable (PSC05) Operational Release in July 09 SZTAKI Logwatch Plug-ins for Grid Services Development -> Beta (PSC05) September 09RBI Alert Messaging Service Development-> Beta (PSC05) September 09 UoB, IPP/UoBL/ICI

7. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.097 Access to JRA1 Developments http://wiki.egee-see.org/index.php/JRA1_Commonalities

8. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.098 Y1 review recommendations The reviewers make the following recommendations: DJRA1.5 due in M23, Assessment of Operational Tools Developed, should include a description of:  which tools have come from previous projects;  which tools have been enhanced in this project;  which tools are new;  how the tools compare with what has been developed elsewhere  which tools have been picked up and exploited by other communities/projects. In the second year of the project, the partners will need to place more emphasis on dissemination of the scientific outputs from the project.

9. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.099 Internal JRA1 Metrics Measure and compare the progress of AS & OT Current status (only one of offered values, maximum is 8 points):  1 - Planning - Conceptual description, possibly with initial functional specification, or architectural description  3 - Development - in progress, no working version available  5 - Alpha - working version exists, available only to developers  6 - Beta - working version exists, available to users  7 - Production/live - released, open to adding new features and bug-fixes  8 - Production/stable - released, developers still work on bug-fixes but it is closed for new features  7 - Production/closed - final version released, development closed  NaN - Abandoned/Inactive - project abandoned before being released to production Usage (additive for each named usage, but up to maximally 6 points):  2 – per each application currently using an application service (AS only)  1 - per each site having tool deployed (if applicable, OT only) or  1 - per each user (e.g. grid site administrator) using it in last 3 months (for OT only) Presentation (only one of offered values, maximum is 6 points):  0 - No presentation or outdated presentation  2 - Up-to-date brief presentation (based on JRA1 presentation template) available (not more than 3 months old)  4 - Up-to-date detailed presentation available (not more than 3 months old)  6 - Detailed presentation available with usage or performance analysis and live or recorded demo Visibility towards wider community (additive for each fulfilled indicator, but up to maximally 8 points)  1 - Software license defined and declared  1 - Introductory web site or Wiki with basic data and functional overview  2 - Architectural description available, online or within the corresponding JRA1-related project deliverable  2 – User documentation available (preferably online) fully covering typical usage, including deployment, if applicable  1 - Source code available publicly or to all eligible users (in accordance with license), e.g. via download.  1 - Source code repository with version control available publicly or to eligible users

10. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0910 Metrics issues PSC05 metrics  Transitive (indirect) usage by applications should be included as well as external  Usage limit moved to 8 (SDSAS, GSSVA and JTS were over 6)  Some missed to provide links Future  Should publications be added?  Automated installation? Fair to centralized OT – clients?

11. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0911 General ranking and status (OT + AS) DevelopmentPartnerScore Work BinderUOB25 JTSIPP-BAS24 Event LoggerUOB23 SDSASULAKBIM23 GSSVAMTA SZTAKI23 USGIMEMTA SZTAKI23 DM-WebUOB22 FM-J-APIUOB22 CWREMTA SZTAKI20 ESIP PlatformICI / UTCN20 MEWSRS-ETFBG16 NMTTICI16 AMSUOB13 ULMONUKIM12 BBmSAMeXUoBL12 RASRBI10 AWTUKIM9 Logwatch-GRBI9

12. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0912 Usage (OT + AS) ULMON and AMS must integrate with users quickly BBmSAMeX BBmSAMeX, NMTT, Logwatch should start using AMS DevelopmentPartnerUsage JTSIPP-BAS11 GSSVAMTA SZTAKI9 SDSASULAKBIM8 DM-WebUOB6 FM-J-APIUOB6 Event LoggerUOB6 Work BinderUOB6 ESIP PlatformICI / UTCN4 AWTUKIM2 CWREMTA SZTAKI2 USGIMEMTA SZTAKI2 Logwatch-GRBI2 RASRBI2 MEWSRS-ETFBG1 NMTTICI1 ULMONUKIM0 AMSUOB0 BBmSAMeXUoBL0

13. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0913 Presentation and end-user visibility (OT + AS) To many rely on standard brief presentations User documentation Only three publish data in a source repository

14. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0914 Dissemination and Plans Achieved so far  Early start through presentation of 3 VOs at EGEE’08 conference in Istanbul  4 developments present at EGEE UF4: ESIP Platform, SDSAS, Work Binder, ULMON  Dozen of published papers  Initial publishing of details and documentation of JRA1 developments Focus on  Improvement of existing documentation, installation and user documentation  Making both code and packaged (installable) software available  Start promotion of developments when they reach adequate level of maturity  Possible external verification: should advertise our software and collaborate with other related projects and user communities

15. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0915 Actions to be Taken 1 Source repos whenever possible  Developers are encouraged to use the EGEE-SEE/SEE-GRID-SCI SVN-Trac Repository  Cleared pending licensing issues (compatibility with used components) Usage by applications – commitment defined in DJRA1.1! New recommendations and guidelines  RPM based deployment, installers  Use of other development and maintenance support tools (build and publishing of build artefacts - Maven, continuous integration?) Installation packaging Architectural, installation and user documentation

16. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0916 Actions to be taken 2 Promotion, publication, dissemination! Target external communities!  Attempt to get additional users and stakeholders from outside the project involved  SEE-GRID-SCI UF  iSGTW - along with applications  Domain-related journals – e.g. Lizza-PAKP/Work Binder in Journal of Hydrology EGEE’09 Conference in Barcelona  Earth Science Application Development Methodology by ESIP and gProcess Platforms  A Service for Turning Alerts into Messages (AMS)  WatG Browser - Grid Information System Browser - non-JRA1  WMSMon - gLite WMS/LB Monitoring Tool - non-JRA1  We had 4 application services (SDSAS, Work Binder, ULMON, ESIP Platform) at 4th EGEE User Forum! Grid observatory (ULMON, GSSVA)  Select 2-3 SEE-GRID-SCI generic AS candidates with good metrics, hopefully two would end up endorsed? EGI equivalent of EGEE-II RESPECT program within EGI User Community Services (UCS). Info on UCS contacts and timeframe? To be exploited after the project!  Select 2-3 SEE-GRID-SCI generic AS candidates with good metrics, hopefully two would end up endorsed?

17. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0917 Existing APs 114JRA1AS (lesser extent OT) first round of publishing of documentation and/or Wiki materials. JRA1 contractors 11/19/20082/1/2009Closed8/1/2009 165JRA1Explicit specific source code licenses, especially for FLOSS JRA1 contractors 1/16/20092/15/2009Closed9/4/2009Based on DJRA1.3 contributions, solved by 9 out of 10, on 3.9.09 166JRA1Start using either EGEE-SEE/SEE-GRID-SCI or an internal repository JRA1 contractors 1/16/20093/15/2009Ongoing From DJRA1.3 contributions, only 2 out of 10 as reported on 3.9.09 215JRA1Final decision on presentation of OT at reviewBranko5/8/20095/22/2009Closed5/22/2009 216JRA1Provide up to date data for JRA1 metricsJRA1 contractors 5/8/20097/15/2009Closed9/10/2009 217JRA1Resolve licensing compatibility issues regarding licenses of components Boro, Anastas, Davor 5/8/20097/15/2009Closed8/31/2009AWT (GPL) uses gsoap (modified MPL) and ULMON(GPL) uses RabbitMQ (MPL) incompatible with GPL - should resolve; RAS (GPL) uses POV-Ray, the license of which does not allow partial derivative works, but POV-Ray 4 is likely to migrate to GPL 218JRA1Calculate and analyse JRA1 metricsBranko5/8/20098/15/2009Closed9/11/2009 219JRA1MJRA1.3 reportIPP - Emanouil 5/8/20099/1/2009Closed9/10/2009Wiki or informal report document 220JRA1All AS beyond development stage at Y1 to implement, describe and provide installation packaging JRA1 contractors 5/8/20099/15/2009Open

18. PSC05 meeting, Dubrovnik, 8-11.09.0918 New APs JRA1 wiki – add overview, publications, relationships with existing products (BMa, all) Update JRA1 wiki with new information already provided in metrics (not everybody did so) (all) Investigate possible collaborations with Grid Observatory (ULMON, GSSVA) Check possibilities for inclusion of 2-3 AS into RESPECT (ILi) Making the shared source repository available to the public (without certificates) with R/O access (ILi) Prepare abstracts for SEE-GRID-SCI UF (all) Add publications (scientific papers and articles) into metrics (BMa) Review alignment with DJRA1.1 commitments (BMa) PSC06 JRA1 metrics (All) NA4 AP on description of AS in detailed application descriptions